Skip to main content

3 underrated shows on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in May 2024

Josh Brolin wearing a cowboy hat and looking at someone in a scene from Outer Range.
Amazon Studios

Hot off the heels of the sci-fi hit Fallout, which you probably finished in a single night or two, you might be looking for a new show to sink your teeth into. Amazon Prime Video has a wide selection beyond the most-talked-about hit shows, including some underrated series that you might not know about or haven’t considered watching.

Among the three underrated shows on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in May, one is a British miniseries that will give you Quentin Tarantino and Coen Brothers vibes, another is a neo-Western with a sci-fi twist, and the third is a Canadian comedy-drama based on a ranch that has been going strong now for 17 years. Learn more about each one and you might find that they’re right up your alley.

Recommended Videos

Boat Story (2023)

Boat Story | OFFICIAL trailer - BBC

Available to stream through Amazon Freevee, Boat Story gives Quentin Tarantino vibes on the small screen thanks to its genre-bending style and violent storyline. In the show, two strangers discover cocaine on a boat. But rather than turn it into the authorities, the pair, both down on their luck with nothing to lose, decide to sell it and split the funds. But a large cocaine shipment never goes missing without someone nefarious hot on its tail, as Janet (Daisy Haggard) and Samuel (Paterson Joseph) quickly realize.

Running from the police, dodging hitmen and gangsters, and desperate to get out of the harrowing situation, the unlikely duo meet gruesome, graphic, savage violence along the way. Boat Story beautifully weaves humor with the dark plot and heavy brutality, with fast-paced action through the short six-episode series.

Stream Boat Story on Amazon Prime Video.

Outer Range (2022-)

OUTER RANGE Trailer (2022)

Starring Josh Brolin, Lewis Pullman, and Imogen Poots, Outer Range hasn’t received the recognition it deserves for being a sci-fi-fueled neo-Western that uniquely blends the two genres. Described as Yellowstone meets Stranger Things, Brolin is Royal Abbott, a rancher in Wyoming desperate to keep his precious land in the family. Things take a strange turn, however, when a mysterious black void appears in his pasture alongside an equally puzzling drifter named Autumn (Poots).

Returning for a second season this month, Outer Range has gotten lost amid so many other high-profile shows on Amazon released over the last few years. But the twists and turns of the compelling plot and many subplots keep you invested. While fans who caught on early to Outer Range have had to wait a full two years for the second season, you can dive right in and binge the entire thing.

Stream Outer Range on Amazon Prime Video.

Heartland (2007-)

Heartland Season 17 Official Trailer

If you’re into shows with a soapy, country feel, Heartland is one of those long-running hidden gems you have either never heard of or glossed over but never thought to stop and check it out. The Canadian family comedy-drama has been airing since 2007 and follows two sisters residing on a family ranch in Alberta alongside their widowed grandfather, their father, and the hired farmhand.

A show about strong familial bonds, facing challenges, and navigating country life, Heartland is one of those mainstay shows that fans love to watch when there’s “nothing else on,” and new fans will appreciate for the same reason. While it has traditionally aired on CBC in Canada and The CW Plus and Up TV in the U.S., Heartland is now also available to stream on Prime Video. The latest season (its 17th!) premiered in October 2023.

Stream Heartland on Amazon Prime Video.

Christine Persaud
Christine has decades of experience in trade and consumer journalism. While she started her career writing exclusively about…
What’s new on Amazon Prime Video in March 2025
The cast of The Wheel of Time season 3.

Amazon Prime Video has a very annoying habit of being late with its list of library titles of classic TV shows and movies joining the library each month. For March, Prime Video has decided not to disclose its new library additions at all. We can only assume that new movies arrived on Prime Video at the start of March, but Amazon has left us all in the dark. The other major streamers share detailed breakdowns of their new films and TV series.

But as of March 4, Amazon has only shared the bare minimum of what's coming to Prime Video in March. To be fair, it's a good lineup. The fantasy series, The Wheel of Time, is premiering its third season on March 13, while the long-running Bosch franchise comes to a close with season 3 of Bosch: Legacy on March 27. To put it in perspective, Bosch was one of the first Prime Video original series in 2014! Ten seasons across two shows is a great run by any measure.

Read more
3 underrated movies on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in March 2025
Several workers with bags standing in a remote location looking scared in Severance.

What makes a movie underrated? It might be that critics have panned the film even though it has earned massive box office success and positive reception from audiences. Perhaps it’s the other way around, and critics love it, but audiences fail to see what’s so special. Some underrated movies are fantastic but simply didn’t get the attention they deserved and have slipped into the deep depths of streaming services, only to be unearthed by those who dare to find them.
The three underrated movies on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in March 2025 fall into varying categories that qualify the movies as underrated. One broke records, yet critics refuse to give it two thumbs up. Another shares its name with one of the hottest shows streaming right now.
Need more recommendations? Then check out the best new movies to stream this week, the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023)
The Super Mario Bros. Movie | Official Trailer

Even before it premiered, The Super Mario Bros. Movie was getting a lot of flak for the choice of Chris Pratt as the voice of the titular character. Following the debut of this adventure comedy film in theaters, critics still weren’t convinced that it was a hit. But The Super Mario Bros. Movie delighted fans and proved naysayers wrong.
The film explored an interesting dynamic whereby Bowser (Jack Black) was a softie with a deep love for Princess Peach (Anya Taylor-Joy). Of course, this brought us that lovely gem of a Peaches song that kids sang for weeks after. The movie's mixed reviews are no match for its tremendous box office success, not to mention the fact that it broke a Guinness World Record to become the highest-grossing movie based on a video game and became the first movie based on a video game to gross more than $1 billion. It’s incredible to learn that with all these huge numbers, The Super Mario Bros. Movie only has a 59% Rotten Tomatoes critics score.
Watch The Super Mario Bros. Movie on Amazon Prime Video. 
Severance (2006)
Severance (2006) Trailer | Danny Dyer | Laura Harris

Read more
Best new movies to stream on Netflix, Hulu, Prime Video, Max (HBO), and more
A man leans on a railing in Kraven the Hunter.

It's a bit of a weird week for our list of the best movies to stream on Netflix, Hulu, Prime Video, Max (HBO), and other services because several of the week's highlights are... well, famously bad? We do call it the best new movies, but we still make a point to include major releases when they arrive, even when they weren't exactly well-received upon release. People still want to see those movies for themselves, after all!

This week is highlighted (lowlighted?) by two of the biggest box office bombs of 2024, Better Man and Kraven the Hunter, plus Disney's underwhelming Moana 2, and a few more hopeful releases.
We also have guides to the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.

Read more