Skip to main content

Keep dreaming. Microsoft’s ‘mixed reality’ visions remain out of reach

1179860 autosave v1 microsoftbuildday2 featured
Microsoft may have the best demos of any consumer tech company, ever. Consistently, year after year, it hits press events and conferences with beautiful, well-paced showpieces that demonstrate how new technology can accomplish the impossible.

Virtual and augmented reality have provided the company with an opportunity to exercise this creativity. At Build 2017 we saw new motion controllers, a Cirque du Soleil set designed and refined with HoloLens, and real-time use of holograms to design chair lifts, among other things.

It all looked great, yet there’s a problem. Microsoft’s real-world rollout of its ideas has fallen behind and so far, appeared for only a limited audience. That makes it hard to take the company’s mind-bending ideas seriously.

Motion controller magic

The biggest VR news from Build 2017 was undoubtedly Microsoft’s new Windows Mixed Reality motion controllers. Based on inside-out tracking technology, the controllers base their position off the headset and their internal sensors, rather than external base stations.

It’s hard to take these mind-bending ideas seriously.

They simplify setup and make multi-room use possible. Better yet, they seem reasonably priced. An Acer Mixed Reality Headset bundle was revealed at $399, just $100 more than the headset on its own.

All that sounds great, but hold on. The controllers weren’t present at Build 2017. They weren’t even shown on stage. While Microsoft answered a few general questions about the controllers in a press session, the specifics weren’t provided.

Fool me once…

Of course, it’s perfectly OK for Microsoft to tease a product. A reveal doesn’t need to have all the details.

The problem is not with the motion controllers’ reveal, but instead in the pattern they’re a part of. Since HoloLens first appeared, Microsoft has continually demonstrated VR, AR, and now Mixed Reality devices without firm release dates, and with only vague technical details.

Tools for Traveling Through a New Reality

Repeatedly, these projects have taken much longer to appear than initially hoped. HoloLens appeared in January of 2015, yet it still lacks any tangible plans for broad release. Windows Mixed Reality was shown first in conjunction with the Windows 10 Creators Update, implying they would launch together. Now, it appears we’ll have to wait until holiday 2017 to see a headset that doesn’t have “dev kit” in its title.

Then we have the elephant in the room — Paint 3D. Touted as a content creation tool for Windows Mixed Reality, the version delivered with the Creators Update is little more than a toy. It’s completely unsuited for 3D printing or serious content creation, and its disappointing execution undermined the heart of the Creators Update.

Let’s see the proof

There may be reason for Microsoft’s delays and lack of detail. As our own Mark Coppock argued several months ago, Microsoft’s casual pace may be due to its desire to create platforms rather than individual devices. In other words, the goal may be an ecosystem of devices, rather than a particular device.

Which may be true.

Still, Microsoft should consider holding back the fireworks until the fuse is lit. It’s hard to get pumped about the next big thing when the last few big things still haven’t launch — or exploded on the launch platform.

Editors' Recommendations

Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
Apple’s AR/VR headset gets one step closer to a reality
Apple VR Headset Concept by Antonio De Rosa

Apple's rumored first step into AR and VR has been hush-hush, but a new report indicates that the mixed-reality headset may be getting closer to its grand unveiling.

As reported by Bloomberg, Apple's board got a sneak peek at the company's upcoming mixed-reality headset at a quarterly meeting. This meeting was attended by "eight independent directors" and CEO Tim Cook.

Read more
Apple mixed reality headset may launch in 2022 after all
Apple VR Headset Concept by Antonio De Rosa

After months of rumors and speculation, the new augmented reality and virtual reality headset from Apple has completed production tests, according to MacRumors.

The production tests were part of ongoing efforts to make sure the headset meets Apple's design standards. The news comes from one of the component suppliers for the headset, and the device is expected to launch late this year. However, that timeline is hardly a consensus among industry experts. Bloomberg's Mark Gurman, for example, doubts it will happen, citing issues with the design process.

Read more
Turns out Microsoft’s HoloLens 3 might not be dead after all
microsoft hololens 2

Recent rumors indicated that Microsoft's next-generation Hololens 3 mixed reality headset could be dead, but now there's a chance that might not be true at all. In a tweet, Alex Kipman, who invented HoloLens and is currently a technical fellow at Microsoft, seemed to indicate that the product could still be alive.

As a recap, the whole saga started after a Business Insider report revealed the state of internal disarray and uncertainty within the HoloLens Team. The report also indicated that Microsoft could be working with Samsung on a next-generation headset, and HoloLens 3 was canceled in the middle of last year when that project began. Kipman, though, says not to "believe what you read on the internet," and that "HoloLens is doing great."

Read more