Skip to main content

Federal case will decide if the government can make you decrypt your laptop

decrypt laptopRamona Fricosu is a Colorado woman being taken to court on 22 counts of bank fraud, four counts of wire fraud, five counts of false statements to a financial institution, and seven counts of money laundering charges after being accused of trying to take title to foreclosed homes. While the verdict in this mortgage scam won’t set any precedents, the means to that end might. Fricosu is being asked by the federal court to decrypt her laptop and offer up the information found there.

The encrypted laptop was found in a raid of her home, and while courts have requested decryption for laptops before, the motion usually goes unopposed by the defendant. But Fricosu has denied the proposal, and no US appeals court has ever ruled on whether or not encrypted information falls under a citizen’s right to remain silence.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has rushed to Fricosu’s side, arguing that asking her to decrypt her laptop is unconstitutional, and that encryption is a method that protects individuals’ privacy and security. “The government makes an aggressive argument here that may have far-reaching consequences for all encryption users. Fricosu will be made witness against herself if she is forced to supply information that will give prosecutors access to files they speculate will be helpful to their case but cannot identify without specificity.” The Fifth Amendment keeps plaintiffs from providing self-incriminating information in court, and the EFF as well as Fricosu’s lawyer says this is exactly what the court is asking her to do by decrypting her laptop.

The Department of Justine doesn’t quite see it that way. Prosecutors maintain that they are not demanding Fricosu’s password: She can type it in herself without providing it to anyone. They just want access to what’s behind it. They say it’s like asking for a key to a room full of data necessary to reach a verdict – while the defense team says it’s like asking someone to decipher a diary they’ve purposefully written in code.

How the court decides will affect how personal computer security works. If it’s ruled that Fricosu doesn’t have to decrypt her laptop, it will set the precedent in these types of cases and the accused will be able to stand behind this decision. The DOJ has expressed worry that allowing Fricosu to cite the right to remain silent means future criminals can use her as an example and safely hide behind a password.

Molly McHugh
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Before coming to Digital Trends, Molly worked as a freelance writer, occasional photographer, and general technical lackey…
The 23andMe data breach just keeps getting scarier
A 23andMe kit

The 23andMe breach that took place in October has been confirmed as much worse than originally reported, affecting 6.9 million people, as opposed to the 14,000 users first thought.

Information stolen in the breach included users' full names, birth years, relationship labels, and locations. Approximately 1.4 million users also had Family Tree profile information on the service compromised. Hackers could also access genetic information in the breach, including details about common DNA percentages shared with relatives, and specifics such as chromosome matching, according to a spokesperson.

Read more
Apple has a chance to fix its worst product next year
Magic Mouse next to a Mac keyboard on a desk.

Apple updated all of its Mac desktops in 2024, but left the worst part untouched: the accessories. In particular, we're talking about the infamous Magic Mouse. The mouse has been dunked on for years at this point, often pointed to as an example of the worst of Apple's design ethos. Despite all the positive changes to Macs over the past few years, the Magic Mouse has remained stagnant.

A new report, however, indicates that the Mac accessories will undergo a major change in early 2024. The Magic Keyboard, Magic Trackpad, and Magic Mouse will reportedly all be moving to USB-C to match the latest iPhone, after having previously used the Apple-exclusive Lightning connection. This seems like an obvious change that probably should have happened earlier. In fact, it was even rumored to happen in time for the launch of the M3 iMac -- but it didn't.

Read more
Apple has a chance to fix Mac gaming for good in 2024
Lies of P being played on an iMac.

Looking back, 2023 was a banner year for Mac gaming. As a gamer, it feels really surreal to say that, given how disappointing the past has been. But it’s true -- and for the first time in a long time, the sun is shining on Mac gamers.

We’ve had the M3 series of chips with hardware ray tracing, mesh shading, and improved GPUs. On the software side, Apple has built-in tools like Game Mode and a game porting toolkit into macOS. And some massive games have come to the Mac, including Baldur’s Gate 3 and Lies of P.

Read more