Skip to main content

Why the ‘games as service’ model is positive for video games

I’ll be the first to admit that I was at first turned off by the idea of “games as a service.” That term refers to the kind of modern games that are meant to be played over a long period of time. Rather than hitting the end credits after a certain number of hours, service games like Destiny 2 feed players a constant drop of new content over time, some of which requires players to pay more.

I was skeptical of that idea initially. I mean, publishers were expecting me to buy a full priced game, only to charge me for more later on? It felt like a scam, and many other people felt the same way, especially because so many service titles tend to launch with little content, gradually fleshing the game out over time with DLC. However, now that a few more attempts have been made at this monetization model, I can confidently say that service games, when done right, are absolutely a positive industry move for players.

No more sequels

Traditionally, when a game is good, we can expect to get a sequel sometime later on. That time frame varies, but has grown in general as production values in games have increased. Other games, such as sports franchises like Madden, come out every year like clockwork, changing very little between iterations. Despite these minor changes, they’re released as full-priced titles every time. If you want to keep up with all the tweaks, there’s no choice but to plunk down a hard $60 (sometimes $70 now) for what may as well be a roster update. Plus, all those hours you put into that last game, and any extra content you bought for it? Gone.

With games as a service, we’re already seeing companies move away from forcing you to buy a new game. Instead, they do the opposite and try to keep players on the same game. The Destiny series is a perfect example. While Activision reportedly wanted a third installment initially, developer Bungie decided to continue supporting Destiny 2 instead. Rather than start from scratch yet again, we got to keep our character, everything we’d earned, and all the content from the game as more was added (though Bungie would later “vault” older content as the game’s file size ballooned).

Guardians fight together in Destiny 2.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Looking at another example, Rainbow Six Siege has been going long enough that its roster of playable operators has tripled from its original size. If this game had not been a service, we’d probably be on the third game in the series with half the characters at best and a far smaller player base.

I can’t mention great examples of games as a service without bringing up No Man’s Sky, which might as well have a 3 stuck on the end of the title by now. All its content updates, patches, and expansions have fully reinvented that game. What it was on day one is almost unrecognizable compared to the state of it today, and everyone playing it got to experience those improvements over time, without losing anything they’d done, or spending a dime on a sequel.

Pro-consumer

A list of challenges in destiny 2.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The term pro-consumer gets thrown around a lot in gaming. Gamers are smart. We know when a game looks like it’s going to rip us off. New service games need to prove that they’re worth investing in, and that our investment is priced correctly. One great move that has almost become standard is how multiplayer content, like maps, is becoming free to all players. That keeps games from splitting their population between those who buy them and those who don’t. Another positive change is that “base” games are often free now. Massive games like FIFA are even toying with the idea of becoming free-to-play and monetizing in other ways.

What are those other ways? The big one is battle passes. Made popular by Fortnite, these come in many different forms, but can be a positive addition for players. To look at a less obvious example, take Marvel’s Avengers. Every character and mission added to the game is totally free, but the special Hero Challenge Cards will cost Credits. Players can earn these through the free battle pass, or purchase them with real money. Even if they pay up for one, they’ll earn back that investment in Credits by the time they complete that battle pass. Those who care for what the battle pass holds, which is usually cosmetic items, will get their investment back just by playing.

Finally, there are the big expansions. Again, we turn to Destiny 2, and look at its model. Yes, its expansions do cost real cash, but there’s three main points that make it better than the alternative. First is that the base game is free, second is that the expansions are cheaper and more frequent than a sequel would be, and third is that new content can become free later on. Over time, as new expansions are added, older ones get brought in as part of the free experience. That means hardcore players get a mostly consistent feed of new content for less than the price of a new game and casual players can choose to wait until it’s released for free.

Pitfalls

Offensivee line-up in Madden 22 Ultimate Team.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

It would be disingenuous to claim games as a service are great for players in every circumstance. There are plenty of ways that companies can exploit these systems to be worse than the traditional model. Battle passes, loot boxes, and the handling of how future content is priced and delivered can all be easily twisted to feel unfair to players. Pay-to-win systems are among the most egregious examples out there that somehow still manage to make it into certain games.

I hate to keep bringing up Destiny 2, but for all it does right, it has also made some big mistakes. From nerfing and outright removing weapons players potentially spent dozens of hours grinding to get, to the news that entire expansions worth of content will be going away, Bungie is in some hot water with its fans — and rightfully so. There’s a social agreement being made when players invest in a games as a service that, so long as the game exists, the content we pay for will always be available to us. Taking anything a player could possibly spend real money on away can break that trust permanently.

We’re still in the experimental age of service games, so it will be a while before the industry finds the right formula. For the most part, we’re seeing the games that do it right rise up and those that don’t fail, which is sending a good message to the industry. Not every game should adopt a service model, such as pure single-player experiences, but this model of game is here to stay. It has all the potential in the world to be a far better model for players than what we’re used to.

Editors' Recommendations

Jesse Lennox
Jesse Lennox loves writing, games, and complaining about not having time to write and play games. He knows the names of more…
The 50 best video games of all time
A logo that says "Best 50 Games of All Time" on a blue background.

Trying to pick the best video games of all time is a task defined by one word: hubris.

How could anyone possibly create a definitive list of gaming's greatest accomplishments when there’s such a wildly large variety of games to choose from? That’s a question we asked ourselves over and over when deciding to put together our own top 50 list. It was the kind of task we could slice up hundreds of ways, coming out with completely different lists every single time based on our preferred methodology. That’s a testament to the rich history of games, which offer countless diverse experiences worthy of praise.

Read more
The best video games of April 2023
Cal stands beneath the clouds in Star Wars Jedi: Survivor key art.

Typically, April isn't that exciting of a month for video games. Most publishers try to get their biggest games out before the end of the fiscal year in March, so April usually only has one or two notable releases alongside a ton of indies. April 2023 was different, though. Although it wasn't packed to the brim with notable new game releases, a lot of very notable franchises like Star Wars, Minecraft, League of Legends, and Tron had significant new game launches during April 2023.
Meanwhile, series such as Advance Wars and Mega Man saw past games updated for new platforms, while experimental indies like OTXO and Shadows of Doubt also managed to leave an impression. There were quite a few awesome new games to play this month, and you'll definitely want to get some playtime in with all of them before The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom comes out in May. If you're looking for something new to play, consider checking out one of the following eight games the released in April 2023.
Star Wars Jedi: Survivor

Like in April 2022, this month's biggest release is an ambitious Star Wars game. Star Wars Jedi: Survivor is a sequel to 2019's excellent Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order and expands on it in almost every way. The story feels more ambitious and personal at the same time, as all of the worlds players can explore as Cal are more densely packed with content than before, and combat has been refined to be even more fun thanks to new stances and perks players can use.
"Cal’s journey follows the thematic trends established by The Empire Strikes Back and The Last Jedi, but is willing to get even more personal with them in a way only a game can," Digital Trends' Tomas Franzese wrote in a four-star review of Star Wars Jedi: Survivor. "This, coupled with its deeper combat and more densely packed worlds, truly put me in the mindset of a Jedi during this dire era."
It's an entirely single-player Star Wars adventure, and a meaty one at that. This game can easily keep you entertained for 20 hours or more and tells the most engaging Star Wars narrative since Andor. This is one of the best Star Wars games ever made, so fans of the franchise shouldn't miss out on it. Star Wars Jedi: Survivor is available now for PC, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X/S.
Advance Wars: 1+2 Re-Boot Camp

Read more
PS Plus’ library is looking more like Game Pass’ in May lineup
Two cars race side-by-side in Grid Legends.

Sony revealed the next batch of three games that will be available throughout May 2023 as part of PlayStation Plus Essential. The lineup includes Grid Legends, Chivalry 2, and Descenders. All are very solid games in their respective genres, but interestingly, they are all also games that Xbox Game Pass subscribers will already have access to.
Grid Legends is the headlining game for this month, and it's a racing game from Codemasters where the standout feature is a story mode framed like a racing documentary with live-action interviews. While I had mixed feelings about the game and the mode when reviewing it last year, those looking for a basic but enjoyable racing game to tide them over until the next Forza Motorsport, Test Drive Unlimited, or The Crew can have some fun with it. If you're subscribed to Xbox Game Pass Ultimate, you're also able to play this game on that platform thanks to EA Play.

For those that are still in a sporty mood, Descenders is an enjoyable downhill biking game that'll scratch the same gaming itch as series like Tony Hawk's Pro Skater or Lonely Mountains: Downhill. Then, there's Chivalry 2, a very intense multiplayer game set in medieval times, which gives it a very welcome change in setting compared to many of its multiplayer peers. Both games are currently playable if you have an Xbox Game Pass subscriber, but will likely leave the service at a later date. 
If you are subscribed to both PS Plus and Xbox Game Pass, you will be fine skipping out on May's PS Plus Essential titles. If you only own a PlayStation console, though, or want to guarantee that you'll still have these games after they leave Xbox Game Pass, then definitely consider downloading them. These games will all be available with PS Plus from May 1 until June 6. Make sure you pick up April's PS Plus Essential games before May 1 as well. 

Read more