Skip to main content

Game 1 of the World Series proves that replay would work fine in Major League Baseball

twitter reaction demuth blown call strengthens case replay manager challenges mlb error final
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Major League Baseball’s umpiring continues to solidify the argument for expanded replay for those who have spent years calling for its implementation.

Last night during Game 1 of the World Series, umpire Dana DeMuth ruled Boston Red Sox second baseman Dustin Pedroia out after St. Louis Cardinals second baseman Pete Kozma clearly failed to catch a ball that was thrown to him. Had Kozma fielded the catch cleanly, Pedroia would’ve been out easily. However, the ball tipped off Kozma’s glove and rolled away from him. DeMuth promptly ruled Pedroia out, to the simultaneous shock of many. However, given the track records of umpires and their propensity to get calls wrong on an all-too-common basis, we’re willing to be that there were plenty of veteran baseball fans who surely were muttering something to the effect of “yeap, I’ve seen this before.” After all, who can forget when Armando Galarraga was robbed of a perfect game back in 2010.

 To the relief of Red Sox Nation and objective baseball fans everywhere, the umpires conferred for a few minutes and overruled DeMuth’s initial call, ultimately getting the play right. What did Umpire Crew Chief John Hirschbeck have to say about what transpired? Referring to the call, Hirschbeck was heard saying “Our job is to get it right” during the FOX broadcast of the game last night.

We wondered what folks on Twitter had to say about the entire sequence. Many on Twitter naturally called DeMuth’s credibility into question. Other commended the umpiring crew for overruling the initial call and getting the play right. However, from the tweets we saw, no one mentioned the extended length of the game as a result of the time that was required for the umpires to convene and reverse DeMuth’s call. Included are reactions from both fans and media.

One of the primary arguments against implementing instant replay into Major League Baseball games centered around the notion that the games would increase in length by significant margins, ultimately decreasing the level of enjoyability. If the Twitter reaction we saw to last night’s game is any indication, any concerns that MLB has had about increased game duration decreasing fan interest should be allayed by the lack of interest in the issue on the part of the fans. After all, the NFL has not only adopted, but they and their fans have embraced replay as well as the strategic implications that come into play when deciding when, where and why an NFL coach should use a challenge.

In the end, if $10 beers haven’t forced MLB fans to run screaming into the waiting arms of the Canadian Football League, making the game a few minutes longer in an effort to get all of the calls right won’t either.

Editors' Recommendations

Konrad Krawczyk
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Konrad covers desktops, laptops, tablets, sports tech and subjects in between for Digital Trends. Prior to joining DT, he…
Best color laser printers for 2024: tested and reviewed
A Brother printer on a counter in front of a brick wall.

The best color laser printers can be a great investment, saving you quite a bit of time and money. For shoppers worried about the long-term ink costs, you'll find color laser printers surprisingly affordable. Laser printers use toner, which lasts a very long time, delivering a low cost per page for monochrome documents and fast color prints. The best color laser printers offer quick performance and reliability to help keep your home office or small business productive.

If you need to scan documents for record-keeping and photo capture or want the convenience of a color copier, an all-in-one color laser printer is an essential tool for your small business or personal use. For a small added cost, you get expanded capabilities. That's why every model on this list is an all-in-one from the best printer brands.

Read more
The 5 best Wi-Fi adapters for PC in 2024
The Ugreen AC1300 Wi-Fi adapter in a desktop PC.

Whether you're designing it yourself or getting a pre-built PC, it can be easy to get a computer and realize that it doesn't have a native Wi-Fi adapter. Or, maybe it does, but you're internet speeds are getting faster, game downloads are getting bigger, you've already upgraded your router and need an adapter to match your newfound power requirements. No matter the situation, an external Wi-Fi adapter that you can add to your PC setup or even laptop setup will be worth your time. Here, we investigate the best Wi-Fi adapters for PC use. Most are incredibly affordable and just snap into a free USB port and start working.
The best Wi-Fi adapter for PC in 2024

Buy the

Read more
How to pin a website to the taskbar in Windows
A man sits, using a laptop running the Windows 11 operating system.

Windows includes many interesting tools, but if you’re like many people, more and more of your digital life is happening in your web browser and nowhere else. That being the case, you’ll want to keep your most important websites close at hand. The easiest way to access them in Windows is the Start menu and the taskbar, treating them more or less like programs in and of themselves.

Although easy overall, getting a website from your browser to your taskbar is slightly different depending on which browser you’re using.

Read more