Skip to main content

‘Lone Survivor’ review

Lone Survivor is the sort of movie that kicks your teeth in. As war films go, it’s as tough a watch as you’ll find. Director Peter Berg perfectly captures the tension and the pain of Navy SEAL Marcus Luttrell’s harrowing five-day journey across Afghanistan. The based-on-truth story of 2005’s Operation Red Wings isn’t without its shortcomings, but Berg’s tight production helps to smooth out any wrinkles as the plot careens along from one terrible moment to the next.

Lone Survivor opens quietly enough, offering up a slice-of-military-life on base during wartime. Luttrell (Mark Wahlberg) and his fellow SEALs may be the U.S. military version of supermen, but we also see them as regular fellows with real hopes and dreams. They have wives and girlfriends to come home to, weddings to plan for. The opening half-hour is filled with small moments and brief glimpses at the material cost of war: the lives that these men who made the ultimate sacrifice left behind.

Lone Survivor is the sort of movie that kicks your teeth in.

It is time well-spent, for the most part. Seemingly trivial moments come to reverberate later in the film, whether it’s a hasty IM exchange between husband and wife, or a humorous back-and-forth over the realities of purchasing an Arabian horse. Berg’s early character-building with Luttrell, Danny Dietz (Emile Hirsch), Matt Axelson (Ben Foster), and Mike Murphy (Taylor Kitsch) that plays out early on is vital to the emotional impact of the rest of the film.
Get your weekly teardown of the tech behind PC gaming
Check your inbox!

The principal shortcoming in all of this scene-setting is its emphasis on jargon. Berg’s 2007 effort The Kingdom suffered from the same problem. The director embraces realism to the point of distraction. The rapid-fire pace of Lone Survivor’s intro serves to get us to the heart of the story that much quicker – and that’s a good thing – but keeping up with the rapid-fire military jargon in the run-up to Red Wings is a challenge for those not steeped in soldierspeak.

To Berg’s credit, he stuffs a lot of important information into Lone Survivor’s first act. The personal moments are just as vital as the dense jargon. The problem is that it flies by just a little too quickly once Red Wings moves into the briefing phase. A fan of first-person shooter video games may be versed in some of this language, but the abundance of acronyms and shorthand is difficult for the average viewer to follow.

The jargon never fully disappears later on, but meanings become clearer as action serves to define the words. The goat herders that discover SEAL Team 10 – and ultimately give away the location of the U.S. force – are the subject of a heated exchange over how to interpret the Rules Of Engagement. There’s a stark contrast between the intro’s briefing and the hurried debate over how to deal with these Afghani interlopers.

The goat herder scene is a pivotal trigger moment for the film, and the performances sell it. All of the pain and misery to come hinges on the decisions made in this brief stretch of minutes. The real life goat herders were released unharmed and then quickly gave up the position of the SEALs. Berg’s tight balance between soldier shop-talk and emotional outbursts at the idea of executing civilians – an option that was considered – is what sells the scene. It’s hard to forget while you’re watching that the actual Luttrell and his squadmates faced this very decision; whether or not it unfolded as Berg imagines it did, the scene carries across the indecision the actual soldiers no doubt felt.

Once the chase is on, Berg wields tension like a blunt instrument. Every moment is fraught. Bullets whizz around in all directions, wounds are captured in stark close-ups, and tumbles down Afghanistan’s rocky hills make use of slow-mo to highlight the bone-on-stone impacts. It’s all heightened by sharp sound design that amplifies every juddering assault rifle and concussive blast. The middle act maintains a lightning pace all the way through, and it never lets up on demonstrating the level of physical punishment these SEALs suffered through. It’s graphic, but more than that, it’s just brutal.

Berg elicits top-quality performances out of the four actors at the center of all this chaos. There’s a bit of dissonance in the idea of Wahlberg, clearly showing his 42-year age, being a subordinate, but he acquits himself well of the difficult Luttrell role. Murphy is younger than Luttrell in real life as well, but Wahlberg’s combined age and movie star face disrupts the illusion somewhat.

Once the chase is on, Berg wields tension like a blunt instrument.

Kitsch also shines as squad leader Michael Murphy in a handful of Lone Survivor’s more poignant moments, but make no mistake: all four stars carry the movie well. Supporting players like Eric Bana, the operation’s CO who later leads a search and rescue party, align their talents around heightening the realism, but the film’s heart beats for the four SEALs on the ground.

The final act can’t hope to reach the heights of the hurried escape efforts that highlight Lone Survivor’s midsection. At first, a slowed pace is the culprit, though chalk that up to being a necessary breather as we transition from Escape to Rescue. More disruptively, however, the specter of Hollywood looms large over this last stretch of story.

The reality of Luttrell’s rescue played out differently than it does on film. While there’s no way to tease out the real truth from what you see on the screen, the timeliness of Wahlberg-as-Luttrell’s extraction feels just a bit too convenient. It’s a forgivable offense, committed in the name of putting a tension-filled cap on this incredible survival story, but the plotting of the third act still strays too far into ‘trite Hollywood ending’ territory.

Minor shortcoming aside, this is Berg at his very best, with no small amount of credit due to cinematographer Tobias A. Schliessler as well. The four stars carry the heavy performance load exceptionally well, somehow infusing light, even humorous, moments into a difficult story. Lone Survivor is the best kind of wartime storytelling, offering a spiritually honest portrayal of boots on the ground that is equal parts devastating, exciting, and entertaining.

Editors' Recommendations

Adam Rosenberg
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Previously, Adam worked in the games press as a freelance writer and critic for a range of outlets, including Digital Trends…
Save $400 on this (upgradeable) gaming PC with an RTX 4060
ibuypower tma7n4601 gaming desktop deal walmart february 2024 pc

Gamers who are on the hunt for gaming PC deals should check out the iBuyPower TMA7N4601 gaming desktop, which is available from Walmart for a discounted price of $899. You can keep the savings of $401 on its original price of $1,300 to eventually buy better components for the machine, though it may be a while before you need to make any upgrades. You're going to have to be quick if you're interested in taking advantage of this bargain though, as we're not sure how much time is remaining before the gaming desktop's price goes back to normal.

Why you should buy the iBuyPower TMA7N4601 gaming desktop
The iBuyPower TMA7N4601 gaming desktop is an excellent choice if you want a machine that will be able to run the best PC games. It's powered by the AMD Ryzen 7 5700 processor, the Nvidia GeForce RTX 4060 graphics card, and 16GB of RAM that our guide on how much RAM do you need says is a good starting point for gaming. When the time comes that you need to upgrade its components -- probably after a few years -- you can easily access its interiors so you can make the swaps yourself.

Read more
It’s time to revisit Pokémon X and Y before its too late
Key art for Pokémon X and Y.

If you’ve been looking for an excuse to revisit Pokémon X and Y, the announcement of Pokémon Legends: Z-A just gifted you a perfect excuse to do so.

Released for Nintendo 3DS in 2013, Pokémon X and Y are important but quiet entries in the RPG series. They were forward-looking games that brought the series into full 3D and took significant steps in making Pokémon even more approachable and easy to play online. A lot of problems more hardcore fans have, like the games being too casual-focused or having a bevy of technical issues, also got their start here. That makes Pokémon X and Y fascinating games to revisit -- and I recommend you do so soon.

Read more
Best Buy’s deal of the day is a starter gaming laptop for $700
A man playing on the Acer Nitro 5 gaming laptop.

You don't need to spend thousands of dollars to get into PC gaming because there are gaming laptop deals like Best Buy's offer for the Acer Nitro 5. The starter gaming laptop, which is already relatively affordable at its original price of $950, is currently even cheaper at just $700. You'll be able to use the $250 in savings on video games and gaming accessories, but you'll have to act fast if you want it because we're not sure how much time is remaining before the bargain disappears, and once that happens, we don't know when you'll get another chance at it.

Why you should buy the Acer Nitro 5 gaming laptop
The Acer Nitro 5 is equipped with the 12th-generation Intel Core i5 processor, the Nvidia GeForce RTX 3050 Ti graphics card, and 16GB of RAM. It's not going to challenge the performance of the top-of-the-line models of the best gaming laptops, but it's going to be more than enough to play the best PC games. Some of the more demanding titles may force you to choose low graphics settings, but that's a fine trade-off for a gaming laptop that you can get for less than $1,000.

Read more