Skip to main content

Neil Young pulls music from streaming services, but why?

Neil Young
Ryan Waniata/Digital Trends
Neil Young became the latest high-profile artist to take a stance against streaming services yesterday when he announced with a quick social media blast on Facebook and Twitter that “Streaming has ended for me.”

Unlike his super-star compatriots Taylor Swift, Bjork, Thom Yorke, and others, however, Young claimed his motivation for abandoning the medium had nothing to do with streaming music’s notoriously low royalty payouts for musicians. Instead, Young claimed it was poor sound quality that made him give up the streaming ghost.

“I don’t need my music to be devalued by the worst quality in the history of broadcasting or any other form of distribution,” Young wrote. “I don’t feel right allowing this to be sold to my fans. It’s bad for my music.”

“For me, It’s about making and distributing music people can really hear and feel. I stand for that. When the quality is back, I’ll give it another look. Never say never,” Young said.

From politics to the environment, Mr. Young has never been shy about making waves when it comes to standing up for what he believes in. However, for those who have followed the rise of Neil Young’s latest cause, high resolution music, his decision to pull out of all streaming services has a ring that’s just slightly more hollow than some of the rock legend’s other causes.

That’s because, of course, Neil Young is the public face, chief cheerleader, and part owner of the high-resolution music service and portable music player under the Pono brand. Famous for raising over $6 million in one of the most successful Kickstarter campaigns of all time, Neil Young’s PonoPlayer and accompanying PonoMusic service tread a wholly different path than the Spotifys and Apple Musics of the new era, grounded in high-resolution FLAC files that must be downloaded and stored, as opposed to MP3-quality streaming.

While many have debated the sonic merit of lossless high resolution files in comparison to the compressed audio you’ll get from an iTunes download, or a standard stream across most services, there’s little doubt that the combination of a high-quality playback device and high-quality audio files from Young’s PonoPlayer (and other devices from the likes of Astell&Kern, and Sony) offers a much better overall listening experience.

pono player yellow
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Still, with so much at stake, it’s hard not to be a little cynical about Young’s move here. PonoMusic has established itself as a mainstay for high resolution downloads which run, on average, over $2 per track.

Further, while audiophiles and discerning listeners will far favor a tour through their favorite tunes in the highest quality available, not everyone can afford to purchase all that music, or a high-res player. It’s arguable that there’s a place for both the quality of high resolution audio, and the convenience/affordability of streaming services in today’s new digital music landscape.

Tidal, which offers a tier with CD-quality streaming to customers for $20/month, might be a happy compromise for Young’s catalog, and could be a litmus test for his overall motivation, though it isn’t clear whether he’ll keep his music there or not.

Those who have followed Young’s altruistic causes in the past know his music decisions are often motivated by dual purposes: equal parts a stance against poor audio quality, and promotion for his own company. And really, it’s hard to blame any entrepreneur there.

In any event, for those locked into the streaming game, get your Neil Young on soon — it might just be your last chance.

Editors' Recommendations

Ryan Waniata
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Waniata is a multi-year veteran of the digital media industry, a lover of all things tech, audio, and TV, and a…
Apple Music launches standalone app for classical music
Apple Music Classical is a standalone app for classical music fans.

Classical music fans no longer have to wade through an endless list of promotions for the latest pop, hip-hop, and alternative artists to get to the music they love, thanks to the new Apple Music Classical App, a standalone app from Apple that strictly focuses on classical music. You can preorder the app now and it will be available for download on March 28.

To be clear, the app is not a new streaming service and it does not require a separate subscription. Anyone who already has an Apple Music subscription via Individual, Student, Family, or Apple One plans will be able to download and use the app, much the same way as you use the existing Apple Music app. Unfortunately, Apple Music Voice Plan members are not included.

Read more
NAD’s CS1 adds wireless streaming music to any audio system
The NAD CS1 Endpoint Network Streamer.

If you've got a hi-fi system you love, but it doesn't speak Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, AirPlay, or any other wireless streaming languages, NAD's new CS1 Endpoint Network Streamer ($349) provides a super-simple and compact upgrade.

The London, England-founded, Canadian-based company, announced the compact audiophile-grade component today that allows you to add streaming capabilities to pretty much any music system. The CS1 can play high-res audio at up to 24-bit/192kHz (with its internal DAC also supporting MQA decoding) via various sources, with connectivity options that include Bluetooth 5.0, dual-band Wi-Fi, and Ethernet, and features support for Apple AirPlay 2, GoogleCast, Spotify Connect, Tidal Connect, and Roon. Through Bluetooth, however, you can stream music from any app from a smartphone, computer, or tablet, opening up the playback options.

Read more
Victrola’s Stream Onyx turntable makes listening to vinyl over Sonos more affordable
The Victrola Stream Onyx Sonos-ready turntable on a wood cabinet with a Sonos Five.

Time-honored audio gear pioneer Victrola is continuing its foray into the wireless record player market, today unveiling the Victrola Stream Onyx turntable at CES 2023 in Las Vegas. An updated and more affordable continuation of its popular Stream Carbon turntable launched earlier last year, the Works with Sonos-verified player allows vinyl lovers to spin their records and wirelessly stream the audio over their Sonos speaker system via Wi-Fi. The new player will retail for $600 and will be available for preorder on January 7.

While Bluetooth-enabled turntables offer the convenience of being able to wirelessly play your records through headphones and speakers, Bluetooth is not the ideal way to do this, as you can lose a lot of the details and accuracy from the vinyl because of the digital file compression needed. Most people wouldn't notice the difference, but using a higher-fidelity wireless system like Sonos to do this is a much better option (especially for audiophiles), one that Victrola started making a lot easier with the Stream Carbon turntable last year.

Read more