Skip to main content

YouTube unhappy with T-Mobile's Binge On program, accuses carrier of throttling video

T-Mobile Binge On
Nick Mokey/Digital Trends
YouTube is not happy with T-Mobile’s new “Binge On” service, and has filed a complaint saying the program lowers the quality of all video traffic, even though the video platform is not part of the program.

Unreported throttling is illegal under the Federal Communications Commission’s net neutrality laws, passed earlier in the year.

“Reducing data charges can be good for users, but it doesn’t justify throttling all video services, especially without explicit user consent,” a YouTube spokesperson said to The Wall Street Journal.

Binge On waives data fees for video traffic, in exchange for sub-720p DVD quality video. Twenty-four providers partnered with T-Mobile at launch, including HBO Now, Netflix, and Hulu, with YouTube the only major video provider not joining the program.

One fifth of video traffic comes from YouTube, and that percentage is even higher on mobile. That puts T-Mobile in an awkward situation, especially if the allegations of throttling the video service turn out to be true.

The Internet Association, which YouTube’s parent Alphabet is a part of, said that Binge On “appears to involve throttling of all video traffic, across all data plans, regardless of network congestion.” No other video service unaffiliated to the program has mentioned throttling on T-Mobile’s network.

T-Mobile has not commented on YouTube’s complaint.

Nothing is official right now, however the FCC has sent agency letters to T-Mobile, Comcast, and AT&T regarding the new programs all three companies recently announced. That is a different tone from the one FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler used last month, describing Binge On as “highly competitive and highly innovative.”

Wheeler said the letters were not a formal inquiry, but it might turn into one if the complaints from YouTube and net neutrality advocates are accurate.

Editors' Recommendations

David Curry
Former Digital Trends Contributor
David has been writing about technology for several years, following the latest trends and covering the largest events. He is…
YouTube launched 17 years ago today with this video
Jawed Karim in YouTube's first video in 2005.

It was 17 years ago on Sunday that a 25-year-old guy called Jawed Karim uploaded the first video to YouTube, kickstarting a service that went on to become the go-to hub for video streaming and giving anyone with a camera and a good idea the chance to make a living out of their own content.

The first video was, it has to be said, nothing to write home about. The low-res, 19-second clip (below), called Me at the Zoo, features YouTube co-founder Karim at San Diego Zoo, helpfully pointing out that elephants have remarkably long trunks.

Read more
YouTube TV finally adds picture-in-picture for iPhone and iPad
YouTube TV shown picture-in-picture atop a web browser on an iPhone.

After months of promises and and extreme patience from customers, YouTube TV finally has added a picture-in-picture feature (also referred to as PiP) for iPhone and iPad. The company confirmed the rollout this week, and it started appearing in the app a few hours later, apparently triggered by a server-side update.

The feature allows you to continue watching a show in a smaller window while doing something else on your device.

Read more
The Weather Channel is coming to YouTube TV
YouTube TV on Apple TV.

The Weather Channel -- which previously had seen relatively small reach on streaming platforms in the United States -- is starting to branch out. YouTube TV will gain the 24-7 weather service this year, according to a press release from Allen Media Group and Google.

The addition is a big deal because The Weather Channel had been limited to two of the smallest streaming platforms -- FuboTV and DirecTV Stream. It also fills a pretty big void in the YouTube TV lineup, which doesn't currently have an all-day weather channel. YouTube TV is believed to be the second-largest streaming service in the United States. It last announced a ballpark figure of "more than 3 million subscribers" in October 2020. It hasn't given any sort of update since then. For context, Hulu with Live TV has a publicly announced 4 million paid subscribers.

Read more