Why Africa has NFC-free mobile payments today, and we’re still waiting


Financial institutions are falling over themselves to introduce mobile payment services, but so far the results have been a bit underwhelming in most of the world. The industry seems to be waiting for near-field communication (NFC) solutions to become reality outside Japan, fulfilling a science fiction-ish notion that mobile phone users will just wave their phones near secured payment points to authorize transactions.

google-wallet-announcement-demonstration-american-eagleAlthough Google Wallet supports NFC payments, the technology suffers from the fundamental disadvantage that it leaves literally billions of cell phones behind: If users want to use NFC mobile payments, they’re going to have to get a new (likely high-end) phones, and they’ll only be able to use it with merchants who have upgraded to NFC-capable point-of-sale terminals from credit card companies. Right now, Google Wallet can use NFC, but only with Citibank Mastercards, a handful of NFC-capable sales terminals, and a single phone (the Nexus S 4G on Sprint). Some industry watchers don’t expect NFC to see serious adoption in the North American market until 2014 or 2015.

Similarly, solutions like Square Card Case rely on GPS and assisted GPS technology to detect when customers are physically close to participating merchants — that’s certainly novel, but it doesn’t help if you’re in an area with poor or no GPS reception or don’t feel like broadcasting to merchants that you’re nearby and shopping. Similarly, unlike well-established credit card companies, merchants have to actively enroll in Square, so it’s not yet something consumers can reasonably expect to use basically anywhere. While services like the Apple’s Apple Store app offer phone based payment and checkout, but they only work in specific retail locations: Try using the Apple Store app to pick up something and walk out of Best Buy, you might get arrested.

Gosh, what if there were a widely deployed mobile technology that can be used securely for mobile payments that was already on the vast majority of mobile phones around the world and was backed by a major credit card company?

Oh, wait! There is.

Visa launches mobile payments in emerging markets

Yesterday, Visa announced a new prepaid mobile payment service that enables users to send and and receive funds from each other, send and receive money internationally, make purchases at Visa merchants (in person or online), and even withdraw cash from Visa ATMs. That makes it already more capable than mobile payments solutions being slowly deployed in the United States. What’s more, it’s all done via mobile phones—and not fancy phones either, essentially any GSM handset will do the job. And here’s the clincher: Users don’t need credit cards or bank accounts.


Here’s how it works. The system is a prepaid service: When users sign up, they get a card verification number (CVV) and set up an identification number for an account tied to their mobile phone. Users can get money put into their account from any other user on the system, or by putting cash into their accounts via Visa ATMs (using their ID numbers and CVVs) or by bringing cash to an authorized agent of the service operator. Once they have money in their account, they can sent it to anyone else on the system, use it at any Visa point-of-sale, along with getting cash out of Visa ATMs. They can also use their accounts to make online purchases and send payments internationally.

The best part is that no special phones or SIM-swapping are required. The service works on essentially any GSM phone using a protocol called Unstructured Supplementary Service Data, or USSD. You can think of USSD as being a lot like text messaging: Messages are limited to 182 characters (including overhead for routing — about 160 characters are available for user data), and like SMS can be used while users are on the phone. However, unlike SMS (which is a delay-plagued store-and-forward service like email) current implementations of USSD are session-based, which means they maintain an open, real-time connection with remote servers. USSD may not be able to push through a lot of data at a time, but it does support interactive connections to mobile services — and, on nearly every provider, USSD isn’t billed separately like text messaging.

In developed markets, USSD is typically only used for things like checking account balances. However, in emerging markets it has been successfully used to roll out mobile payment services. Heck, there are Facebook and Twitter clients built on USSD too. Right now, there are more than 100 mobile payment services operating in developing nations (with nearly 100 more expected) that have served over 100 million people in the last ten years. Successful examples include M-Peda in Tanzania, SWAP Mobile in South Africa, mPay in Poland, and SharEpay in Cambodia.

Visa and Fundamo

Back in June, Visa bought a South African firm called Fundamo for about $110 million in cash — a relatively tiny acquisition for a firm of Visa’s size. At the time, the takeover didn’t generate much interest: Fundamo was a small mobile payments company in South Africa focused on bringing mobile payment solutions to developing markets. Although most global finance watchers agree emerging markets are underserved by traditional financial institutions, they don’t yet see developing market operations as central to those institutions’ future.

fundamo logoVisa is showing some signs of thinking differently. Essentially, Visa’s new payment services layers its own VisaNet services (including payment security, Visa’s vast network of merchants and ATMs, transaction processing, clearance and settlement services) on top of financial services offered by mobile network operators in developing countries. Visa’s new initiative provides a way to put many of those payment services under the Visa umbrella, enabling them to jump from serving a limited geographic area in (say) one market to offering a service that is literally recognized around the world.

Visa’s initial partner is MTN Mobile Money, which is already operating in a dozen countries and sports some 5.7 million users — the initial launch will be in Nigeria and Uganda. Visa says developing countries in Asia, Africa, and Latin America will be among the first target markets for the new service.

Why USSD mobile payments work in emerging markets

One of the reasons prepaid mobile payment solutions can work in emerging markets is that more people own mobile phones than have bank accounts. Where consumers in developed markets like North America and Europe typically have a selection of bank accounts (say checking and savings) and maybe some sort of online payment service (PayPal, Amazon, even Google Checkout), many consumers in developing nations don’t have any of that. Their per-capita income is far lower than their counterparts in developed nations, and in many cases banking infrastructure is too distant, unreliable, or simply non-existent. It doesn’t do you much good to put your money in a bank if you have to walk six hours both ways to do anything with it.

However, mobile phone ownership in developing nations is skyrocketing: In fact, that’s one of the primary reasons why the ownership of feature phones still outnumbers smartphones by about four to one worldwide. According to the International Telecommunication Union, by the end of 2010, about 90 percent of the world’s population lived within range of a mobile network and some 3.8 billion mobile subscriptions were expected to be active in the developing world. That represented nearly three quarters of all global mobile phone subscriptions.

Since mobile operators are handling subscription billing and prepaid accounts for all those billions of people anyway, many have worked out deals with local governments to offer basic financial services to subscribers. They’re typically not doing business as banks (nor are they subject to most banking regulations), but they are able to conduct transactions with and between customers via their mobile phones and maintain accounts on their behalf. They can also authorize agents to collect and disperse cash. The upshot is that, in developing nations, mobile commerce is one of the most common forms of “banking” available to people, and the process is being driven by mobile operators rather than banks.

In terms of sheer numbers, there’s little doubt those billions of mobile phone users will be a major driving force behind mobile financial services, money transfers, and mobile banking for the foreseeable future. Visa sees that huge pool of mobile-enabled users as an opportunity.

Why developed markets haven’t embraced USSD

It’s not true that no mature markets have adopted USSD as a mechanism for mobile payments: Poland’s mPay is a good example. However, a key distinguishing characteristic of developed economies is that banks and credit card companies are the gatekeepers for rolling out mobile payments solutions. And, for the most part, banks and credit card companies aren’t enamored of USSD.

One thing that gives credit card companies the heebee-jeebees is that USSD messages — like text messages — are sent in the clear, and the restrictions on message length and available bandwidth limit software-side encryption options. The radio transmissions between a mobile handset and cell site are encrypted, but the service is still subject to tampering, replay attacks, and similar fraud mechanisms. While USSD can be locked down reasonably well (using many of the same techniques used to secure Web sessions on smartphones) that incurs more overhead for developing, testing, and deploying mobile banking apps, and can significantly reduce the overall responsiveness of USSD-based apps.

Plus, there’s just not a lot of bandwidth available: USSD services uses two channels (FACCH and SDCCH) limited to about 140 bytes per second and 85 bytes per second, respectively. In other words, every USSD message can take over a second to transmit or receive, and during transmission and reception it actually reduces bandwidth for voice capabilities. So if you’re on the phone at the time, you might find voice quality goes down. While limited capabilities and simple interfaces might be a boon for the “unbanked” and “under-banked” in developing nations, financial institutions in developed markets understandably balk at offering only a time subset of services to their mobile customers — many of whom are experienced with sophisticated online banking services.


There’s also limited capacity for handling USSD on typical cell sites. Individual cell sites can support up to eight SDCCH channels, but many only support four. That means that eight simultaneous USSD sessions would use a single cell site’s capacity for USSD service. And remember, since USSD is session-based, those channels stay open even when no data is being transferred to and from handsets. Providers can set timeouts to drop connections if there is no activity, but in crowded places like shopping malls and sporting events, it’s easy to see how available USSD capacity could be consumed quickly. (There is some research (PDF) that purports to show this just doesn’t happen in every day use, however.) As mobile operators in developed markets have focused on rolling out 3G and 4G mobile broadband services, banks and credit card operators have focused on those higher-bandwidth channels for mobile payment technologies, which can support a full range of services, rather than the bandwidth-constrained world of USSD.

Another obstacle: Consumers in developed countries have generally shown limited adoption of prepaid services. Although pre-paid credit cards and phone service aren’t uncommon, consumers in banks’ and mobile operators’ most-coveted demographics prefer to keep all their money in their own accounts, authorizing payments for services on an ongoing or one-at-a-time basis. In many circles, there’s even a stigma associated with prepaid services, where they’re sometimes considered a sign that someone isn’t credit-worthy. These factors make Visa even less likely to try to bring its Fundamo-based solutions to the U.S. or other markets, at least as a mainstream mobile payments system.

Smaller but further ahead?

For consumers in developed countries — outside Japan, anyway — the sad truth is that having well-established financial institutions, credit card companies, and consumers that almost universally have bank accounts has turned into a hindering factor for developing mobile payment solutions. Countries and markets that don’t have that infrastructure (or anywhere near the same level of consumer spending) find themselves in the potentially enviable position of having working mobile payments solutions today that work on everyday inexpensive phones.

It’s one of the little ironies of the high-tech world.


Latest SMS breach could allow hackers access to your online accounts

A new security breach that exposed more than 26 million text messages could be a huge nightmare for users relying on two-factor authentication. Many of the SMS on the database contained security codes and account reset links.

No cash. No talking. What goes next? Welcome to your ‘app-tive’ digital life

Bank of America's 2018 Trends in Consumer Mobility Report found mobility has changed our lives. Mobile tech influences how most of us communicate, meet people, build relationships, and handle money as we move toward a cashless society.

The 100 best Android apps turn your phone into a jack-of-all-trades

Choosing which apps to download is tricky, especially given how enormous and cluttered the Google Play Store has become. We rounded up 100 of the best Android apps and divided them neatly, with each suited for a different occasion.

These 100 best iPhone apps will turn your phone into a jack-of-all-trades

The iPhone is the most popular smartphone in the world, and we want to bring out the best in yours. Behold our comprehensive list of the best iPhone apps, from time-saving productivity tools to fun apps you won’t be able to put down.

T-Mobile's new Revvl 2, Revvl 2 Plus are now available for purchase

Last year, T-Mobile launched its own line of branded smartphones. As a follow-up to their predecessors, the carrier has unveiled the Revvl 2 and Revvl 2 Plus -- complete with a sleeker design. Here's everything you need to know.

How to take great photos with the Pixel 3, the best camera phone around

You’ve scored yourself a new Google Pixel 3 or Pixel 3 XL, and you want to take advantage of that incredible camera. We’ve got everything you need to know right here about how to snap the best photos with your Pixel 3.

Google's Wear OS update 'H' promises battery life improvements

Google has rebranded its Android Wear operating system to Wear OS. Removing the Android name may help people better understand Google-powered smartwatches, which also play nice with iOS devices. 
Smart Home

Huawei could soon take on Google and Amazon with a new digital assistant

According to a report from CNBC, Huawei is working on a new digital assistant that could try to take on the likes of Google and Amazon's Alexa. Huawei already has a digital assistant in China, but the new one will be aimed at markets…

Leak shows a third, budget Google Pixel 3 with a Snapdragon 670, headphone jack

The Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL are considered to be two of the best Android smartphones, but it looks like Google could be prepping a third. A budget Pixel 3 device that boasts some of the best features of the other two has been leaked.

Use multiple phone numbers on one device with Verizon’s ‘My Numbers’ app

For those who have separate phone numbers and devices for your work and personal lives, Verizon wants to help you get more organized. With its new "My Numbers" app, you can use up to four additional phone numbers on a single smartphone.

Need a quick battery boost? Try one of our favorite portable chargers

Battery life still tops the polls when it comes to smartphone concerns. If it’s bugging you, then maybe it’s time to snag yourself a portable charger. Here are our picks of the best portable chargers.

Instagram tool accidentally exposes user passwords. Were you affected?

Instagram's Download Your Data tool accidentally exposed the passwords of a small number of users. Here is the explanation on what happened, and how to find out which Instagram accounts were compromised.

New iPad Pro’s durability in question after it fails YouTuber’s bend test

The new iPad Pro models failed a bend test that was carried out by popular YouTuber JerryRigEverything. The result raises questions about the durability of the tablets, especially since customers are also reporting bending issues.

How to use recovery mode to fix your Android phone or tablet

If you’re having a problem you can’t seem to resolve with your Android device, or maybe you want to update it or wipe the cache, recovery mode could be what you’re looking for. Here's how to use it.