Skip to main content

Woman jailed for failing to return rented VHS has one more reason to use Netflix

Once upon a time there were video stores where you could go and choose a movie on a VHS tape, pay a sum of money, and take it home to watch on your clunky VCR.

That’s what Pickens, SC resident Kayla Finley did one day in 2005, selecting the Jennifer Lopez/Jane Fonda romantic-comedy flop Monster-in-Law from her local Dalton Video store.

Recommended Videos

Either because it was so bad she was too embarrassed to walk back into the store with it, or perhaps because she simply forgot, Finley never returned the tape.

kayla finley
Finley was charged with “failure to return a rented video cassette.” Image used with permission by copyright holder

So imagine her surprise when last week she walked into a local cop shop to report an alleged crime and was promptly arrested for “failure to return a rented video cassette” and slung in the slammer for a night.

According to Fox Carolina, the owner of the store had reported the non-return nine years ago – after Finley had apparently failed to respond to letters demanding the return of the cassette – with a judge issuing a warrant in response.

When 27-year-old Finley spoke to police last Thursday, the warrant came up in a check of police records, resulting in her arrest and a night in jail despite her claim that she’d never received the letters.

“It’s obvious that Pickens County has nothing better to do,” Finley told Fox Carolina, adding, “I fully intend on fighting this, it’s ridiculous I had this happen to me.”

The movie in question has a dismal 16 percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes’ Tomatometer, with reviews describing it variously as “a comedy without laughs” (Seattle Times), “like a really bad sitcom from forty years ago” (Ebert and Roeper), and an “utterly generic Hollywood mess” (eFilmCritic), though to level things out a bit, the San Francisco Chronicle generously called it “a really shrewd bit of popular entertainment.”

Although Finley had arguably been helping the people of Pickens by keeping the widely panned movie out of circulation and thereby preventing a ruined Friday or Saturday night, local cops were clearly intent on following through with the warrant, an act that may have others with unreturned VHS tapes gathering dust in the closet wondering if they will one day suffer a similar fate…..

[Fox Carolina via Fox News]

[Image: Sakhorn / Shutterstock] [Insert: Pickens County Sheriff’s Office]

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
3 underrated movies you need to watch in July 2025
Steven Spielberg on a boat as the Jaws shark is in the background.

July is for the blockbusters. By the end of the month, three of the biggest movies of the year will be in theaters. These include Jurassic World Rebirth, Superman, and The Fantastic Four: First Steps. Both Jurassic World and Superman are well on their way to making half a billion dollars. Early tracking suggests Fantastic Four will do the same.

The three underrated movies below will not be box office juggernauts. Some are bypassing theaters and premiering directly on streaming. Two of the three are documentaries, including the terrific Jaws @ 50, which details the making of the seminal shark thriller. View the rest of our picks below.

Read more
7 best Superman movies, ranked
Superman readies to fight in Superman.

Superman was the first superhero, but his screen history lacks successful outings. The Man of Steel, an upright do-gooder who is more powerful than any other superhero, has proven difficult to adapt because he's neither terribly conflicted nor all that vulnerable.

James Gunn's Superman is just the latest attempt to tell a story about this character, and not the first one to be a success. We've ranked the long history of Superman movies on screen, narrowing it down to his seven best live-action films:

Read more
2025 Emmy nominations: Severance dominates, Apple TV+ impresses, and more observations
Two people stare at a computer.

The Television Academy rewarded the battle between innies and outies as Severance led the 2025 Emmy nominations with 27. Season 2 of the hit sci-fi drama is the frontrunner to win Outstanding Drama Series. The more impressive feat is the six acting nominations for the principal cast, with Adam Scott and Britt Lower leading the way in the categories for Lead Actor and Actress in a Drama Series.

Speaking of the lead actor, Scott's toughest competition will be Noah Wyle, who secured a nomination for his portrayal of Dr. Michael "Robby" Robinavitch on The Pitt. It's Wyle's first Emmy nomination since receiving five consecutive nods in the '90s for playing Dr. John Carter on ER. It will be difficult for The Pitt to knock off Severance for Outstanding Drama, but there is an "it's time" narrative for Wyle building that could propel him to the Emmy over Scott.

Read more