Skip to main content

Is the live-action Ghost in the Shell remake really that bad?

Ghost in the Shell, released in 2017, has gone on to become one of Hollywood’s most infamous cinematic remakes. Plagued by controversy and lackluster reviews, this Scarlett Johansson-led film grossed $169.8 million against a budget of $110 million, making it one of the biggest box-office disappointments in recent history.

There are always going to be comparisons between a remake and the original film, and while there have already been many scathing reviews about the 2017 remake, let’s look at whether or not this 2017 movie really is as bad as people think.

The plot is more reflective than active

Scarlett Johansson in "Ghost in the Shell" (2017).
Paramount Pictures / Paramount Pictures

With every remake, there are bound to be some creative differences from the source material. With Ghost in the Shell, the remake removes many of the original’s philosophical musings for a greater emphasis on fast-paced action (which is done pretty well). However, this approach kills two birds with one stone, as the anime moves at a more steady pace, allowing the audience to take in the gorgeous and intricate world presented to them.

Also, instead of forging a new identity for herself as an android, the Major spends more time trying to figure out who she was before she became one. Though she is encouraged not to let her memories of her past define her, this is done more to keep her from learning the dark truth and to allow her evil superior to control her. All in all, the new Major is defined more by her past than her present in the film, which seems to reflect the film’s nature as a nostalgic remake.

I’ll admit it: the worldbuilding in the remake is impressive

Scarlett Johansson in "Ghost in the Shell" (2017).
Paramount Pictures / Paramount Pictures

The remake does a terrific job recreating some of the anime’s iconic scenes, including the Major’s opening dive, her invisible fight on the water, the scub- diving scene, and her battle with the spider tank. It also adds some Blade Runner-esque holograms to liven up the city. Though the live-action visuals are stunning, they don’t stand out as much they could, as the more colorful parts of the Major’s world seem to get watered down by gray skyscrapers and the dark of night. Thus, it all comes across as another dystopian future film that looks bleak and colorless compared to the anime.

Nevertheless, this remake has an advantage over the original by having over two decades of new material to dip into to keep things fresh. The live-action film distinguishes itself by integrating new characters and plot elements into the story, including the villain Kuze taking the role of “Puppet Master,” Major’s “deep dive” into an infected Geisha-robot, and Batou losing his eyes in an explosion.

The whitewashing controversy still stings

Scarlett Johansson in "Ghost in the Shell" (2017).
Paramount Pictures / Paramount Pictures

Though Johansson does bear a striking resemblance to the Major in this remake (who is known as Mira Killian), the fact that a white actor played an East Asian character received quite a lot of backlash. It didn’t help that the film ends with the revelation that the Major was born a Japanese girl with the character’s original manga name, Motoko Kusanagi.

Though many people took issue with this, many fans in Japan didn’t seem so bothered by Johansson’s casting, with some arguing her character’s body is artificial and inconsequential due to the franchise’s theme of finding one’s identity. Even the anime film’s director, Mamoru Oshhii, felt the same, saying to IGN that casting an Asian actress was unnecessary and only motivated by politics, which should be separate from artistic expression.

This discourse is probably best summed up by Justin Charity of Ringer, who wrote: “Your average Japanese citizen’s outlook is much less influenced by pluralism than the outlooks of many Asian Americans, who live in a country where popular culture rarely represents them well, if at all.” So even if Johansson’s casting does work with the film’s concept and theme, it still feels like a missed opportunity to bring true representation to Japanese-American audiences in this Hollywood blockbuster. Also, the fact that a Japanese person’s mind is transferred into a white body in this film could not be more symbolic of Hollywood taking the original anime and repackaging it for a Western audience.

The verdict

Scarlett Johannson in "Ghost in the Shell" (2017).
Paramount Pictures / Paramount Pictures

The live-action Ghost in the Shell may have been branded a remake, but it is very much its own story with a few elements taken from the anime film. The former has its flaws, and it could’ve done more to appeal to modern audiences in terms of casting and staying faithful to the source material. By itself, the remake is a decent blockbuster with its own merits, but it doesn’t reach the high bar set by the anime.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Anthony Orlando
Anthony Orlando is a writer/director from Oradell, NJ. He spent four years at Lafayette College, graduating CUM LAUDE with a…
Everything coming to Netflix in June 2024
A man and a woman soak in a bathtub in Hit Man.

Hit Man | Official Teaser | Netflix

May was an eventful month for Netflix. The streamer opened with a bang with A Man in Full and John Mulaney's live show Everybody's in L.A., debuted the latest season of Bridgerton in the middle of the month, and in the last week of the month, it launched a strange new show with Benedict Cumberbatch called Eric. (We won't mention Jerry Seinfeld's unfortunate "comedy," Unfrosted.) It was a typically diverse programming slate for Netflix, which still leads the industry in total number of subscribers.

Read more
Stranger Things: The First Shadow trailer teases the rise of Henry Creel
A boy holds a blindfold and readies to put it around his eyes.

You can witness the rise of the sinister Henry Creel in the trailer for Stranger Things: The First Shadow, the stage play based on Netflix's hit sci-fi series.

It's 1959, and the Creel family is looking for a fresh start in Hawkins, Indiana. “It’s not real. I’m normal,” Henry ominously says in the footage. As the trailer progresses, Henry remains tormented by his telekinesis, eventually winding up at the Hawkins National Laboratory, the site where he will transform into 001, aka Vecna.

Read more
The 10 most popular movies on Netflix right now
Dakota Johnson looks through a spiderweb in an image from Madame Web

Netflix is one of the most popular streaming services in the world, with nearly 270 million subscribers. And just what do those people tend to watch? In particular, what is the most popular movie on Netflix? Each week, the streaming service releases a list of its 10 most-watched movies over a recent seven-day period to keep subscribers in the loop regarding its most popular titles.

After flopping at the box office, Madame Web is now on Netflix. Ironically, Madame Web shot right to No. 1 on the Netflix top 10 list. Mother of the Bride remains strong in its second week at No. 2, followed by Shrek at No. 3. Other new movies in the top 10 include Upgrade at No. 4 and Thelma the Unicorn at No. 5. Below, we've listed the top 10 movies in the U.S. from May 13 to May 19, along with general information about each film, such as genre, rating, cast, and synopsis.

Read more