Skip to main content

FIFA 23 career mode: the best teams to manage

FIFA 23 is the latest in EA Sports’ popular soccer franchise, and one of its best features is career mode. This lets you choose any club in the game — or even create your own — and lead them to glory, picking teams, making transfers, and doing things your way.

But which club should you manage? With over 700 teams to choose from, it can feel overwhelming. Fear not — we’ve analyzed every club in the game to find five that will create careers as thrilling as they are unusual. Whether you want to start from the bottom or rely heavily on youth, these are the best teams to manage in FIFA 23.

If you’re looking for a few helpful FIFA 23 beginners’ tips, we’ve got a guide for that. We’ve also got a full-blown FIFA 23 career mode guide if you want to go more in-depth.

The road to glory: Barrow

A screenshot from FIFA 23 showing the information board of Barrow.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The enduring appeal of FIFA’s career mode is its ability to craft stories of your own creation. Seasons twist and turn, rivals rise and fall, new star players emerge — all of this helps to make each career uniquely yours.

One of the best ways to create a memorable career mode story is to embark on a “road to glory” journey. Usually, this involves taking a very low-rated team and leading them to trophies and success. In FIFA 23, the best team for this job is Barrow in League Two, the fourth tier of the English soccer pyramid.

Being in such a lowly division means you’ll need to grind for several seasons before you’re able to even think about winning the nation’s highest honor, the Premier League trophy. Not only that, but Barrow have the lowest budget in League Two, making your task even tougher. Fortunately, the board is very forgiving, aside from expecting you to rein in spending by keeping an eye on the club’s finances. Take them to the top, and the glory is all yours.

The most lenient board: RFC Seraing

A screenshot from FIFA 23 showing the information board of RFC Seraing.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Making a success out of your team, both on and off the pitch, can be hard enough at the best of times, but add to that a slate of unreasonable demands from the club’s board, and the pressure ratchets up another notch or two.

In FIFA 23, each club has a set of board requirements covering domestic success, continental success, brand exposure, financial performance, and youth development. If you want a chilled-out career with little pressure from the board, you’ll want these requirements to be as low as possible — and they don’t come any lower than at RFC Seraing in the Belgian Pro League.

In every category, the board expectations are “very low” (the lowest score possible). That means there will be minimal interference in your career, and the expectations that the board does set should not be too difficult to achieve. As well as that, the team is in a competitive league, so it should remain interesting as you scale the club up. If you want a career where you can take things easy, this is the team to try.

The toughest board: Boca Juniors

A screenshot from FIFA 23 showing the information board of Boca Juniors.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

At the opposite end of the spectrum, you have Boca Juniors. A far cry from RFC Seraing, this club has the toughest, most demanding board expectations of any club in the game. If you want a real challenge, you’ve found it.

Domestic success? Critically important. Continental success? That’s critically important, too. Brand exposure and youth development? You’d better believe they’re critically important. The only respite is the club’s financial targets, which have a rating of “high” instead of “critical.” Not much respite after all, then.

Incidentally, Boca Juniors’ board expectations are the same as their arch-nemesis club, River Plate. However, we’ve picked Boca Juniors here because they have a lower budget — wouldn’t want things to be too easy now, would we? Keep this board happy, and you’ll have achieved something remarkable.

The youth-only challenge: SC Freiburg II

A screenshot from FIFA 23 showing the information board of SC Freiburg II.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Securing the future of your club is just as important as any victory on the pitch, and in FIFA 23, that’s best represented by scouting and developing young players. If you want to make that the centerpiece of your career, why not try a youth-only challenge where your only recruitment can be from your own youth academy? Without being able to bring in outside talent, you’ll embark on a challenging career that can be immensely rewarding.

One of the best teams to pick for this is SC Freiburg II in the German 3 Liga. For one thing, this team is the B-team for Bundesliga outfit SC Freiburg. That immediately creates some lore for you to exploit. Since the real-life SC Freiburg II is mainly a development team, it makes sense that you should only recruit youth players.

As well as that, the board’s expectations also play into this. Most objectives are rated at “very low” importance, with financial performance set to “medium.” Youth development, however, is critically important. The good news is the low domestic objectives allow you time to build up the squad and create a lasting project without the pressure of trophy demands. Time to get scouting!

The smallest budget: UCD AFC

A screenshot from FIFA 23 showing the information board of UCD AFC
Image used with permission by copyright holder

These days, the world of soccer is dominated by wealthy clubs wielding untold financial resources with which to dwarf their rivals. Manchester City, Real Madrid, Paris Saint-Germain — all these clubs and more could effectively buy whoever they wanted without a second thought.

In FIFA 23, exercising that kind of power can quickly get boring. If you really want to prove yourself with minimal resources, take the helm of Irish club UCD AFC. At a little over $700,000, they have the smallest budget of any club in the game, meaning you’ll be woefully restricted in who you can buy to improve the club.

Not only that, but the Irish league does not have a very high reputation in the game, meaning it’ll be tough to convince players to join even if you can afford them. Your best bet is to scout for cheap youth players and hope a lucky cup run brings you a sizeable windfall. If that kind of challenge sounds right up your street, this is the team to go for.

Editors' Recommendations

Alex Blake
In ancient times, people like Alex would have been shunned for their nerdy ways and strange opinions on cheese. Today, he…
How to pre-order Madden NFL 23: retailers, editions, and bonuses
This mid-air hit is an example of one of Madden NFL 23's new disruptive FieldSense animations.

Down, set ... hike! It's a yearly tradition for the biggest, best Madden title to drop in near the end of summer and this year is no exception. Madden NFL 23 has fans of both games and the physical sport joining together in shared excitement for this latest installment in the quintessential football simulation game. Madden NFL 23 will let you carve your own rise into the ranks of the best players of all time, go behind the scenes in the Franchise mode to scout players, facilitate trades, manage your staff, or even build an unstoppable dream team in Madden Ultimate Team.

Madden games have come a long way since the early entries on the early consoles. Madden NFL 23 is a full-on service game, with its own currency and progression to keep the game fresh and relevant all season long. While you could just grab the game after release, hardcore fans of the game who know they will be investing more than the initial asking price should check out what extras there are available for pre-ordering, as well as if the extra content included in the different editions speaks to you. Here's everything you need to know about how to pre-order Madden NFL 23.

Read more
Madden NFL 23’s ‘no-brainer’ cover star is John Madden
John Madden bursts through the cover of Madden NFL 23: All Madden Edition.

EA has confirmed rumors that Coach John Madden will be the cover star of Madden NFL 23. 
John Madden, who had a long career as both the coach of the Oakland Raiders and a football analyst, died in December 2021. EA is honoring Madden -- the namesake and inspiration behind its highly successful football game franchise -- by renaming a recently renovated field at its Redwood Shores headquarters to the "John Madden Field" and putting him on the cover of Madden NFL 23. There will be three unique covers, including one by artist Chuck Styles for the digital-exclusive Madden NFL 23 All-Madden Edition.

Speaking to Digital Trends, executive producer Aaron McHardy said that EA typically looks at the most exciting and Madden brand-aligned athletes in the NFL when choosing a cover star. But he says there wasn't much of a debate about who would headline the next game after the team learned of Madden's death.
"I don't even think there were discussions as everybody just arrived at the fact that he's going back on the cover because we have to honor him in the best way we possibly can," McHardy said. "It's been so long since he was on the cover of the game, but the game has got his name on it every single year, so we wanted to do everything we could to honor the legend like he is, and it was a no-brainer to put him on the cover." 
Madden is not just being honored on the cover. The first thing players will experience when booting up Madden NFL 23 is a fictional game where two versions of Madden are facing off against each other with all-star teams of athletes in the 1970s Oakland Coliseum. This game will even include real voice clips from Madden, remastered just for this experience. McHardy also believes Madden's influence can be felt outside of that opening game because his death encouraged the development team to work harder. 
"I didn't have the pleasure of speaking with him, but I know a lot of the guys on the team did." McHardy continued. "He was invested in making sure that our game was the most authentic 11v11 football game that it could be. It was obviously a sad and somber moment to lose someone like Coach Madden, but it really energized the team in a way this year to think about our features, what we're building, and how we can honor that legacy." Madden NFL 23 will be released for PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X/S later this year. 

Read more
Say goodbye to FIFA and hello to EA Sports FC
Player kicking a ball surrounded by other players in EA Sports Fifa 22.

EA is taking its football/soccer series into a new era. But this new age isn't being brought in simply by innovation, but due to a name dispute over the FIFA title between EA and the Fédération Internationale de Football Association. EA announced that it will be changing the series' name to EA Sports FC going forward.

FIFA 22 | Official Gameplay Trailer

Read more