Skip to main content

Apple is repeating a major mistake from its past with the Vision Pro

Apple’s Vision Pro headset could be one of the company’s most advanced high-tech devices in years, stuffed to the gills with futuristic tech that far surpasses anything even the best VR headsets can produce. From the flashy demos to the highly positive feedback from developers, it’s clear that Apple is making a pretty remarkable device.

Yet despite all that, there’s a problem. Not only will Vision Pro be incredibly expensive — expect to pay a whopping $3,500 — but Apple hasn’t announced an alternative headset with a more palatable price tag.

A person sits down wearing an Apple Vision Pro headset.
Apple

Sure, a cheaper version is rumored to be in the works, but we’re not expecting that until late 2025 at the very earliest. For almost two years, there will only be one game in town.

So, when Vision Pro launches in early 2024, either you will have to scrape up the cash or, more likely, Apple’s headset will be hopelessly out of reach for you and the majority of its potential customers. Apple is severely limiting the product’s reach and threatening to repeat one of its biggest mistakes in recent years.

Prime Day Focus
These Razer Blade Prime Day deals really pack a punch [in gaming power]
Anker SOLIX Prime Day deals: This shopping guide highlights the best discounts
Send it! This HoverAir X1 Drone can capture your adventures and it's $120 off
Secretlab Prime Day deals: Build your ideal work-from-home or gaming station

History repeats itself

Apple HomePod 2023 next to a TV.
Zeke Jones / Digital Trends

This situation is eerily similar to what happened in 2018 with another Apple product: the original HomePod. This high-end speaker boasted incredible audio specs, but was wincingly expensive, even considering everything it could do. Like the Vision Pro, Apple didn’t offer a more affordable HomePod, so you were left to choose between a costly device and nothing at all. In the end, hordes of people opted for the latter.

With rumors swirling of poor sales, it seemed that average users didn’t care as much about the premium sound quality as they did about having a decent, inexpensive speaker. When Apple eventually offered one in the form of the HomePod mini, it sold so well that the company ditched the original HomePod altogether. Even though a second-gen HomePod did eventually come out, there’s no question that it’s overshadowed by its smaller sibling.

My concern is that the same experience could play out once again with Vision Pro. By setting the price so high, Apple risks hamstringing its own product until a cheaper alternative arrives to save the day. But if that happens, how many customers are going to fork out $3,500 on a high-end headset when the toned-down version does the job perfectly well for the majority of users?

It’s unlikely Apple will ditch the high-end Vision Pro altogether — after all, rumors have claimed a second-generation flagship model is already being developed. But Apple’s focus here is apparently on reducing the size and weight, not on cutting the cost. Either Apple is extremely confident or sorely misguided.

Not learning from the past

The Apple Vision Pro reveals the wearer's eyes on a front-facing display.
Apple

There’s a reason why Vision Pro is so painfully expensive. Apple’s approach is to make the best product it can, and in this case, it’s done just that. The Vision Pro is far more advanced than rival headsets. In fact, reports have suggested it cost so much to research and produce that Apple will hardly make any profit on it at all, even with its $3,500 price tag.

Apple is betting that customers will be so blown away by its headset that they will overlook any price concerns. Often, this attitude works well. After all, iPhones are getting more expensive, but continue to sell in phenomenal numbers.

But it’s a different kettle of fish when you’re talking about a $3,500 niche product versus a $1,000 iPhone 15 Pro. One is a device you might pick up and use a few times a week, while the other is something you’ll interact with multiple times every single day. Convincing people to spend $1,000 on the latter isn’t so hard; doing the same when the former costs $3,500 definitely will be.

The next few years are going to be absolutely crucial for Apple’s shiny new headset. In the period between the Vision Pro’s launch and its cheaper sibling hitting the shelves, we’ll learn just how much customers are willing to stomach that $3,500 price tag. If they’re reluctant to bite, we could see the HomePod’s history repeating itself all over again.

Alex Blake
In ancient times, people like Alex would have been shunned for their nerdy ways and strange opinions on cheese. Today, he…
The Vision Pro is already in trouble. Here’s how Apple can turn the tide
A man wears an Apple Vision Pro headset.

Apple’s Vision Pro headset lit the world on fire when it was announced at the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) in June 2023, and again when it launched in February of this year. But in the months since, it’s apparently been losing steam, with sales down and people staying away from in-store demonstrations. That doesn’t bode well for Apple’s “next big thing.”

The key question, though, is whether this an actual problem for Apple. And if so, what can the company do about it?
In free fall?
If you read Bloomberg journalist Mark Gurman’s latest Power On newsletter, you’ll see some concerning reporting, at least from Apple’s perspective. Citing staff at Apple’s retail stores, Gurman claims that “Demand for [Vision Pro] demos is way down. People who do book appointments often don’t show up.”

Read more
This new VR headset beats the Vision Pro in one key way and is half the price
Pimax Crystal Super and Light VR headsets appear on a dark background.

While the Apple Vision Pro offers ultra-high-resolution displays with 23 million pixels, the staggering $3,500 price might inspire you to look for Vision Pro alternatives.

Good news: Pimax just announced two new VR headsets, including a budget model that costs as low as $799 and a more advanced version starting at $1,799. Both are based on the design of one of the best VR headsets currently available -- the Pimax Crystal that launched in May 2023 for $1,599 -- but come with a serious upgrade in terms of resolution.
Pimax Crystal Super

Read more
How Vision Pro tech could come to the Mac
The Mac Studio and Studio Display at Apple's Peek Performance event.

You're probably familiar with the Apple Vision Pro, which uses spatial computing technology to bring content alive in the world around you. Virtual reality headsets and 3D displays exist to make games and other content feel more immersive. Apple, however, wants to be the best of the best and is looking into bringing spatial computing experiences to computer monitors, presumably to run your Mac.

A patent for "Displays with Selective Pixel Brightness tuning" was published on April 4, showing the company's interest in the technology. Much of it involves using a lenticular display and a lenticular lens film so that a viewer can see what looks like three-dimensional images without wearing a headset.

Read more