Make any TV 3D? This converter will do it

3d pioneer gene dolgoff shows off his in development instant converter

Gene Dolgoff planted the seed in Gene Roddenberry’s imagination that blossomed into the forward-thinking Holodeck on Star Trek: The Next Generation. He invented and built the world’s first LCD projector. He worked on the development of the HDTV system as we know it today and, in his current role at 3-D Vision, he’s revolutionized lenticular imaging technologies. He also developed the 3-D Vision process, a low-cost analog-to-anaglyphic 3D that offers improved optical effects with none of the color loss or eye strain that is typically associated with the old method. He took it public with the Halloween 2010 edition of The Rachel Ray Show in 3D, distributing cardboard-and-plastic glasses with TV Guide subscriptions.

For his next trick, Dolgoff wants to deliver digital stereoscopic 3D to every living room using a low-cost device that doesn’t require you to upgrade your TV. Even if said TV is a crusty, old tube set that can’t even push past a 480i video mode. In short, he wants every TV to be a 3DTV. He’s established a Fundable to get the project going — complete with a competition built around having a community-sourced design for the device — and he may well turn to Kickstarter for additonal funding once the groundwork is established.

Dolgoff envisions a converter, a small device that will connect to your TV and, thanks to the magic of image-processing software, convert what you see to 3D. You’ll need special glasses (included with the converter), just like you would with any other consumer 3DTV. The aim here is to offer an affordable alternative upgrading your TV set, a commendable goal when you consider that many of us already stepped up to HDTVs before 3DTVs were introduced as the Next Big Thing.

I was immediately doubtful when I read the pitch. After seeing it in person, my doubts were proven to be unfounded. This tech works. And it works exceptionally well.

3d pioneer gene dolgoff shows off his in development instant converter fundable

3D conversion that works

I spent a few hours visiting with Dolgoff at his 3-D Vision lab on Long Island. First he showed off some of the aforementioned Rachel Ray stuff which, while impressive for its grand-scale delivery, doesn’t come close in terms of quality to the 3D tech that is in use as of 2012. Eventually we moved on to the converter, which currently exists only in prototype form. The unit is massive, and almost too heavy to lift. It houses multiple fans, which makes for a loud demonstration. It works though, and Dolgoff promises that the mass-produced version of this converter will be much, much smaller, the sort of thing that could fit easily into anyone’s media center.

First we took a look at a few things on an old Sony WEGA flatscreen, a TV set that went up to a whopping (at the time) 480p. A DVD of The Wizard of Oz, a Blu-ray of Bee Movie, and a PlayStation 3 version of NCAA Football 13 served as the testing materials. There’s an unavoidable, minimally distracting, flicker that you get when watching the converted 3D on a CRT screen, but the optical effect is immediately noticeable. In every case, the converter capably translated the depth of the image into a 3D display.

The flickering disappears when you step up to modern-day HDTV, though depending on which set you use you do see some minor ghosting. Again, it’s not distracting to the point that it draws you away from the convincing 3D effect. I played a race in MotorStorm Apocalypse and, once again, the added depth that the converter offers is immediately noticeable. It was the next step in the test that really drove home the potential of this device, however.

Dolgoff switched us over to a live television broadcast. The converter software works exactly as it does with content pulled from a piece of physical media. Old-style 2D cartoons — such as an old Looney Tunes episode that we came across — don’t really convert, but any true video or CG animation does. A local high-school marching band’s performance stood out in particular, especially during long shots that took in the entire field. Same goes for Olympic soccer, which happened to be airing at the time. Given how few properly 3D broadcasts there are, the converter even makes a place for itself in 3DTV-equipped households.

The effect perhaps isn’t as pronounced as native 3D content that was actually shot with stereoscopic cameras. This is particularly true in the case of effects that seem to pop out of the screen. The converter does a brilliant job with depth, but the more gimmicky stuff really comes out more with content that was actually crafted for 3D. The converter can actually handle that too; send a 3D video signal through  the box, and it will process it.

It’s software doing the heavy lifting, as Dolgoff explained. “It takes the two-dimensional input video signal and it looks at two frames at a time. It looks at brightness, contrast, color saturation, sharpness, position in the frame, because as the depth goes back, all of these things decrease. When you have motion, the occlusion of background objects by foreground objects also gives a lot of information,” he said, offering up a familiar example.

“If you’re looking out the window of a train, the phone poles are going the real fast, the buildings are going a little slower, the mountains are going real slow, and the moon isn’t moving at all. The The further back you are, the slower the motion. So all of these different factors are taken into account to create the stereo pair, and it’s done in a way that is consistent with the algorithms that we have in our brains, so when we look at it we can reconstruct the three-dimensional scene with accurate 3D information in it.”

microsoft patent hints at star trek like holodeck

A lifelong quest to record reality

It’s helpful to know where Dolgoff is coming from to really appreciate the passion he’s got for this work. The advances he’s made in 3D are but one step in a lifelong pursuit of a much grander goal. “When I was three years old, I remember very clearly looking around and saying, ‘Wow, look at this!'” He gestures at the general world surrounding us before continuing. “I wanted to record it and play it back. So my life became all about that.”

“I made my first 3DTV in 1963, and it was put into the Brooklyn museum. It was a stereoscopic CRT. I started doing these lenticular 3D pictures in ’63. Holography in ’64. In ’68, I got the idea to use a light valve to modulate an external source instead of a CRT, and I then had the basis of the LCD projector. It took me until 1970 to make it digital and use liquid crystals as my digital light valve. It took a long time to really get the prototype finished, but I did finished the world’s first digital LCD projector in April of ’84. I have it here [in the lab], and it still works.”

“I’ve always been involved in imaging and different ways of recording and playing back reality as faithfully as possible, and I’m still on that quest.”

In essence, Dolgoff envisions a Holodeck future. Planting the seed for that Strek Trek innovation with its creator speaks to this big picture goal. He has working technology, in his lab right now that delivers glasses-free 3D on a heavily modified CRT TV set. In an opposite corner, there’s a holographic display unit, once again a fully functional one. It’s the goal of the long game, but the technology isn’t there yet on a mass scale.

“Movies are great, and they’re making a billion dollars a picture sometimes, but consumer 3D is not moving so fast. It’s a chicken-egg problem,” Dolgoff explained. “There’s just not enough content out there for people to justify buying a 3D set, and without an installed base of a lot of 3D set owners, there’s not enough money for [entertainment companies] to produce more 3D content. So there’s maybe 4 million 3D sets sold in this country. It’s kind of going slowly.”

“My whole initial thrust was [the knowledge] that we can’t get everyone to buy a new TV, that’s going to be a logjam. So let’s find a way to make everybody able to see 3D right away with whatever they have.  That’s what this technology was designed to do. Once we get it out there, it’s going to get… a lot more people watching 3D on their 2D sets and a lot more people buying 3D sets. That’ll start increasing the installed  base, which will then provide the incentive for more content to be made in 3D. And then the 3D consumer field will really take off.”

Dolgoff pegs the lifespan for 3D as we know it, with the glasses and such, at around 5 to 10 years. Glasses-free displays will follow, but the ultimate goal is consumer holography. Not only do you lose the glasses, you lose the screen too. The barrier between actual reality and recorded reality slips away. “The basis of holography is the interference of energy, and that’s the way reality works,” Dolgoff explained. “So we’re just playing back reality the way reality works. That’ll be the next step.”

Home Theater

I only watched free streaming services for a month, and I didn’t miss much

For a month, I only watched movies and TV shows on free streaming services, and as it turns out, you can find a whole lot of entertainment online only without spending so much as a dollar.
Emerging Tech

Stanford A.I. can realistically score computer animations just by watching them

Researchers at Stanford University have developed a computer system that’s able to synthesize realistic sounds for 3D animation, based entirely on its knowledge about the physical world.
Deals

Get your Mario Kart nostalgia on with the 3DS XL Super NES Edition

If you love all things retro and have been waiting for a 3DS deal, you're in luck: The New 3DS XL SNES Edition is on sale for $150. This limited-time offer is the best way to score a deal on a 3DS right now -- the free copy of 'Super Mario…
Emerging Tech

Soft robotic hand gives scientists new grip on deep sea life

A team of roboticists and marine biologists from Harvard University have created a sampling device that’s soft and flexible for grabbing fragile organisms, and can be 3D printed for easy customization.
Emerging Tech

‘There’s Waldo’ robot will find Waldo long before you can

There’s Waldo is the brain child of Matt Reed, a creative technologist at the creative agency Redpepper. Reed and his colleagues built the bot out of a uArm Swift Pro that’s controlled by a Raspberry Pi computer.
Emerging Tech

Bright idea: Keep your gadgets juiced up with these stellar solar chargers

Looking for a gizmo that can help you charge your phone while on the go? Here, we've outlined the best solar chargers on the market, whether you're looking to charge your phone once, twice, or three times over.
Emerging Tech

Replaced by robots: 10 jobs that could be hit hard by the A.I. revolution

According to one study, 47 percent of current jobs in the United States could be automated within the next two decades. Here are 10 examples of the kind of employment that refers to.
Emerging Tech

By studying patient data, A.I. can limit toxicity in cancer treatment

In a bid to improve quality of life for cancer patients, a team of researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology have turned to machine learning to help avoid toxicity from cancer medications.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Robo sidekicks, AC for your bed, and more

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the Web this week. You can't buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!
Emerging Tech

NASA’s Parker Solar Probe sets out to try and ‘touch’ the sun

A NASA probe launched on a journey to take measurement of the atmosphere of the Sun, hopefully uncovering crucial details about the origins of the solar winds generated there.
Emerging Tech

The Perseid meteor shower peaks this weekend! Here’s how to watch

Thanks to a new moon, 2018's Perseid Meteor Shower will be much easier to view, with even the dimmest meteors observable by the naked eye. Here's how to see the show this weekend, and where the views will be the best.
Emerging Tech

Don’t get burned! How to back crowdfunding projects the smart way

In the world of crowdfunding, there’s no such thing as a sure thing. There's a million reasons why a project might fail. But with this handy guide, you'll be able to spot the signs of a sketchy project and decrease your chances of getting…
Emerging Tech

‘Rogue medicine in a bathtub’: 4 experts on the vice and virtue of pharma hacking

A biohacker, pharmahacker, and two bioethicists walk into a bar. We ordered them a metaphorical round and had a chat about the risks and rewards of DIY medicine — from unsanctioned gene therapy to medication made on the kitchen counter.
Emerging Tech

No keyboard? No problem. Masterkey will project you a virtual one to type on

Miss having a physical keyboard when you're out and about? Wish you could have a mobile display bigger than your smartphone can offer? Masterkey 4.0 is a wireless projector that promises to help.