Skip to main content

World Health Organization says ‘Immunity Passports’ are a bad idea

As the world grapples with when and whether to lift social distancing restrictions imposed due to the pandemic of coronavirus, officially called COVID-19, one suggestion that has been floated is the use of “immunity passports.” The idea is that people could be tested to see if they have the antibodies to coronavirus, which is one indication that they may have developed immunity to the virus. Those who have antibodies could be issued passport-like documents that would allow them to travel or work in areas where the virus is still widespread.

But the World Health Organization (WHO) wants to put the kibosh on that plan. This week, it released a scientific briefing warning that even people who have antibodies may be vulnerable to being reinfected. So just because you have had coronavirus once, that doesn’t necessarily mean you won’t get it again. This makes the idea of immunity passports unfeasible.

“At this point in the pandemic, there is not enough evidence about the effectiveness of antibody-mediated immunity to guarantee the accuracy of an ‘immunity passport’ or ‘risk-free certificate.’,” the WHO briefing read. “People who assume that they are immune to a second infection because they have received a positive test result may ignore public health advice.”

Antibodies are produced by the body as part of its immune response to a virus. These antibodies bind to the virus and neutralize it. Several studies have shown that people who recover from coronavirus do have specific antibodies for the virus. However, there is also a second response which is relevant, called cellular immunity, in which the body’s T-cells recognize and eliminate cells that are already infected with the virus.

The problem with antibody tests is that some people who have recovered from coronavirus have only low levels of antibodies, so it looks as if cellular immunity is also important in recovering. It’s possible that people with antibodies could become re-infected if they don’t have sufficient cellular immunity.

Another issue is that tests for COVID-19 are very new, and like any diagnostic test, can show false positives or false negatives. Also, as COVID-19 is only one of a family of six coronaviruses known to affect humans, an antibody test may not be able to distinguish between antibodies for COVID-19 and antibodies for one of the milder viruses which are common and cause cold-like symptoms.

Research into antibody tests will continue and it’s possible that new findings will make the tests more accurate and reliable. But for now, it looks like immunity passports won’t be a good solution to the current crisis.

For the latest updates on the novel coronavirus outbreak, visit the World Health Organization’s COVID-19 page.

Editors' Recommendations

Georgina Torbet
Georgina is the Digital Trends space writer, covering human space exploration, planetary science, and cosmology. She…
The World Health Organization wants you to stay at home and play video games
A Pc gamer playing games.

The World Health Organization (WHO) has teamed up with representatives from the gaming industry to launch the #PlayApartTogether campaign to encourage people to follow social distancing and hygiene recommendations to avoid spreading the coronavirus, officially called COVID-19, for example by staying at home and playing video games online.

Representatives from some of the world's largest games studios have signed on to the campaign. CEO of Activision Blizzard, Bobby Kotick, said, “It has never been more critical to ensure people stay safely connected to one another. Games are the perfect platform because they connect people through the lens of joy, purpose, and meaning. We are proud to participate in such a worthwhile and necessary initiative.”

Read more
ZTE will skip Mobile World Congress press conference due to coronavirus outbreak
Cricket Wireless

ZTE has decided to skip its Mobile World Congress press conference this year due to the coronavirus outbreak in its home country of China. To be clear, ZTE saysthe cancellation was triggered by the secondary effects of the outbreak -- not because of employees having contracted it themselves.

For example, the virus has made it harder to get visas and make travel arrangements. ZTE also says that it tends "to be an overly courteous company, and simply doesn’t want to make people uncomfortable,” according to a ZTE spokesperson in an interview with The Verge. It's currently unclear if it's only the ZTE press conference that's canceled, or ZTE's presence at the show in general.

Read more
The World Health Organization labels gaming disorder as a mental condition
mac gaming lifestyle

In what can be described as a sign of the times, the World Health Organization recognized a new kind of mental health condition. It's a familiar ailment, though some of us may be slow to call it a medical condition. It's called gaming disorder, and it's characterized by "a pattern of persistent or recurrent gaming behavior," or more simply, an addiction to gaming.

The inclusion of the new condition was originally announced in the 2017 beta draft of WHO's update of International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11). As of Monday, June 18, gaming disorder is officially recognized as a mental health condition by WHO.

Read more