Skip to main content

Politicians can’t block users on social media, federal judge rules

politicians on social media randall case gavel2
Blocking other users on social media may be peace of mind for some, but for public officials, it could be a violation of the First Amendment. In the continuing debate on how politicians on social media should act, a U.S. District Judge just ruled that blocking a user from a politician’s account is unconstitutional.

In the case, Virginia Judge James Cacheris ruled that when chairwoman of the Loudoun County Board of Supervisors Phyllis Randall blocked a user from her Facebook page, she violated the First Amendment. While a county official may have limited influence outside that area, the ruling could set a precedent for politicians using social media, including President Donald Trump, who is currently facing a lawsuit for blocking users on Twitter.

In the Virginia case, the user was blocked after accusing the school board of corruption. By blocking that user, the judge said that Randall was “suppressing critical commentary regarding elected officials,” which is a form of viewpoint discrimination, or suppressing opinions out of fear of retaliation.

Randall, who also deleted the offending comment, said she unblocked the user 12 hours later. She also argued that she did not use county resources to run the Facebook account. The results of the case, for Randall, doesn’t include any major form of punishment, but the federal ruling could set guidelines for how political figures can and cannot act on social media.

Social media’s role in politics has been in and out of the spotlight recently, thanks in part to Trump’s unconventional tweets, debating the medium’s role in the political conversation. Introduced earlier this summer, the Communications Over Various Feeds Electronically for Engagement (COVFEFE) Act, named after a typo later deleted from Trump’s Twitter account, seeks to make social media posts subject to the same preservation as the president’s official communications. If the act passes, deleting tweets from both the official presidential account as well as non-official accounts would be illegal.

Trump, along with former White House press secretary Sean Spicer and social media director Dan Scavino, is currently facing a lawsuit similar to the ruling in Virginia. A group of Twitter users blocked by the president claims that the block violates their First Amendment rights by excluding them from the discussion. The lawsuit calls @realDonaldTrump a “kind of digital town hall,” arguing that excluding members of the public for opposing viewpoints is unconstitutional.

Editors' Recommendations

Hillary K. Grigonis
Hillary never planned on becoming a photographer—and then she was handed a camera at her first writing job and she's been…
X CEO reveals video calls are coming to the app formerly known as Twitter
The new X sign replacing the Twitter logo on the company's headquarters in San Francisco.

X, formerly Twitter, is to get video calling as part of ongoing efforts to turn the platform into a so-called “everything app” offering a broad range of services.

X CEO Linda Yaccarino announced the news during an interview with CNBC on Thursday.

Read more
How to download Instagram photos (5 easy ways)
Instagram app running on the Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 5.

Instagram is amazing, and many of us use it as a record of our lives — uploading the best bits of our trips, adventures, and notable moments. But sometimes you can lose the original files of those moments, leaving the Instagram copy as the only available one . While you may be happy to leave it up there, it's a lot more convenient to have another version of it downloaded onto your phone or computer. While downloading directly from Instagram can be tricky, there are ways around it. Here are a few easy ways to download Instagram photos.

Read more
X seems to have deleted years of old Twitter images
The new X sign replacing the Twitter logo on the company's headquarters in San Francisco.

The social media platform formerly known as Twitter and recently rebranded as X appears to be having trouble showing images posted on the site between 2011 and 2014.

The issue came to widespread attention on Saturday when X user Tom Coates noted how the famous selfie posted by Ellen DeGeneres at the Oscars in 2014, which quickly broke the “most retweets” record, was no longer displaying. Later reports suggested the image had been restored, though, at the time of writing, we’re not seeing it.

Read more