Skip to main content

Eyewitness Claim Re-Ignites Seagate-Convolve Litigation

seagate-ST31500341AS
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Technology patent battles often drag out for years, and often out-live the disputed technology itself as major players either work around the disputed technology or simply move on to bigger-better-smaller-faster solutions that give them a competitive edge. One such drawn-out patent case involves Seagate Technology—one of the world’s largest makers of hard drives—and Convolve, a company that spun out of the MIT with technology that helped hard drives run more quietly without sacrificing performance. In a patent battle that has raged since (literally) the last century, Convolve has alleged that Seagate essentially stole Convolve’s “sound barrier” technology and began rolling it out in its own hard drive products without licensing the solution from Convolve. Seagate denied the claims, and the companies have been duking it out ever since.

But a new affidavit has the potential to put the case back on the map: the New York Times and other outlets are reporting that a former Seagate employee can offer an eyewitness account of Seagate tampering with evidence in the Convolve case.

Recommended Videos

According to the filing, former Seagate engineer Paul Galloway has offered eyewitness evidence that Seagate violated its non-disclosure agreement with Convolve by distributing information about Convolve’s technologies to its engineers. According to Galloway, Seagate engineers were never told about a non-disclosure agreement, and noise-suppression technologies Seagate went on to implement wee “influenced by Convolve’s technology.” Galloway also claims Seagate destroyed code for a disk dive it was ordered to produce as evidence in the case, and either withheld or destroyed information information on Galloway’s work computer about the technology, along with records of meetings between engineers working on the technology.

According to the filing, Galloway worked at Seagate until mid-2009 and contacted Convolve about the case only after leaving Seagate.

If the allegations in the affidavit bear out, Seagate could be on the hook not only for patent infringement, but subject to criminal charges for tampering with evidence.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
The new Reachy Mini robot can let kids turn play into innovation
The Reachy Mini robot.

The Reachy Mini is an exciting new desktop robot aimed primarily at developers, educators, students, and enthusiasts, or basically anyone interested in creative coding.

There are actually two of them -- Reachy Mini Lite ($299) and Reachy Mini Wireless ($449) -- and both were developed by the prominent AI platform Hugging Face following its recent acquisition of Pollen Robotics. 

Read more
If you’re itching for an HP OMEN MAX gaming laptop, this deal will save you $500
The HP Omen Max gaming laptop with Valorant on the screen.

We've recently published a stunningly positive review of the HP OMEN Max 16. It's got a list of "Pros" a mile long. The single, obligatory con is "Thick and heavy." Considering that it's a gaming laptop, that's practically the equivalent of saying a flashlight is too bright to look at. Thick, and a bit heavy, just comes with the territory. All of this is to say that the review was great and we're fans of the HP OMEN Max 16. As a deal hunter it made me want to go and see if I could find a deal on the HP OMEN Max 16 and I did, sort of. Right now you can get a customizable HP OMEN Max 16t — a laptop that, if it didn't have a separate store page, I would think is identical to the one we reviewed — with a $500 discount, no matter what settings you choose. With the base settings of the laptop, that discount brings it from $2,100 to just $1,600, but you're free to upgrade to your heart's content. Tap the button below to start customizing to your whimsy or keep reading for some advice on how to do so and what to expect from the 16t.

Buy Now

Read more
Google’s AI agent ‘Big Sleep’ just stopped a cyberattack before it started
Sundar Pichai

Google's AI agent, dubbed Big Sleep, has achieved a cybersecurity milestone by detecting and blocking an imminent exploit in the wild—marking the first time an AI has proactively foiled a cyber threat. Developed by Google DeepMind and Project Zero, Big Sleep identified a critical vulnerability in SQLite (CVE-2025-6965), an open-source database engine, that was on the verge of being exploited by malicious actors, allowing Google to patch it before damage occurred. “We believe this is the first time an AI agent has been used to directly foil efforts to exploit a vulnerability in the wild,” the company said.

Why it matters: As cyberattacks surge—costing businesses trillions annually—this breakthrough shifts defense from reactive patching to AI-driven prediction and prevention. It gives security teams a powerful new tool to stay ahead of hackers, potentially saving devices and data worldwide. CEO Sundar Pichai called it "a first for an AI agent—definitely not the last" according to Live Mint.

Read more