Skip to main content

EFF sides with YouTube, says T-Mobile is throttling video on its network

tmobile bingeon youtube google play movies t mobile binge on
Image used with permission by copyright holder
T-Mobile already had trouble with its Binge On program when it launched, with net neutrality advocates calling the network out for sidelining the laws. Now, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) has sided with these advocates, claiming the program should be considered throttling.

In a report published on Monday, the EFF shows that T-Mobile’s “video optimization” is nothing more than network throttling. It lowers all video content, regardless of the service, to 1.5Mbps.

eff-test-results-t-mobile
EFF test results on T-Mobile network Image used with permission by copyright holder

That allows T-Mobile to cut the costs of supplying video content, by lowering the video quality to 480p. T-Mobile argues that most customers are simply incapable of viewing higher quality video, despite some customers suggesting they could watch HD video before the Binge On program launched.

YouTube is the biggest video provider in the U.S. to not support the Binge On program, and last week said T-Mobile is throttling its content. It wants to see the program become opt-in rather than opt-out, or have services unsupported removed from the program.

T-Mobile has not said whether it will honor YouTube’s requests. In a statement made shortly after YouTube’s comments, T-Mobile refuted claims it is throttling video content, despite clear evidence that it is lowering the bandwidth for video content across its network.

The third largest network might face more than angry customers and services in the near future, with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) sending letters to T-Mobile, AT&T, and Comcast on the new “data-free” services, which might break net neutrality laws set in place last year.

T-Mobile has been winning over customers with its new Un-Carrier deals, but this latest program might hurt the company, especially if video services or net neutrality advocates continue to fight against it. The EFF says the FCC should investigate the Binge On program, and we suspect in the next few months we will hear a lot more about the program’s future.

Editors' Recommendations

David Curry
Former Digital Trends Contributor
David has been writing about technology for several years, following the latest trends and covering the largest events. He is…
Popular YouTubers react to Shorts’ new video remix feature
Two mobile devices showing two people dancing in YouTube Shorts videos.

YouTube introduced Shorts in 2021, months after its release in India. The feature came as an answer to TikTok, which had already taken the world by storm. While YouTube is still ahead of TikTok in terms of popularity, the company's Shorts service is nowhere near TikTok. But YouTube is making constant efforts to catch up in the short video format. Recently, YouTube introduced a feature for Shorts that allows creators to use clips from billions of public YouTube videos. The feature is a build-out of the existing remix feature that lets users sample out audio for their Shorts posts. Since this is a new feature, we reached out to some popular YouTubers to find out their opinion on the feature.
An overview of the new Shorts feature
The new video sampling feature from YouTube Shorts aims to popularize the service. Also, it is an answer to TikTok’s popular Stitch feature. Through this feature, Shorts creators can splice 1- to 5-second clips from public YouTube videos. When a short is created using clips from long videos, the original creator gets credited via a link. All the videos on YouTube are available for remixing by default. Hence, creators who don't want their videos to be used for the particular feature have to opt out of it manually in YouTube Studio.

YouTube Shorts splice feature YouTube

Read more
Google is killing off its lightweight YouTube Go app
Three phone screens showing the new Android 12 Go Edition.

Google is killing off its lightweight YouTube Go app, an app designed for phones with low storage and limited access to robust LTE and 5G networks. The company cites improvements to the mainstream YouTube app that rendered this service redundant. The app will remain available for download in the Play Store until August. The app boiled down YouTube to its essentials and stripped away things that weren't necessary like commenting, posting, or creating videos.

"When we launched YouTube Go in 2016, it was designed for viewers in locations where connectivity, data prices, and low-end devices prevented us from delivering the best experience in the main YouTube app. Since then, YouTube has invested in improvements to the main YouTube app that make it perform better in these environments, while also delivering a better user experience which is inclusive of our entire community," the YouTube team said.

Read more
T-Mobile wants you to test drive its 5G home internet
T-Mobile CEO Mike Sievert

T-Mobile is taking a bold new step into 5G home internet with a new program that will make it easier for broadband customers to “break up with Big Internet.”

During a live-streamed event today, T-Mobile CEO Mike Sievert unveiled the carrier’s new “Internet Freedom” initiative, which he hopes will fix the “broken” broadband industry by giving folks an easy path to move to wireless 5G home internet.

Read more