Skip to main content

Brave review: Lives up to the Pixar pedigree, but doesn’t exceed it

brave review
Image used with permission by copyright holder

If there is any movie studio in the business that has earned the benefit of the doubt, it’s Pixar. Again and again the studio has swung for the fences, and again and again it doesn’t just hit a homerun, but makes the ball explode as stunned fans drool over what they were witnessing. Pixar and Disney have enjoyed a fairly stunning string of successes, both commercially and critically. And because of that, Pixar may be its own worst enemy.

After years of setting the bar so high with movies like Up, WALL-E, and the Toy Story series to name a few, any Pixar film that doesn’t instantly become a classic is tinged with just a bit of disappointment. Naturally, that isn’t fair, but it is unavoidable. Just look at last year’s Cars 2. It wasn’t a bad movie, but neither was it anywhere near the same level as The Incredibles, Monsters Inc., or one of the several other groundbreaking films bearing the Pixar logo. It became the first Pixar film not nominated for any Academy Awards, and many critics called it a failure, even as it went on to earn well over half a billion dollars. Granted, a big box office haul doesn’t mark a great movie, but Cars 2 was at least decent. People just expect more from Pixar than decent.

BraveBrave won’t blow minds, but it will entertain, especially younger audiences, who will enjoy the fairy tale yarn. And adults will still find plenty to like in the humor and the tender mother-daughter relationship that lies at the heart of the film.

Princess Merida (voiced by Kelly Macdonald) is the daughter of the jovial King Fergus (Billy Connolly) and the loving, but controlling, Queen Elinor (Emma Thompson). Merida has been herded toward a predetermined destiny her entire life: wedding one of the sons of a local Lord. Despite rebellious tendencies that often put Merida at odds with a mother that constantly wants her to be more “ladylike,” Merida loves her deeply, even while fundamentally disagreeing with her about her fate.

On the eve of the decision on who she will marry, Merida runs away. Led on by Will O’ the Wisps who are said to lead people to their fates, Merida meets a witch who gives her a spell to use on her mother, allowing her to change her destiny. Naturally, it goes badly and the spell has unintended side effects that lead the Queen and the Princess to flee the castle and seek a way to undo what was done.

Brave-MeridaThe relationship between Merida and her mother lies at the heart of the film, and by extension Merida’s place in the world. It is a fairy tale, after all, and like most fairy tales there is a moral lesson at the core.

The moral of Brave will definitely resonate with children, even if most adults find it a bit obvious — not in a bad way, just a familiar one. There is no traditional “bad guy,” so to speak; instead the conflict comes through a series of circumstances.

Pixar has taken a great deal of effort to include 3D, and it works well, but retains the same inherent problem that all 3D movies face — it makes the picture darker. Generally you can overlook this, but the art and colors of Brave are so vibrant that the muted hues caused by the lenses of the glasses are almost a shame. It’s a tradeoff. The 3D technology is well used and it adds depth to the world, which is how the technology should be used. But skipping it won’t affect your enjoyment.

Merida with a Will O' the WispsThe same sharp sense of humor that permeates Pixar’s other films will keep adults happy through Brave, though the tenderness of the relationship often takes precedence over the jokes. It isn’t quite as laugh-out-loud funny as some of the previous offerings, but it is smart and entertaining, and  and the endearing artwork mixed with the best animated technology in the industry help to sell it.

Conclusion

Brave is not on par with some of Pixar’s more groundbreaking works, but it is still a good movie, packed with the smart humor you would expect from Pixar, and presented with animation that is always enjoyable to watch. The voice cast is also top notch, and there is real effort behind each of the actors’ performances.

Brave is the type of movie that will improve on the second viewing, after you shake the lofty expectations that Pixar fans will unavoidably carry in with them. It is far more predictable and traditional than most of Pixar’s other works, but the writing, dialog, and humor are still very good. Brave is a quality film, and will likely be another feather in Pixar’s crowded cap.

Editors' Recommendations

Ryan Fleming
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
Luca review: Pixar’s Italian sea monster story is sweeter than gelato
Luca and Alberto give a thumbs-up sign to their homemade Vespa scooter in a scene from Pixar's Luca.

Great storytelling can do more than trigger an emotional response. It can evoke powerful olfactory memories and tickle your senses in ways that bring the audience deeper inside the world in which the tale unfolds.

Therein lies the beauty of Luca, Pixar's animated feature about a pair of young sea monsters whose adventures on the coast of Italy are so thoroughly immersed in the sights and sounds of the region that its wonderful coming-of-age tale should come with an advisory: Best experienced with pasta.

Read more
Infinite review: Mark Wahlberg’s sci-fi adventure is a waste of good lives
infinite movie review mark wahlberg samurai sword

There's plenty of pedigree behind Infinite, the sci-fi thriller from Training Day director Antoine Fuqua that casts two-time Oscar nominee Mark Wahlberg as a diagnosed schizophrenic who discovers that his hallucinations are actually the memories and accumulated experiences of past lives.

The film pits Wahlberg's character against a similarly reincarnating -- but fully aware -- villain played by Oscar-nominated 12 Years A Slave star Chiwetel Ejiofor, and was produced by Lorenzo di Bonaventura, who famously shepherded both The Matrix and Transformers franchises to the screen. The movie's concept is also pretty slick, with two factions of characters who wield a wide array of abilities, expertise, and wealth gained from their past lives battling it out across the globe -- one trying to protect humanity while the other tries to end their infinite reincarnation by wiping out all life on Earth.

Read more
Gemini Man review: Stunning visuals can’t mask a weak story
gemini man review young will smith close up

On paper, Gemini Man is as close to a sure thing as Hollywood gets. It stars Will Smith in not one but two roles: An aging assassin and the assassin's young clone. It's directed by Ang Lee, who's won Best Director Oscars for both a visual effects extravaganza (Life of Pi) and an intimate character drama (Brokeback Mountain), and it's produced by blockbuster king Jerry Bruckheimer. To top it all off, it features next-level visual effects and a groundbreaking 120 frames-per-second picture that's unlike anything you've ever seen.

In all of those aspects, Gemini Man lives up to the hype. It's the film's script that simply isn't up to par. While the special effects and souped-up frame rate make Gemini Man a true spectacle, the film is plagued by poor dialogue, sloppy plotting, and thinly drawn supporting characters. Visually, it's a blast. In every other aspect, it's a missed opportunity.

Read more