Skip to main content

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds review: Old school is new again

Rebecca Romijn, Anson Mount, and Ethan Peck walk in the hallway of the USS Enterprise in a scene from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

“Why you can trust Digital Trends – We have a 20-year history of testing, reviewing, and rating products, services and apps to help you make a sound buying decision. Find out more about how we test and score products.“

It might not have a big movie on the horizon, but Star Trek is still in a pretty great place right now. The long-running sci-fi franchise has multiple critically praised series currently in production, spanning a wide range of audience demographics and formats, from family-friendly space adventures (Star Trek: Prodigy) and serialized cosmic drama (Star Trek: Discovery and Picard) to raunchy animated comedy for adults (Star Trek: Lower Decks). That covers a lot of ground, but the latest addition to the franchise — the Paramount+ series Star Trek: Strange New Worlds — still manages to find plenty of fresh stories to tell in fascinating ways.

Recommended Videos

Created by Akiva Goldsman, Alex Kurtzman, and Jenny Lumet, Star Trek: Strange New Worlds is ostensibly a spinoff from Star Trek: Discovery chronicling the adventures of Capt. Christopher Pike and the crew of the USS Enterprise after their appearance in season 2 of Discovery. The series brings back Anson Mount (Hell on Wheels) as Pike, along with Ethan Peck as Spock and Rebecca Romijn as Number One, Pike’s second-in-command.

Rebecca Romijn, Anson Mount, and Ethan Peck walk in the hallway of the USS Enterprise in a scene from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Mount impresses as Pike

Unlike Discovery, however, Strange New Worlds takes an episodic approach to the Star Trek universe, with Pike and his crew tackling a new dilemma in each chapter of the show — much like the Enterprise’s crew did in the original Star Trek series and many of its successors. While there are a few significant, overarching narratives, they take a back seat to the mystery-of-the-week format of Strange New Worlds, which often feels more closely aligned with the franchise’s original spirit than the modern, decompressed dramas of Discovery and Picard.

Strange New Worlds owes much of its existence to the positive buzz Mount generated in his debut as Pike in Discovery, and over the first five episodes of the series, he does nothing to suggest that  thewarm reception wasn’t deserved.

Every Star Trek captain has a set of traits that defined them in their respective series, from the brash confidence of William Shatner’s Capt. James T. Kirk to the resolute calm under pressure that Patrick Stewart brought to Capt. Jean-Luc Picard. In Discovery, Pike proved to be a brilliant judge of character, innately aware of whom he should trust, what wisdom he can glean from those around him, and how to make the best use of that information. Strange New Worlds continues to use Pike’s relationships to those around him to elevate the character, and Mount’s performance is as steady and inspiring as the role demands.

It might seem like hyperbole, but it’s easy to imagine just one season of Strange New Worlds delivering enough memorable moments and stirring performances from Mount to put Christopher Pike in the conversation when discussing the franchise’s most revered captains.

Anson Mount as Christopher Pike stands on the bridge of the USS Enterprise in a scene from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Spock’s inner life

The series’ other featured cast members rise to the occasion, too, with Romijn and Peck both adding an impressive amount of depth and nuance to their characters over the course of the season. While Peck received plenty of screen time in Discovery, it’s in Strange New Worlds that we’re given our best look yet at Spock’s life outside Starfleet — not just his childhood on Vulcan (which we learned a lot about already), but what the half-Vulcan icon does when he’s not on duty.

The series brings in plenty of compelling new characters and new faces playing familiar characters, too. Celia Rose Gooding manages to walk the line between embodying what we know of communications officer Nyota Uhura from Nichelle Nichols’ original portrayal of the character and expanding the space she fills in Star Trek lore. As Christine Chapel, the Enterprise nurse originally played by Majel Barrett, Jess Bush does a similarly impressive job of juggling the expectations for an established character and the need to give the Chapel the additional depth she deserves.

The aforementioned, episodic formula of Strange New Worlds is a welcome return, too. While Discovery and Picard rely on fascinating, far-reaching stories that deliver a drip-feed of high drama and escalating stakes, Strange New Worlds offers a reminder that compartmentalized adventures still have a place in the Star Trek universe — and can offer just as much entertainment and satisfaction as a season-long arc.

Christina Chong, ethan Peck, and Anson Mount talk while standing in a room of the USS Enterprise in a scene from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The episodic format of Strange New Worlds also offers storytelling opportunities that wouldn’t be possible in Discovery or Picard, which need to maintain a more consistent tone across a full season. The original Star Trek series — as well as Star Trek: The Next Generation and the other episodic series in the franchise — occasionally offered up some memorable, lighter stories that showed a softer, humorous side to the franchise and its stars. That tradition is picked up again in Strange New Worlds, which finds some clever ways to poke fun at itself and the seriousness of its world on occasion (particularly in the season’s fifth episode, playfully titled Spock Amok).

It seems bizarre to suggest that the decision to embrace the formula that made the original Star Trek series so successful is what makes Strange New Worlds stand out from the pack now, but it’s true. In recent years, the Star Trek franchise has proven itself to be surprisingly malleable for all manner of storytelling, and the projects that have come out of this renaissance period for the sci-fi saga have each brought something new, fresh, and entertaining to Star Trek’s legacy.

Amid all of that, Strange New Worlds is a welcome reminder of both how far the franchise has come, and how much it still has to offer.

Season 1 of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds premieres May 5 on Paramount+ streaming service.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds (2022)

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds
1 Season
Genre
Sci-Fi & Fantasy
Stars
Anson Mount, Ethan Peck, Rebecca Romijn
Watch on Paramount+
Movie images and data from:
Rick Marshall
Former Contributing Editor, Entertainment
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
5 sci-fi movies on Paramount+ that are perfect to watch in the summer
The Interstellar crew lands on a shallow ocean planet.

Just a few years after rebranding CBS All Access into Paramount+, the streamer has become one of the largest in the country, now holding over 60 million subscribers. With tons of original programming, a large collection of Paramount movies, and even an option to bundle in Showtime, the streaming service has lots to love.

It should also come as no surprise that Paramount+ has tons of excellent sci-fi movies since the streamer is probably best known for its massive collection of Star Trek shows and movies, including tons of originals. If you're looking for some great sci-fi movies to watch this summer, here are five you definitely need to check out.
Interstellar (2014)

Read more
The 10 best Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episodes, ranked
Captain Sisko brandishes a phaser rifle outdoors in the DS9 episode "Rocks and Shoals"

For decades, Deep Space Nine was “that other Star Trek show.” It debuted in 1992, during the run of Star Trek: The Next Generation, the first Trek series to achieve mainstream popularity. DS9 overlapped in first-run syndication with TNG until 1994, and then with Voyager — which ran on primetime network television — from 1995 to 2001. Throughout its seven-year run, Deep Space Nine was never a top priority for studio Paramount or franchise executive producer Rick Berman. While this was a source of frustration for the cast and crew, the studio’s neglect also allowed them to take greater creative risks.
Under showrunner Ira Steven Behr, DS9 gleefully subverted the Star Trek formula, pulling open the cracks in the franchise’s futuristic utopia and refusing to be bound by the episodic nature of weekly television. DS9’s serialized stories and long character arcs may have made it harder to keep up with when it first aired, but it’s perfect for the modern binge-streaming model, which has introduced it to a whole new generation of fans. Thirty years after its debut, Deep Space Nine is finally receiving the respect it always deserved.
Selecting just ten episodes of DS9 to showcase is a challenge, as many of its most compelling stories are spread out across multiple episodes. Some of the episodes below are totally standalone stories, some are standout chapters in multi-part arcs that can be appreciated on their own, and some are two-parters that we simply couldn’t separate and had to list as a single entry. We hope you don’t mind us bending the rules just a bit — after all, that’s part of what made DS9 great to begin with.

10. In Purgatory’s Shadow/By Inferno’s Light (season 5, episodes 14 and 15)

Read more
At SDCC, Strange New Worlds goes full musical and more Star Trek trailers
Anson Mount Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' musical episode.

How do you celebrate Star Trek at Comic-Con when all of the actors stayed home? The actors and writers strike has greatly diminished the star power of San Diego Comic-Con, but Paramount+ had a novel solution. The streamer put its cards on the table early by promoting the remaining episodes of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 2, including a video preview for the upcoming musical episode.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | "Subspace Rhapsody" Trailer (SDCC 2023) | Paramount+

Read more