Skip to main content

Google denies claim that it’s tracking internet users when incognito mode is on

Google search
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Google is disputing a study released by competing privacy-focused search engine DuckDuckGo that claims the search giant is tracking users across the internet in order to deliver personalized search results, even when incognito mode is enabled. DuckDuckGo claimed that Google is using personal information — ranging from search and browsing history to online purchases — to tailor search results in what the competitor calls “Google’s filter bubble.”

Recommended Videos

“These editorialized results are informed by the personal information Google has on you (like your search, browsing, and purchase history), and puts you in a bubble based on what Google’s algorithms think you’re most likely to click on,” DuckDuckGo said in a blog post outlining its privacy research study. As part of its findings, DuckDuckGo noted that participants saw search results that were unique to them. Moreover, enabling private browsing mode did little to affect how search results could vary from user to user. “Private browsing mode and being logged out of Google offered very little filter bubble protection. These tactics simply do not provide the anonymity most people expect. In fact, it’s simply not possible to use Google search and avoid its filter bubble.

“We saw that when randomly comparing people’s private modes to each other, there was more than double the variation than when comparing someone’s private mode to their normal mode,” DuckDuck Go continued. “We often hear of confusion that private browsing mode enables anonymity on the web, but this finding demonstrates that Google tailors search results regardless of browsing mode.”

Of concern are search results delivered when users searched for political topics, DuckDuckGo highlighted. The company explored how search results related to political topics may have impacted the 2012 presidential election after the publication of a 2012 Wall Street Journal article that claimed Google “often customizes the results of people who have recently searched for ‘Obama’ — but not those who have recently searched for ‘Romney.'” The influence of technology companies on politics has been called into question in recent months, and Google was part of a legislative inquiry after the company received criticism from President Donald Trump that the search engine may have used its position to censor conservative voices, a charge that Google continues to vehemently deny.

Following the publication of the DuckDuckGo’s privacy research on 9to5 Google, Google disputed the study, noting that the research methods were flawed. “This study’s methodology and conclusions are flawed since they are based on the assumption that any difference in search results are based on rationalization,” Google retorted. “That is simply not true. In fact, there are a number of factors that can lead to slight differences, including time and location, which this study doesn’t appear to have controlled for effectively.”

This isn’t the first time that Google has been under fire for privacy confusion related to incognito mode. When Google launched its updated Chrome 69 browser, the company faced backlash after researchers pointed out that the use of cookies may still allow Google to follow you on the internet even when private browsing mode is enabled, a hypothesis that Google refuted.

Chuong Nguyen
Silicon Valley-based technology reporter and Giants baseball fan who splits his time between Northern California and Southern…
You can now have secret chats with Google’s Gemini in incognito mode
Launching Gemini Deep Research query on Chrome desktop.

You can now have a quick chat with Gemini on your web browser without having to sign in first. And, to speed up the process, the Gemini website even takes you directly to the chat window instead of showing you a landing page first.

This move, spotted by 9To5Google, is pretty smart as it allows unconvinced users to try out the product with no strings attached. With any luck, they'll enjoy the experience and decide to sign up to get access to more of the features.

Read more
Google AI Mode will reinvent Search. I’m worried — and you should be, too
Google AI Mode for Search.

Update: A Google spokesperson responded to our queries. The story has been updated with their answers in a dedicated section below. 

Google is pushing forward with more AI into how internet search works. Remember AI Overviews, which essentially summarizes the content pulled from websites, and presents it at the top of the Google Search page?

Read more
Google Taara could deliver internet at the speed of light
A beam of light.

Everyone knows the woes of slow internet connection speeds, but the Google Taara chip could provide Internet to previously unreachable areas — and at speeds of up to 20Gbps per second. This project has been in development for years, but the team behind it just announced the next-generation Taara chip.

Taara is a silicon photonic chip, which is a technical way of saying it transmits data through the air using beams of light. The original version of Taara worked, but it had limitations — namely, the complicated series of mirrors and hardware needed to adjust the direction of the beam. The new version utilizes advanced software to steer the beam.

Read more