Skip to main content

How to fix HP: A new CEO can’t do it alone

hewlett-packard-headquarters
Image used with permission by copyright holder

This last week has been full of corporate drama. Google is apparently being pounded by the US Senate for its “bait and switch” strategy, and HP’s brand new CEO, Leo Apotheker, is already rumored to be out. Rumors suggest that HP’s new board member Meg Whitman is likely to replace him if booted. I think that would be an incredibly bad idea, because it would basically repeat the mistake Yahoo’s board made with Carol Bartz. My friend Lance Ulanoff (who recently landed at Mashable) argues that Mark Hurd would be a better choice, and with due respect to Lance, I think this is just nuts.

So let’s focus on HP and its ongoing CEO troubles this week.

Tightening the leaky faucet

First off, HP has a serious leak problem. Just before this most recent drip, word leaked about the HP board considering spinning off its PC business, causing HP investors to flee the company. I expect PC buyers did the same, particularly in corporate accounts, and all of this because HP was just considering options. The board was supposedly 18 months from a decision, which means by the time they actually did anything, two or more years would have passed. Nothing that far out is certain in technology, and it is kind of silly to worry about it, just like it was silly to make this announcement. The cause was the leak, and with all of this drama, the criminal inside of HP (this is insider information, and disclosure rules were clearly violated) who made it should be found, prosecuted, and fired.

If they can’t contain information about what HP’s board is thinking of as confidential, no CEO will be successful. This needs to be fixed first.

Leo-ApothekerLeo Apotheker

This poor guy was brought onboard HP to dramatically change the company. He has been CEO for 10 months now, much of which he has spent being chased by Oracle’s legal team, as Oracle sought to draw HP into its litigation with SAP. Oracle won that litigation, but recently lost its $1.3-billion judgment for it because it couldn’t actually show damages. During this time, he has been plagued by the aforementioned leaks, likely coming from someone who wants his job. His board, the ones who put him in the job, was largely replaced because they mishandled Mark Hurd’s separation. In addition, he was handed a company that Mark Hurd had gutted. Employee loyalty and satisfaction were at historic lows, and divisions were finding it hard to execute their tasks because of excessive layoffs. One of the first things he had to do was restore some of the performance incentives that Hurd had cut to refocus employees on their jobs, but hurt HP’s bottom line. Yes, things have kind of gone to hell in a hand basket, but to be fair, most were outside his control.

Now, Apotheker did make one $10-billion acquisition, which appeared excessive, but recall that Oracle had gone to war with HP and was attacking their shared customers, so HP had to rapidly build a stronger software portfolio. That is going to be expensive.

I sincerely think it is too early to pull the plug on Apotheker, unless the new board wants to go in a completely different direction than the old board, and Internet services likely aren’t a good choice for HP.

meg-whitmanMeg Whitman

This takes us to Meg Whitman, who had a mixed history at eBay and a failed attempt to run for Governor of the State of California. HP is made up of five pillars that include software, hardware (servers and PCs), services, networking (the old 3Com), and printing. Apotheker struggled because Hurd gutted the software portion of the company, and this is what needed to be rapidly rebuilt when Oracle declared war and breached their partnership. But HP has no Internet service business to speak of, and that is Meg Whitman’s area of expertise. Recall Yahoo and Carol Bartz, the CEO the company got from Autodesk. She was a capable CEO, but her background in tightly targeted packaged software was a mismatch for a company that is basically in the Internet publishing business. Ironically, Whitman is likely far more qualified to run Yahoo than she is to run HP. Finally, recall that she largely lost the election because she alienated the State’s Hispanic base. She did this by showing disloyalty to her long-time illegal alien housekeeper. The attorney who effectively caused Whitman’s loss, Gloria Allred, is the same one who effectively got Mark Hurd fired. As showcased by all the leaks, HP has a loyalty problem at the moment, thanks to Hurd. Getting a CEO who also appears to have a loyalty problem would just make this worse, unless this is overtly addressed.

As I finish this, it looks like she may have the job, and she is a capable CEO. But to be successful, she will have to stop the leaks and fix the loyalty problem. In short, she’ll have to surround herself with loyal people who know HP and aggressively stamp out disloyalty. With the right team, and as a temporary solution, she could run the company, but HP would have to learn from Yahoo’s mistakes, and HP’s board would have to learn from their predecessors’ mistakes with Carly Fiorina (who also had political ambitions). This isn’t to say that people can’t change, or that these problems can’t be managed, but it says they must be, or Whitman could be worse than Apotheker.

mark-hurdMark Hurd

Most of the problems HP is currently having seemed to track back to Mark Hurd. From employee issues to the weakness in HP’s software unit, to the Palm collapse, critical decisions track back to Hurd or his cronies in HP. He was fired not because he violated expense policy, but because board members felt he was lying to them and covering up insider information leaks made to his mistress. These are serious allegations that have recently led to criminal charges for a number of executives in other companies. His settlement with the mistress effectively sealed the evidence, barring the HP board from doing an investigation, giving the board no choice but to force his resignation. You can’t have a CEO who doesn’t follow corporate policies, that the board believes may have behaved illegally and covered it up, and that they don’t trust. The “Burn Your Eyes” letter that effectively got Hurd fired still hasn’t been disclosed.

Wrapping up

I’ll end as I started: Unless HP can fix the leak problem, no CEO will be successful at the company. Apotheker hasn’t been given enough time to learn the job, let alone do it, and HP is a far more complex company than SAP was. While I think it too early to replace him, Whitman could do the job if she were properly supported and backstopped for a short period (and she is being positioned as “interim”). But to truly fix the problem, HP needs a true leader who is matched to the company.

IBM had a leadership conference this last week, and a collection of international CEOs, presidents from emerging countries, and leadership experts defined who HP should look for. That person has a vision that HP can execute, a passion for making the company better than when they found it, the ability to lead, and love for facts upon which they make their decisions. What they don’t need is another CEO who would rather be in politics, like Carly Fiorina, or one that is only passionate about his own benefits, like Mark Hurd.

Rob Enderle
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Rob is President and Principal Analyst of the Enderle Group, a forward-looking emerging technology advisory firm. Before…
This Samsung Odyssey G9 OLED gaming monitor deal is perfect for Super Bowl LIX
Kena Bridge of Spirits on the Samsung Odyssey OLED G9.

If you're planning to watch Super Bowl LIX on your computer, you've still got time to upgrade with monitor deals. For the best possible experience, you'll want a top-quality screen like the 49-inch Samsung Odyssey OLED G9 curved gaming monitor, which is on sale from Samsung at $300 off. From its original price of $1,700, it's down to $1,400 -- still pretty expensive, but since it's going to serve as an excellent display long after the big game, it will be worth every single penny. You need to hurry with your purchase if you want it delivered in time though!

Why you should buy the 49-inch Samsung Odyssey OLED G9 curved gaming monitor
Many of the reasons why the Samsung Odyssey OLED G9 secured a spot in our list of the best gaming monitors also make it a fantastic screen for watching Super Bowl LIX. You'll enjoy amazing image quality with impressive color accuracy and deep contrast, so you won't miss anything that's happening on the field, while its 240Hz refresh rate will deliver incredible motion clarity so you'll catch all the action as it unfolds. It also runs on Samsung's Tizen operating system, so you have the option of accessing the streaming service where you're planning to watch the big game directly from the gaming monitor.

Read more
Watch Super Bowl LIX on the insane Samsung Odyssey Ark — on sale!
A person playing video games on the Samsung 55-inch Odyssey Ark curved gaming monitor 2nd Gen.

Planning to watch a spectacle like Super Bowl LIX is a perfect reason to splurge on monitor deals, so why not go all out with the second-generation Samsung Odyssey Ark curved gaming monitor? This premium screen, which is originally priced at $2,700, is down to $2,000 from Samsung following a $700 discount. It's still far from being called affordable, but it's going to be an amazing display for watching the big game. You're going to have to hurry with your purchase if you want to have it delivered on time though, so stop hesitating!

Why you should buy the second-generation Samsung Odyssey Ark curved gaming monitor
The second-generation Samsung Odyssey Ark may have been built for video games, but it's also going to be fantastic way to watch Super Bowl LIX. The gaming monitor offers a 55-inch curved screen that fills your field of vision for maximum immersion, a 165Hz refresh rate for smooth movements, and Sound Dome technology with four corner speakers and two central woofers for impressive sound. You'll be able to see and hear every detail of the big game! The second-generation Samsung Odyssey Ark also functions as a smart TV, if you want to watch the event directly from the monitor instead of through your computer.

Read more
List price for RTX 50-series GPUs might be officially dead
RTX 5090.

There's no doubt that Nvidia's new RTX 50-series GPUs are expensive, despite ranking among some of the best graphics cards you can buy. It's looking like prices will remain high in the immediate future. Both MSI and Asus have introduced price increases for their RTX 50-series models, with MSI completely doing away with cards at list price, as reported by VideoCardz.

The new RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 are sold out everywhere, but MSI and Asus are two brands that still list official prices online. You can't buy these cards, but it's a look inside where prices are headed once cards become available again. MSI has completely done away with models at MSRP, with its most inexpensive card, the RTX 5080 Ventus, now listed for $1,140. Most of MSI's RTX 5080 offerings range from $1,300 to $1,500, marking anywhere from a $300 to $500 increase over list price.

Read more