Skip to main content

Say goodbye to the video-sharing apps Twitter’s Vine will try to strangle

vine headerPhoto-sharing apps like Instagram have taken the digital world by storm, and the next platform in line seems to be social video – at least, that’s what everyone keeps pitching.

Unlike photo apps, current video apps are fragmented, each with a distinct style for presenting and publishing content. One app will limit videos to 15 seconds, while another will encourages users to stitch together multiple clips into one continuous video. Right now platforms and users still seem undecided on how they want to create and watch short-form content. But Twitter’s bet on Vine’s stitched-together, looping clips, just might pay off, should it emerge as the standard for how users want to watch short-form video.

After Dick Costolo publicly teased Vine on Wednesday, which now apparently supports Twitter cards among other smaller upgrades, we all Vine was close to debut. With the full force of Twitter behind it, Vine could offer a serious challenge to third-party apps in the space – none of which have much of a following to hang on to. So which apps might be choked out by Vine?

Direct competitors

lighttThere are a couple of  apps that present videos in the same GIF-like looped format that Vine does, namely Vigi and Lightt. And because of the similarities, these two arguably have the most to lose. Vigi co-founder Senhor Ricardo tactfully told us that the company welcomes the new competitor.But Twitter integration is critical for remotely having a chance of mass adoption. When asked if Vigi offered Twitter card support, Ricardo said that it was a feature that the company was working on integrating – and something that Vine notably already has. 

Threat level: High. These apps do what Vine does, but they don’t have Twitter throwing money and spotlight at them, and they aren’t directly embedding into tweets.

One-take video apps

For the apps that aren’t looping or playing out GIF-like content, there are more traditional video apps that play back a seconds-long video shot in just one take. Viddy, Socialcam, and Klip are a few Vine competitors to keep a close eye on, considering these apps are the leading startups in their category and have garnered tens of millions of dollars in funding. Vine could be something of a challenge – maybe one that motivates these competitors to introduce a similar GIF-type function. But because different playback styles of videos have emerged, in retrospect this fractional state could play in Viddy, Socialcam, and Klip’s favor. In fact, if users end up deciding that apps like Vigi, Vine, and Lightt are too “annoying,” the traditional short-form video apps might end up winning.

socialcam Threat level: Mild. These apps are also about user-made video clips, but they bring different features to the table that distinguish them, so you could argue they aren’t direct competitors. However, it’s worth noting that Socialcam and Klip don’t support Twitter cards. 

Channel-based video apps

The third style of video apps, from a tech standpoint, aren’t all that different from apps like Viddy and Socialcam. Products like Tout and Mobli are distinguishing themselves from competitors by focusing on a different type of business model altogether. These types of apps aren’t just platforms for communication, or for capturing spur of the moment videos. They encourage users to publish quality content, similar to the types of videos that users would upload to their YouTube channels. 

Threat level: Low. These apps are more about curating content than creative outlets for users to experiment with. 

Twitter-specific video apps

Of course, a handful of third-party developers have made entire products that do nothing but help you upload video to Twitter. Apps like Twitvid, TwitC, and twitLENS exist for the specific purpose of allowing you to put video clips on Twitter – because that’s something that Twitter doesn’t have a native solution for. Of course, Twitter didn’t use to have a native solution for much of anything: The platform didn’t even have its own photo-uploading feature until summer 2011… when it kicked sand in the faces of outside developers who had been providing the function for quite some time and felt blindsided by the move. The Vine acquisition was originally seen as a warning to these third-party video developers, although Twitter hasn’t folded it into the platform as an integrated tool – yet. For the time being, Vine is a separate app that simply feeds into Twitter, like a lot of other video apps do. The different being, of course, that Twitter owns Vine and will therefore be giving it some special treatment.

Threat level: Mild. The biggest threat to these apps is the fact that there’s another Twitter video solution. However, these are more focused on the functionality of uploading videos – not making a creative piece of media, like you do with Vine. Anytime a video app that works with Twitter is launched, these guys have to be a little nervous. The fact that Twitter is increasingly interested in making in-house tools is what is actually nerve wracking for them. 

It’s all a little familiar…

If Twitter promoting Vine feels familiar, that’s because the whole deal is incredibly reminiscent of how Facebook scooped up and used Instagram. The obvious difference here is that when Facebook bought Instagram, it was already a huge player in its own right – Vine is not. Still, there are plenty of parallels to be drawn, the first of them being the interest in media-sharing apps. Here we have two big social networks that each scooped up photo-sharing and video-sharing specific apps. Both are letting them exist as standalone apps, although Facebook has some strong tie-ins, bringing a hefty amount of Instagram content to its site. We expect Twitter will do the same at some point, by either integrating Vine into its mobile app completely or somehow featuring its content.

Six seconds of stitched-together, looping videos just might be the next Instagram – but that’s a really big might. There’s always a shot, and the democratization of GIF creation does lend itself to Vine’s potential. With no clear leader in the social video space, and Twitter’s power to market Vine to the masses, thinks look goof for it. But the jury’s still out on whether Twitter is where we want to consume and send these bite-sized videos. Vine may be just the latest experiment, but with Twitter on its side, the cards are stacked in its favor.

Editors' Recommendations

Francis Bea
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Francis got his first taste of the tech industry in a failed attempt at a startup during his time as a student at the…
Elon Musk says Twitter character limit will increase hugely
Twitter logo in white stacked on top of a blue stylized background with the Twitter logo repeating in shades of blue.

Elon Musk, the man who bought Twitter for $44 billion at the end of October, says the social media platform is planning to up the limit for tweets to 4,000 characters, a significant increase on the current 280-character limit.

Responding to an inquiry on Twitter from someone asking if it’s true "that Twitter is set to increase the characters from 280 to 4000," Musk replied, “Yes,” but declined to offer any additional information, such as when the change will take place. It's also unclear as to whether longer tweets will only be available to subscribers of Twitter Blue, Twitter's premium tier that's set to relaunch sign-ups on Monday.

Read more
Hive Social is my favorite Twitter alternative, but that’s not saying much
iPhone 14 Pro in hand showing off profile page on Hive Social app

Ever since Elon Musk bought Twitter, it seems that the once-favorite social media site has just been going down in flames. It’s a sad sight to see — fake news and misinformation running rampant from paid “verified” accounts, restoration of formerly banned accounts (they were banned for good reason), and so much other stuff that I just can’t keep up anymore. With all of these changes, there’s been a rise in alternatives to Twitter, like the incredibly popular Mastodon.

I prefer something simpler, like the new Hive Social that has recently made waves. Think of Twitter and Instagram, and what you would end up with if you combined the two. There’s also a little dash of Myspace in there, as you can even add some music to your profile page. I’ve been poking around on Hive Social since I joined a week ago, and while I’ve been enjoying my time there, I also noticed a few things along the way.
Hive reminds me of the early days of Twitter
OnePlus 10T Andy Boxall/Digital Trends

Read more
Musk says some impersonation Twitter accounts face permanent ban
Twitter logo in white stacked on top of a blue stylized background with the Twitter logo repeating in shades of blue.

New Twitter owner Elon Musk said on Sunday that anyone on the platform that operates an account impersonating someone else, without stating “parody” in the profile, will be permanently suspended from the service.

In a follow-up tweet, Musk said that, while the company used to give a warning to an imitator to give them a chance to rectify the situation, there would no longer be a warning, with suspension taking place as soon as the violation was discovered.

Read more