Skip to main content

That’s not gone well: Reliability issues dampen Consumer Reports’ love for the Tesla Model S

You don’t have to look far to find people praising the Tesla Model S. Some of the most enthusiastic praise has come from the road testers at Consumer Reports.

The magazine called the Model S the best car it’s tested since 2007, and named it Best Overall vehicle for 2014.

Recommended Videos

In its latest update on the car – which has just over 15,000 miles on the odometer – staffers report the Model S has “more than its share of problems.”

Those problems include door handles that wouldn’t emerge from the bodywork. The handles normally sit flush to the door to improve aerodynamics, and motor out when needed.

This performance anxiety was cured by an over-the-air software update, which Tesla has used to fix numerous glitches since the Model S has been on sale.

Then, at around 12,00 miles, the car’s central touch screen went blank, a major issue because it controls virtually all vehicle functions, including opening the charge port. This was fixed with a “hard reset” during the car’s annual service.

While it was in the shop, technicians addressed a creaking sound coming from the passenger-side roof pillar area, and replaced the entire third row of seats, just because one buckle was broken.

RELATED: Tesla Model S goes without Google navigation in China

After that, drivers found that the front trunk lid wouldn’t respond to the virtual “button” that opens it. Around the same time, an adapter that allows the Model S to plug into non-Tesla charging stations fell apart.

As warranty claims, both issues were resolved free of charge (no pun intended).

While the love affair appears to be over, Consumer Reports emphasized that its staffers’ experiences with the Model S are anecdotal, and won’t affect the magazine’s overall reliability rating for the car. That’s determined by a survey of owners.

Many of those owners may be having an easier time. Unlike many other carmakers, Tesla doesn’t wait until a new model year to implement significant changes. It’s been steadily addressing problems found with early production cars, like Consumer Reports’ 2012 model.

Still, if an owner experienced this many problems, or the drive-unit issues reported by Edmunds, it’s hard to imagine them sticking with Tesla.

All cars develop problems over time, and several carmakers have even managed to survive despite legendary reputations for unreliability.

However, as a new carmaker selling a new type of car, Tesla can’t afford a negative reputation. Its cars’ reliability will be under the glare of media scrutiny for some time.

Stephen Edelstein
Stephen is a freelance automotive journalist covering all things cars. He likes anything with four wheels, from classic cars…
Topics
Tesla Model S vs. Porsche Taycan: turning heads and snapping necks
A 2021 Tesla Model S.

The Tesla Model S kind of pioneered the concept that electric cars could be cool. When the Model S first launched in 2012, electric cars in general were considered to be slow and a little nerdy. But since then, a range of other attractive EVs have popped up -- including the ultra-cool Porsche Taycan.

If you're looking to fulfill a need for electric speed, you may be deciding between the Model S and the Porsche Taycan -- and it makes sense. They both have a lot to offer. But is one of them truly better? Here's what you need to know.
Design
The first thing to notice about these two cars is their design, as they take a slightly different approach to it. The Tesla Model S has certainly evolved a little over the years, now offering a much sleeker and more modern design than the initial bulb-nosed Model S that was released in 2012. But it also doesn't do that much to stand out, especially in a world where it has become not uncommon to see Teslas on the streets.

Read more
Tesla Model S vs. Model X: Which is right for you?
Tesla Model X

The Tesla Model S was the original cool electric car, boasting a sleek and stylish design and the ability to go superfast. But there's another premium Tesla in the lineup that's also pretty darn quick -- and it offers a whole lot more space to boot. The Tesla Model X offers the same design aesthetic as other Tesla cars, along with a superpowerful electric motor and some other features that you can't find on any other Tesla.

But that doesn't mean it's better than the Model S. In fact, it's not -- it's just different. But which is the better option for your needs? Here's a look at the two cars and what makes them different -- or the same.
Design
Perhaps the most notable difference between the two cars is their design. The Model S is a smaller sedan, while the Model X is marketed as an SUV (though it's perhaps more of a crossover). Regardless of marketing, however, the Model X is basically much larger than the Model S.

Read more
Volkswagen ID.4 vs Tesla Model Y
volkswagen id4 vs tesla model y 2021 id 4 blue charging

The electric car world is seriously heating up, with a number of high-end electric crossovers now available, albeit still at a higher price than comparable gas-powered cars. The Tesla Model Y is one of the first of these, offering the Tesla design, a high-tech software experience, and more. But another one of the older of these models is the Volkswagen ID.4, which was first released in 2021 and also offers among the better electric car experiences out there.

Can the ID.4 compete with one of the best-selling electric cars out there? We put the two head-to-head to find out.
Design
The first thing to compare between these two cars is design, and they take a slightly different approach.

Read more