Skip to main content

Supermicro investigation: no spy chips found on our motherboards

Computer motherboard stock photo
Fancycrave.com/Pexels

Computer hardware manufacturer Supermicro announced on Tuesday the results of an investigation into its recent motherboard security controversy.

In a letter posted on its website, Supermicro’s CEO, Charles Liang addressed recent allegations stemming from a story published by Bloomberg which reported that China’s spies had been able to insert malicious hardware into Supermicro’s motherboards during the manufacturing process. The letter went on to state that Supermicro’s investigation was conducted by a third-party investigations firm which concluded that no malicious hardware had been found on the motherboards that had been tested.

The motherboards tested included the specific type mentioned in Bloomberg’s article, motherboards that had been purchased by the companies mentioned in the article, and “more recently manufactured motherboards.”  Reuters reports that the investigation was completed by the firm Nardello & Co.

Tuesday’s letter from Supermicro also described the safeguards it has in place to prevent such security issues. The most notable of the safeguards, regarding the kind of tampering that was alleged recently, was the company’s promise that “no single employee, team, or contractor has unrestricted access to our complete board design.”

Bloomberg’s report was particularly troubling since if true, it would mean those malicious chips may have compromised the security of the data centers of Supermicro’s biggest clients, specifically Amazon and Apple.

Amazon and Apple quickly denied Bloomberg’s report in October, within hours of the story’s publication online. Apple’s statement specifically stated that it “repeatedly explained to Bloomberg reporters and editors over the past 12 months, there is no truth to these claims.”

Amazon’s response was via a blog post and swiftly denied the presence of the spy chips:

“At no time, past or present, have we ever found any issues relating to modified hardware or malicious chips in SuperMicro motherboards in any Elemental or Amazon systems. Nor have we engaged in an investigation with the government.”

Bloomberg continued to stand by its story even though calls for a retraction had been issued by Apple CEO Tim Cook and the chief executive of Amazon Web Services Andy Jassy. Bloomberg Businessweek also issued a statement soon after the article was published, saying that they were confident in their reporting and mentioned that 100 interviews and 17 individual sources confirmed their report.

Editors' Recommendations

Anita George
Anita has been a technology reporter since 2013 and currently writes for the Computing section at Digital Trends. She began…
Apple just did something unprecedented with its new M3 chips
Logos for Apple's M3 chips.

Apple announced the M3 series of chips today but has switched up the rollout in a significant way. In previous years, the company started with the base configuration of the chip series, whether that's the M1 or the M2. The initial releases would build the foundation of what these chips could do on entry-level devices like the MacBook Air or Mac mini.

Intel rolls out its chips in a similar way, starting its annual refresh of laptop chips with its entry-level stuff first.

Read more
Even Intel’s best chips won’t catch up with Apple, TSMC CEO says
Intel CEO talking about Meteor Lake

You might not know it, but all of Apple’s chips are made by a company called TSMC. They're widely considered to be far more advanced than any chip rival Intel is pumping out at the moment, and now, TSMC has declared that things are going to stay that way.

The comments come after Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger said his company would catch up with Apple’s chips by next year, with the intention of surpassing them in terms of power and efficiency.

Read more
It’s time to stop ignoring your motherboard when building a PC
An Asus TUF Gaming Z790 BTF motherboard with hidden connectors, shown from the front.

The motherboard is the spine of your computer, but despite how important it is, it often becomes an afterthought. It's easy to overlook when there are shinier, more exciting components to spend money on, such as a top-notch graphics card.

Buying a motherboard can be a tricky process, because, on the surface, they all seem to do the same thing -- and if they all do the same thing, why should you spend more money on one? There are actually several good reasons to shell out some cash on a midrange to high-end motherboard, and you should be aware of them before you work on your next PC build.
Slots and ports

Read more