Skip to main content

Testing shows Nvdia’s GeForce GTX 1060 outperforming AMD’s Radeon RX 480 in VR

testing gtx 1060 betters rx 480 vr gtx1060
Now that Oculus VR and Facebook have reduced the price of the Oculus Rift, customers have a more affordable option of diving into virtual reality. The bundled headset isn’t exactly cheap, but will likely push customers into grabbing a low-cost graphics card if their current hardware isn’t up to speed. Two affordable options include Nvidia’s GeForce GTX 1060 with 6GB of on-board memory ($300) and AMD’s Radeon RX 480 card with 8GB of onboard memory ($250). But which is the better buy for VR?

A recent test shows that Nvidia’s card comes out ahead. Testing included the use of the Oculus Rift, the HTC Vive, and four games: Chronos, Dirt Rally, Obduction, and Edge of Nowhere. The GTX 1060 outperformed the RX 480 in the first three games while both cards tied in performance in Edge of Nowhere. The cards’ performance was measured using FCAT VR, a frame capture analysis tool in the same vein as FRAPS, but for VR.

That, of course, raises a red flag. The tool is provided by Nvidia, so there is some skepticism given that the testing wasn’t performed with a non-Nvidia/AMD solution. However, the site testing the VR capabilities isn’t necessarily rooting for one specific team over the other, nor is there any indication that Nvidia fine-tuned the tool to provide better numbers for its GeForce cards.

That said, FCAT VR consists of two components. First, the Capture tool runs on the PC to evaluate its performance and uses data pulled from Oculus Event Tracing, the SteamVR performance API, and Nvidia driver stats. The second component is the Analyzer that grabs data generated by the Capture tool and shows the framerates, the dropped frames, warped frames, synthesized frames, and so on.

Finally, the testbed consisted of an Intel Core i7-5960X Haswell-E processor, an Asus Rampage V-Extreme X99 motherboard, 16GB of Ripjaws DDR4-3,200 from G.Skill, a Corsair AX1500i 1,500-watt power supply, and Windows 10 (64-bit). The operating system resided on a 256GB OCZ Agility 4 SSD and the tested games on a 500GB Adata SP610 SSD.

Using Nvidia driver version 378.78 and AMD driver version 17.2.1, the testing showed AMD’s card creating predicted frames in Chronos and Dirt Rally while Nvidia’s card generated all new frames. Both generated new frames in Edge of Nowhere whereas both cards were caught synthesizing predicted frames in Obduction.

Here are the numbers based on the high preset, which includes an additional test using the Oculus Rift-only Robo Recall game:

GTX 1060 Radeon RX 480
Chronos – Delivered FPS 90.0 76.0
Chronos – Unconstrained FPS 112.5 93.8
Dirt Rally – Delivered FPS 90.0 47.0
Dirt Rally – Unconstrained FPS 76.3 57.9
Edge of Nowhere – Delivered FPS 90.0 90.0
Edge of Nowhere – Unconstrained FPS 150.3 143.9
Obduction – Delivered FPS 63.9 55.3
Obduction – Unconstrained FPS 73.2 61.8
Robo Recall – Delivered FPS 63.9 55.3
Robo Recall – Unconstrained FPS 73.2 61.8

As the numbers show, the GeForce card may be a better investment for $50 more. But at $250, customers looking to upgrade their desktop to support VR can’t go wrong with AMD’s Radeon RX 480 either. How Nvidia’s GeForce GTX 1060 card will measure up to AMD’s upcoming Radeon RX Vega card with the same price tag will be interesting to see.

Editors' Recommendations

Kevin Parrish
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kevin started taking PCs apart in the 90s when Quake was on the way and his PC lacked the required components. Since then…
VR training is helping police learn to cut down on unnecessary use of force
VR Training

“You're the first officer on the scene. You get teleported in and you’re at an office building. You're moving down the hallway and there’s an avatar on the ground who's been shot and they’re saying, ‘Help me, please help me.’ At that point you, the user, have to make a decision.”

So explains Oliver Noteware, co-founder and CEO of a New York-based startup called Street Smarts VR. Street Smarts makes virtual reality training technology. For police officers.

Read more
A mystery AMD graphics card just beat an Nvidia RTX 2080 Ti by almost 30%
mystery amd gpu beats 2080 ti openvr mysteryamdgpu02

An unnamed and entirely unknown AMD graphics card has appeared in the OpenVR benchmark paired up with an unnamed AMD CPU. That mystery is only compounded by the result, as together they managed to beat every Nvidia RTX 2080 Ti on the table, including heavily overclocked ones, by a sizeable margin. Is this the "Big Navi," GPU that team red fans have been waiting for? It sure seems like it.

Since the release of AMD's RX 5700 graphics cards in July 2019, speculation about when it would launch a new high-end graphics card has gathered traction. There have been rumors of AMD staff testing an alleged "Nvidia Killer" graphics card, and CEO Lisa Su has repeatedly stated that we can expect AMD to return to the top of the graphics card performance spectrum. But with no announcement of anything close to "Big Navi," at CES 2020, many suspected we'd be waiting a long time to learn more. With this leaked result, perhaps not.

Read more
The AMD Radeon 5600 XT seems poised to be the GTX 1060 of this generation
can amd radeon 5600 xt replace gtx 1060 ces 2020 rx 03

This story is part of our continuing coverage of CES 2020, including tech and gadgets from the showroom floor.

When you look at any recent Steam survey, the GTX 1060 dominates the list. That 3-year-old Nvidia GPU clearly has hit a sweet spot between performance and price for 1080p gaming over the years.

Read more