Tiny trucks are making a comeback, but you won’t want to drive them

2016 Toyota Tacoma
After nearly a decade of languishing at the bottom of the industry’s priority list, the midsize truck market seems to be finally getting some much needed attention. In the past year GM has rolled out twin midsize trucks the GMC Canyon and the Chevy Colorado, meanwhile Toyota has announced the first update to its Tacoma since dinosaurs roamed the earth.

Beneath the surface though, things may not have changed all that much. Not only are these trucks not quite as new as they seem, the future may not hold more competition or innovation.

State of the market

The odd thing about midsize trucks is that while automakers have largely ignored the midsize truck market — the last new truck introduced before this year was the now deceased Dodge Dakota — consumers haven’t. Though their share of the overall truck market has declined, new and used midsize trucks continue to command outsized prices. Anyone who has shopped for a used Toyota Tacoma can attest to the fact that they simply don’t lose value. Here in the Pacific Northwest, one of the larger, midsize truck markets, buyers can expect to pay around $16,500 for a ten-year-old Toyota Tacoma.

According to GM product planners Digital Trends has spoken with, it was this shockingly robust used market that convinced the company to get back into midsize trucks with the new Colorado and Canyon.

The curse of this robust market, and a lack of competition, is that automakers charge a premium for midsize trucks. A two-wheel drive, four-cylinder GMC Canyon, like the one we tested, will set buyers back more than $32,000, a comparably equipped GMC Sierra 1500 costs just $4,000 more. Meanwhile a Toyota Tacoma can cost over $37,000 when fully equipped.

Old Tech

Those might seem high but fair prices, considering the outrageous prices similar used trucks command — but unfortunately there’s more to the story.

Despite being fresh from the factory, the three current midsize offerings, the GMC Canyon/Chevy Colorado, Toyota Tacoma, and Nissan Frontier, are based on surprisingly dated technology.

New and used midsize trucks continue to command outsized prices.

Take the newest of the three, the Colorado and Canyon: While the truck is a big improvement in driving dynamics from its predecessors, its platform is a reengineered version of the company’s international truck. This design was geared for rough and ready use in the developing world, rather than the sort of urban cowboys who make up most of the American truck buying public. As such, it lacks in refinement when compared to GM’s full-size trucks developed for the American market.

The newly refreshed Toyota Tacoma will also wade into battle with outdated components. Yes, the platform has been updated with higher strength and lower weight materials, but the basic design appears unaltered, and in fact hasn’t been changed significantly since the truck first appeared in the 1990s. Likewise, the base four cylinder and many other components will be carried over unchanged from the previous vehicle.

The natural response may be to say, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it,” and there is certainly something to that sentiment. However, when the slow pace of change on midsize trucks is compared to the radical improvements in full-size trucks, things look a bit different.

For example, the current Ram 1500 EcoDiesel gets better mileage than the four-cylinder Canyon, and the new F-150 manages only 1mpg less than the V6-powered Canyon. Even the Canyon’s V6-driven big brother, the Sierra 1500, manages to come within a couple mpg of the smaller Canyon.

While, mileage is only one measure of quality, full-size trucks are also making more rapid progress in areas like ride, refinement, and capability. This despite the fact that the gulf in price between well equipped mid-size offerings and moderately equipped full size trucks is often minimal.

The problem

So if midsize truck development is lagging so far behind, why aren’t more automakers stepping into the gap to grab market share? The answers aren’t simple, but you don’t have to dig far to find them.

The first and most straightforward is cost. One of the main factors in vehicle cost is development, and those costs can be staggering. For example the all-new Volvo XC90 may have cost north of $2 billion to design and develop. Actual production costs are not nearly as big as a factor in final price.

Volvo XC90

The price for designing a midsize truck is not that much lower than a comparable fullsize vehicle. Yet the lower sale price, means a lower profit margin for the maker.

During the height of the SUV craze it was easier to offset these costs by using a midsize truck platform across a range of products. For example, the first two generations of Ford Explorer were based on the Ranger pickup, likewise the Chevy Trailblazer and Colorado, and Dodge’s Durango and Dakota. These days small and midsize SUVs have disappeared in favor of car-based crossovers. The current Ford Explorer shares its underpinnings with the Ford Taurus, for example.

Full-size trucks are making more rapid progress in areas like ride, refinement, and capability.

America’s unique import export laws create further difficulty for automakers looking to amortize costs for truck development. The so called “Chicken Tax,” a law leftover from a poultry export dispute in the 1960’s, places incredibly high duty on trucks imported from outside the United States. The result is that automakers who hope to make a profit on U.S. truck sales are almost forced to build them in country. This keeps out some international models like the Volkswagen Amarok, or even complicates matters for domestic automakers. For example, GM had to invest $380 million in expanding a Missouri facility to produce its new midsize trucks.

This is good for the local economy, but ups the costs and risks of entering the midsize truck market.

The Future

The result of all of these issues is a challenging market that primarily exists because there are consumers who want to own city-sized pickups. In fact, GM believes that the customers for its new midsize trucks will choose them not because they can’t afford a full-size option but because they simply prefer something a bit smaller.

This group is fundamentally a niche. It may be worthy of attention, but one that automakers clearly don’t think is a major cash cow. Ford and Ram have already said as much by announcing that they have no plans to reenter the midsize truck field.

Instead, automakers have been replacing midsize trucks as their entry-level commercial vehicles with small vans like the Ford Transit Connect or the Ram ProMaster city. Automakers expect these vehicles to fill the same need for cheap, rugged, utilitarian vehicles that can share development costs across borders and oceans.

The one ray of light for American truck diehards is the arrival of light-duty diesel. GM’s new mid-size trucks will be getting a 2.4-liter diesel starting in 2016. Engines like this have the potential to not only drastically improve on the efficiency of full-size trucks, while simultaneously upping their utility with generous helpings of torque.

Whether or not this advance catches on with other automakers is anyone’s guess, but it may offer a great reason to go small.

Product Review

You won't buy Microsoft's Surface Hub 2S, but it could still change your life

The Microsoft Surface Hub 2S wants to change the way you collaborate at work. That’s a lofty goal most devices fail to achieve, but the unique Hub 2S could be an exception. And trust us – you’re going to want it.
Trash

Smash your carrier shackles with the best unlocked phones

If you want the freedom to switch carriers at will or you prefer to get your phone directly from the company that makes it, you'll want to buy an unlocked smartphone. These are the best unlocked phones you can buy in the U.S.
Cars

Would you buy the Tarok compact pickup truck? Volkswagen wants to know

The Volkswagen Tarok pickup truck concept will make its United States debut at the 2019 New York Auto Show. The truck first appeared at the 2018 Sao Paulo Auto Show, and VW wants to see what U.S. buyers think of it.
Smart Home

What you need to know before buying a new washer and dryer

Washers and dryers are big, expensive appliances that you'll want to last for decades. Our buying guide will help you sift through all the options and find the best machines for you.
Cars

More tech and more space make the Mercedes-Benz GLS the S-Class of the SUV world

Mercedes-Benz introduced the second-generation GLS at the 2019 New York Auto Show. The company's biggest and most luxurious SUV gains more tech features in its quest to become the S-Class of the SUV world.
Cars

Sick of civilization? Volkswagen’s Atlas Basecamp concept lets you get away

Volkswagen revealed the Atlas Basecamp concept ahead of its debut at the 2019 New York Auto Show. Built for overlanding, this family-hauler was upgraded jointly by Volkswagen and aftermarket manufacturers.
Cars

The 2020 Nissan GT-R Nismo sheds weight, uses racing tricks to stay sharp

The 2020 Nissan GT-R Nismo isn't dramatically different from the 2019 model, but Nissan made changes where it counts. The updated GT-R Nismo is lighter and offers better aerodynamic performance, according to Nissan.
Cars

Nikola previews $80K NZT off-road EV speedster with 590 horsepower

Nikola Motor is taking reservations for the NZT, a high-performance, all-electric off-highway vehicle (OHV). The $80,000 NZT has 590 horsepower, 775 foot-pounds of torque, and reaches 60 miles per hour in 4 seconds.
Cars

Bored with stock? The best tuner cars are begging to be modified

Modification has been around almost as long as the automobile itself. Here are 25 of the best tuner cars you can find, ranging from American muscle standouts to Japanese drift cars.
Cars

21 charged in Chicago carsharing heist; 100+ cars stolen, many still missing

More than 100 Mercedes-Benz vehicles belonging to carsharing service Car2Go were stolen in Chicago. Police are still working to recover all of the cars, which are equipped with GPS, and 21 people have been charged.
Cars

The VR goggles you wear to shoot alien ships is helping Magna design car parts

Canadian automotive supplier Magna has started using virtual reality in its research and development department. The technology helps engineers get a better view of what they're working on, whether it's an interior part or a powertrain.
Cars

From rugged wagons to hot sports cars, the 2019 NY Auto Show brought it all

From city cars to supercars, anything goes at the New York Auto Show. Automakers from all over the globe traveled to the 2019 show to unveil their newest concept cars and production models.
Cars

Toyota leads $1 billion investment in Uber’s self-driving tech division

In a move that has been a long time coming, Uber filed its S-1 documents, which sets the stage for the company to finally go public with an initial public offering. The company could be valued at more than $100 billion.
Digital Trends Live

Digital Trends Live: Samsung Galaxy Fold woes, zombie pigs, and more

Today's topics: Samsung Galaxy Fold, Facebook A.I. voice assistants, YouTube comes to Fire TV, facial recognition on airline flights, the SpaceX DART program, Yale's zombie pigs, and much more!