Skip to main content

Federal case will decide if the government can make you decrypt your laptop

decrypt laptopRamona Fricosu is a Colorado woman being taken to court on 22 counts of bank fraud, four counts of wire fraud, five counts of false statements to a financial institution, and seven counts of money laundering charges after being accused of trying to take title to foreclosed homes. While the verdict in this mortgage scam won’t set any precedents, the means to that end might. Fricosu is being asked by the federal court to decrypt her laptop and offer up the information found there.

The encrypted laptop was found in a raid of her home, and while courts have requested decryption for laptops before, the motion usually goes unopposed by the defendant. But Fricosu has denied the proposal, and no US appeals court has ever ruled on whether or not encrypted information falls under a citizen’s right to remain silence.

Recommended Videos

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has rushed to Fricosu’s side, arguing that asking her to decrypt her laptop is unconstitutional, and that encryption is a method that protects individuals’ privacy and security. “The government makes an aggressive argument here that may have far-reaching consequences for all encryption users. Fricosu will be made witness against herself if she is forced to supply information that will give prosecutors access to files they speculate will be helpful to their case but cannot identify without specificity.” The Fifth Amendment keeps plaintiffs from providing self-incriminating information in court, and the EFF as well as Fricosu’s lawyer says this is exactly what the court is asking her to do by decrypting her laptop.

The Department of Justine doesn’t quite see it that way. Prosecutors maintain that they are not demanding Fricosu’s password: She can type it in herself without providing it to anyone. They just want access to what’s behind it. They say it’s like asking for a key to a room full of data necessary to reach a verdict – while the defense team says it’s like asking someone to decipher a diary they’ve purposefully written in code.

How the court decides will affect how personal computer security works. If it’s ruled that Fricosu doesn’t have to decrypt her laptop, it will set the precedent in these types of cases and the accused will be able to stand behind this decision. The DOJ has expressed worry that allowing Fricosu to cite the right to remain silent means future criminals can use her as an example and safely hide behind a password.

Molly McHugh
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Before coming to Digital Trends, Molly worked as a freelance writer, occasional photographer, and general technical lackey…
A 2-in-1 has challenged the Surface Pro 11, but not how you might think
The ports shown on the side of the Surface Pro 11.

Microsoft's Surface Pro 11 epitomizes the detachable tablet form of 2-in-1 laptop, and it's come a long way since the company first introduced the form factor over a decade ago. The newest model leveraged Qualcomm's Snapdragon X chipset for strong performance and great battery life, making for the best version of the Surface Pro ever.

But the more popular 2-in-1 format is the 360-degree convertible, where the keyboard flips around from clamshell through tent and media modes into a tablet. HP's new OmniBook Ultra Flip 14, based on Intel's new Core Ultra Series 2 chips, is one of the best laptops in this category. But here's the question: Which makes for the better 2-in-1 experience?
Specs and configurations

Read more
This 24-inch gaming monitor is under $100 at Walmart
An Onn. 24-inch gaming monitor on a desk next to a PC.

Monitor deals are rarely this inexpensive: Walmart just knocked $50 off the Onn. 24-inch FHD Gaming Monitor. Usually priced at $149, it’s down to $99, which is a steal of a deal for a gaming monitor with some great specs. If that instantly sounds appealing to you, keep reading while we take you through what the Onn. 24-inch FHD gaming monitor has to offer for the price. The deal is proving popular already, so don’t count on it sticking around for much longer.

Why you should buy the Onn. 24-inch FHD gaming monitor
While you might not think of Onn. as making some of the best monitors, you’ll be pleasantly surprised by the Onn. 24-inch FHD gaming monitor. It’s a 24-inch 1080p/full HD monitor with an impressive refresh rate of 165Hz. That means even if you’re playing action-packed games that are moving quickly, you won’t have to worry so much about motion blur as your monitor will be able to keep up with it.

Read more
Early Black Friday gaming laptop deals 2024: Asus, Alienware, Lenovo, more on sale
AMD and Intel logos next to each other on gaming laptops.

Update 11/06/24: November is officially here, and we're only a few weeks away from Black Friday. That means that we're already seeing a lot more deals coming through as retailers ramp up their sales for the big event. We've updated the prices of the deals below, as well as added three more options for you to pick from, so you should find something great below!

Black Friday doesn't officially begin until November 29. As that's near the tail end of November, it doesn't take a long ponder to realize that the big shopping holiday is quite some time away. However, if you're in the mood and market for a new gaming laptop, you don't really need to wait. Retailers and companies are already pushing out deals on serviceable gaming laptops now. Some of them are even on the best gaming laptops available. So, if you want to get started on your portable gaming journey, there's no need to wait until the last minute, you can get started with these great deals now.
Dell G15 — $920 $1,150 20% off

Read more