Skip to main content

No Flash for You: Dissecting Steve Jobs’ Flash Explanation

flash-steve-jobsAdobe has had its words over Apple snubbing Flash on the iPad. And now Steve Jobs has had his.

In a small “town-hall-style” meeting within Apple following the launch of the iPad last week, Jobs apparently told employees that Flash would soon be made obsolete by HTML5, and that it’s too buggy, obviating the need for it in the iPad.

Recommended Videos

While there’s a kernel of truth to both assertions, Jobs’ cocky Flash-bashing still seems to miss the point on both accounts.

The distant future doesn’t matter. We need Flash now.

Is HTML5 the future? Almost certainly. For instance, both YouTube and Vimeo have rolled out HTML5 betas that let you skirt Flash and use HTML5 instead. Even Google’s controversial Google Voice app for the iPhone – which is actually not an app but a sophisticated Web page – uses HTML5. Clearly, HTML5 has legs, and it’s coming soon.

But “coming soon” doesn’t cut it. It could be years until we see HTML5 roll out in full force. The team developing HTML5 doesn’t even expect it to receive the first level of recommendation from the World Wide Web Consortium (the group that governs international Web standards,) until 2012. According to them, the third and final maturity recommendation likely won’t occur until 2022.

apple-ipad-no-flash-2Meanwhile, the Apple iPad will launch in less than 60 days.

Parts of HTML5 will be useable before that – and even work now – but opting for a work in progress seems hypocritical while you simultaneously bash its predecessor for unreliability. “There is no real test suite, there are many parts of the spec that are lacking real implementations, there are big parts that aren’t interoperable, and the spec has hundreds if not thousands of known errors that haven’t been fixed,” HTML5 developer WHATWG writes in its own wiki entry.

Even if HTML5 clicked over to final, perfect and unchangeable specifications today, Flash would remain a live part of the Web for years to come, making Steve Jobs’ tunnel vision even sillier.

We’ll live with crashes.

We can’t verify Apple’s assertion that the majority of OS X crashes are due to Flash – the company keeps all its Crash Reporter data private. But for the sake of argument, let’s trust them.

We still need it. Like a lot of shoddy products, people continue to use Flash because it mostly works: for video, music, games, intense Web graphics, apps, and whatever else developers use it for.

Shunning Flash because it sometimes crashes, or because it’s a closed-source plugin that makes the Web a less flexible place (like QuickTime) makes a nice academic approach, but ignores the reality of browsing the Web today.

Apple’s desire to keep users safe from crashes takes a straight-jacket approach: You can’t hurt yourself when you can’t do anything. Simply offering the option to turn off Flash when you want a safer browsing experience would make a perfectly acceptable compromise for users who want to walk outside the padded asylum walls Apple wants to put them in.

Sorry, Steve. We just don’t buy your Flash fairy tales. The iPad needs it.

Nick Mokey
As Digital Trends’ Editor in Chief, Nick Mokey oversees an editorial team covering every gadget under the sun, along with…
Apple’s gaming push is heating up faster than you think
Frostpunk 2 runs on a MacBook.

A few years back, I was invited to meet with Apple about its new push into gaming. The company wouldn’t show me a flashy new product to enable that. Instead, it showed me something more modest: No Man’s Sky running smoothly on a MacBook. It looked great, but it wasn’t exactly earth-shattering. It was an independent game from 2016 running on a laptop as well as it had already been running for years on other PCs. I got the sense that I wasn’t there to cover a big development in tech, but rather to see a proof of concept that had bigger plans attached.

Years later, those plans are coming into focus even if they still aren’t fully realized yet. I recently attended a repeat of that showcase, only this time I wasn’t just watching an eight-year-old game running on a laptop. I demoed several games, including brand new ones, this time running on a range of devices including the MacBook Air M3 and a 13” iPad Pro M4. While we’re still a long ways away from the App Store being up to snuff with Steam on Windows, I’m starting to see where gaming on iOS is headed -- and Apple is getting there faster than I expected.
Growing gaming
During my recent session with Apple, I’d get to see and play several games running across iPhone, iPad, and Macbooks. Some of those experiences are more exciting for Apple than for casual players. It’s neat that Resident Evil 7 can run well on an iPhone, but that’s not so surprising when I already know that the much more recent Resident Evil 4 does too. I’m happy to see games like Control and Valheim looking great, but those are existential wins for Apple as it seeks more partners to expand its gaming efforts. I don’t imagine that gamers are jumping to play games that have been out for years on an Apple device (and according to reports, they very much aren’t yet).

Read more
Steve Jobs predicted Apple Intelligence almost 40 years ago
Steve Jobs in Steve Jobs: The Man in the Machine.

The generative AI revolution began long before ChatGPT made its debut in November 2022. Computer Science researchers and sci-fi authors alike have been imagining the potential of thinking, feeling computers from the days of pulling literal bugs out of mainframes. Visionary Apple co-founder Steve Jobs was just as enamored with that ideal, as he describes in this 1985 video recording, almost 40 years ago.

https://twitter.com/vijayshekhar/status/1702939329654661278

Read more
How the new iPad Pro is changing everything for the MacBook
M4 iPad Pro with Magic Keyboard.

iPad Pro (M4) Nadeem Sarwar / Digital Trends

If Apple products from the last decade are known for anything, it’s for being incredibly thin and light. Now, almost five years to the day since former head designer Jony Ive left Apple, his obsession for weightlessness looks set to come roaring back at the company that once employed him.

Read more