Skip to main content

MySpace’s Tom warns Google+ about excessive feed filtering

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Google would be remiss to use its vaunted talent in algorithms in Google+, MySpace founder Tom Anderson has cautioned in a TechCrunch editorial. Anderson argues that Facebook’s over-reliance on algorithmic filtering of the vast output of information in the network is hurting the company by limiting the amount of control users have over their feeds. As such, Anderson warns, Google should be cautious of trying to find an algorithmic solution to increasing the “signal-to-noise ratio” of Google+.

Recommended Videos

Anderson suggests that as Google+ gets larger (and more noisy) the company is going to fall back to its bread-and-butter, referring to PageRank as the “founding algorithm” of company and calling it “Google’s most important work.” But this gives rise to his biggest question: “Can a company so enamored with the power of algorithms and machine learning, let the user take control?”

User control is at the heart of Anderson’s argument, and not without merit. A major lasting complaint users have about Facebook is a lack of transparency and command over their own profiles. While this has been most apparent in Facebook’s regular modifications of their privacy policy and the various options associated with it, Anderson says the biggest factor in both networks is control of their streams. Right now, Facebook users’ streams are run by a Facebook algorithm, rather than allowing users to decide from who and what they want to hear. Twitter aside, there hasn’t been a competing social network with an all-encompassing stream until Google+, and with the amount of control Google+ users have over what updates they see, Facebook’s stream can be both misguiding and frustrating.

Even so, Anderson staunchly writes that he indeed loves both networks, but Facebook’s feed algorithm is limiting his contact with friends: “Anyway, I love using G+ and Facebook. On Facebook, nearly all of my “distant” friends and former co-workers are there. It’s the best way to keep in touch with them. But recently I’ve noticed that I get less and less response from my Facebook friends. I post something that used to generate some interaction, and now I receive almost nothing.”

Anderson’s point is that by not giving him (and other users) more ability to discern who’s information comes up in their feeds, the value of it all is lost, largely because the worth of a social network isn’t in maintaining relationships with our closest friends but with our distant ones. As he writes, “Social networks may be more valuable to us in that they allow us to maintain more “weak ties” than we ever could before. Our “strong ties,” after all, are already “strong,” and don’t benefit as much from the technology boost. If you question the value of “weak ties,” how about job networking, dating (a shocking, to some, percentage of new relationships start online), advice/recommendations, or opportunity of any kind?”

Thus, Google has an opportunity to really differentiate Google+ from Facebook despite their love for algorithmic solutions. While Facebook, in Anderson’s eyes, seems to have picked its course, Google+ still offers users a better way to broadcast to and interact with the more distant areas of their network, which helps users maintain larger social circles than they ever could without it. The real question is, with 10 million users and counting, how Google will help users cut through all the fluff.

Derek Mead
Former Digital Trends Contributor
How to deactivate your Instagram account (or delete it)
A person holding a phone with the Instagram app open on it.

Oh, social media. Sometimes it’s just too much, folks.

If you’re finding yourself in a position where shutting down your Instagram account for a period of time sounds good, the people at Meta have made it pretty simple to deactivate it. It’s also quite easy to completely delete your Instagram, although we wouldn’t recommend this latter option if you plan on returning to the platform at a later date.

Read more
Bluesky finally adds a feature many had been waiting for
A blue sky with clouds.

Bluesky has been making a lot of progress in recent months by simplifying the process to sign up while at the same time rolling out a steady stream of new features.

As part of those continuing efforts, the social media app has just announced that users can now send direct messages (DMs).

Read more
Incogni: Recover your privacy and remove personal information from the internet
Incogni remove your personal data from brokers and more

Everything you do while online is tracked digitally. Often connected to your email address or an issued IP, trackers can easily identify financial details, sensitive information like your social security number, demographics, contact details, like a phone number or address, and much more. In many ways, this information is tied to a digital profile and then collated, recorded, and shared via data brokers. There are many ways this information can be scooped up and just as many ways, this information can be shared and connected back to you and your family. The unfortunate reality is that, for most of us, we no longer have any true privacy.

The problem is exacerbated even more if you regularly use social media, share content or images online, or engage in discussions on places like Reddit or community boards. It's also scary to think about because even though we know this information is being collected, we don't necessarily know how much is available, who has it, or even what that digital profile looks like.

Read more