Skip to main content

Sony’s PlayStation 5 repeats the PS3’s mistakes, with one key difference

Mark Cerny’s PlayStation 5 presentation detailed many key elements of Sony’s new console. It was also, frankly, a snoozefest for most of the people watching it. That’s not a huge surprise. Cerny is the project’s lead, not a personality or presenter, and the talk was originally scheduled for the now-postponed Game Developers Conference (GDC) 2020. It was a deep dive, not a flashy marketing presentation (though Sony could’ve done more to make that clear).

Still, the presentation’s focus was a surprise. You might have expected it to linger on the CPU and GPU, two key components most gamers associate with performance. Instead, Cerny went deepest on the console’s custom storage solution and audio engine, which only Sony’s PlayStation 5 will have.

Recommended Videos

They’re exciting features if, like me, you’re a serious hardware nerd. Yet I can’t help but think Sony is treading a hazardous path.

The PlayStation 3 all over again?

First, a quick history lesson.

Sony’s PlayStation 3 was a truly momentous effort from the company. Encouraged by its successful PlayStation and PlayStation 2, the company went all-in to make the PS3 a cutting-edge device. A key element was its Cell microprocessors, a customized piece of silicon that paired a familiar PowerPC core with seven “Synergistic Processing Elements.”

This gave the PS3 far more “cores” than the Xbox 360, which had just three PowerPC-based cores. At the time, major game studios were starting to abandon platform exclusives in favor of cross-platform launches. Though technically the quicker system, the PS3 often failed to deliver a performance or visual boost because developers had trouble optimizing for Sony’s unique hardware.

PlayStation 5 presentation
Cerny detailed “Time to Triangle” for past consoles Image used with permission by copyright holder

Cerny briefly referenced this problem during his GDC 2020 presentation when he spoke of “Time to Triangle,” or the time a developer needs to understand new PlayStation hardware. According to Cerny, developers needed at least six months to familiarize themselves with the PS3, and it could take up to a year.

It was odd, then, for Cerny to go deep into two of the PlayStation 5’s unique hardware features during the same presentation. The PS5 includes two specific features that will set it apart from other consoles. One is an SSD storage solution that features a highly customized storage controller that will deliver superior I/O throughput. The other is Tempest 3D AudioTech, a custom audio engine that can improve audio quality while reducing CPU load for audio tasks.

Not quite. But here’s the problem.

These custom elements aren’t a misstep on the level of the PS3’s Cell architecture. Still, I find them worrying. I don’t see how these features will be relevant in a gaming industry embracing cross-platform play.

Most developers aren’t making games only for the PS5.

Cerny used a frequent level design problem to illustrate why fast SSD storage solution matters. He reminded players that games so often include twisted corridors to hide loading times as assets are delivered from the hard disk to RAM. A significantly quicker storage solution means level design that hides loading assets is less of a concern, increasing both the size and detail of levels.

This example is true, but here’s the problem. Most developers aren’t making games only for the PS5. They’re designing games for at least the PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, and PC; many studios also want to release on Switch and mobile. (This is why cross-platform games are becoming so popular.) That limits the superior solid-state drive’s relevance. It’s an amazing advancement, but not every developer will make the most of it.

An example of twisted level design hiding load times Image used with permission by copyright holder

The same is true for Tempest 3D AudioTech. It’s a nice feature that also sits on an island. Many developers will find themselves forced to choose between optimizing for this unique audio engine or building for every device. They’ll inevitably choose the latter. Audio may be better on the PS5, but most developers will choose not to make the most of it.

It’s important to note the accessibility of these features differs from a faster CPU or GPU, hardware the Xbox Series X has prioritized. Better GPU performance is simple to tap into. Increased polygon counts and better textures are easy for a developer to implement, and developers are familiar with optimizing for a wide range of GPU performance. CPU performance also scales easily, allowing more on-screen characters and more A.I. routines.

I don’t think developers will find the PlayStation 5 difficult to design for, but I think it will be difficult to optimize for. Developers may look at the PlayStation 5’s unique hardware features and decide designing for them isn’t worth the effort.

At least it won’t be expensive

This means the PS5’s key features will have more bark than bite. They might look good on a box, but they’re unlikely to make gaming more enjoyable for most people.

The key improvements are the GPU, CPU, and the fact an SSD is included at all, not the specifics of the storage solution. Cerny’s presentation revealed that, as expected, the PlayStation 5 won’t keep pace with the absurdly fast Xbox Series X. The PS5’s GPU has fewer compute units than the Xbox Series X, though they do make up for that a bit with higher clock speed. The PS5’s CPU also runs at lower clock speeds than its rival from Microsoft.

The PS5’s key features will have more bark than bite.

It’s inevitable this will lead to a performance hit for Sony’s console relative to the Xbox Series X. Yet it also leaves room to hope the price could hit the lower end of the spectrum. The PlayStation 5’s more reserved silicon should mean lower costs for Sony, and a better price at retail.

Don’t get too excited. I still think the PlayStation 5 will be $500 at launch. However, I’m thinking the Xbox Series X will end up at $600, so Sony’s console is going to look like a bargain.

Sony’s PlayStation 3 struggled not only because of its custom architecture, but because the architecture was expensive (the PS3 also had a pricey Blu-Ray drive). It drove the price of the PS3 up to $600 at launch, while the Xbox 360 was just $400 at launch. That mistake left an impression on Sony. The company is now conservative about hardware performance and price.

That’s important. While I think Sony’s focus is misguided, it’s no disaster. Sony and Microsoft will release new consoles later this year, and Sony’s is almost certain to be more affordable. For many gamers, that’s all that will matter.

Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
PlayStation confirms new PS2 sales numbers to hold onto its record
A close-up of a PlayStation 2's buttons. The reset button is on top and the eject button is on the bottom.

Despite modern consoles like the Nintendo Switch continuing to rise in the charts, the PlayStation 2 is still the highest-selling video game console of all time, with new numbers confirmed Tuesday for the first time.

Sony published a console history on the PlayStation website in celebration of PlayStation's 30th anniversary, and it includes a new sales number for the PS2. This brings the total sales up to 160 million. While Nintendo always seems to be nipping at Sony's heels with the Nintendo DS and Switch, the DS still remains the second-highest-selling console at around 154 million followed immediately by the Switch at around 146 million, according to Nintendo's website.

Read more
The PlayStation Portal is finally worth buying
A Pulse Elite, DualSense, and PlayStation Portal sit on a table.

Whether you're looking at the base PlayStation 5 or the Pro model, investing in a current-gen machine hasn't gotten any cheaper since launch. While sales for Sony's newest console are by no means bad, there are still a large number of players out there who are either sticking with their PS4s or simply holding off on buying hardware entirely. Sadly, $450 is the lowest admission price (excluding the rare discount or buying secondhand), and it is not an insignificant amount of money for most people.

The PlayStation Portal was originally launched as an accessory to the PS5, much to the chagrin of those who were hoping for the next iteration of the PlayStation Vita. It isn't quite the dedicated PlayStation handheld we wanted, but it might be the closest thing we get. Thanks to a fresh update, this $200 device has transformed into a no-brainer entry point to the PlayStation ecosystem that doesn't break the bank, and I can easily recommend to almost anyone.
Step through the portal
At launch, the PlayStation Portal was fairly limited in functionality. It would allow you to play your PS5 games remotely so long as both were connected to the internet. That kept it from truly competing with devices like the Steam Deck or Nintendo Switch, which could function completely independently. That has all changed with the latest firmware update. Now, the Portal can stream a selection of PS5 games directly from the cloud via the internet -- no PS5 required. While the update to the Portal doesn't fully take it off the leash -- you're still tethered to a Wi-Fi connection -- it does create the perfect on-ramp for new players.

Read more
Your PlayStation Portal is about to get a much-requested feature
PlayStation Portal bundle home screen while turned on.

Sony is about to introduce more ways to use your PlayStation Portal. The company announced that it's releasing a cloud streaming feature in beta that will let users stream certain games to the device without needing a console.

This is part of a larger PS Portal update that will also bring along audio fixes and be available starting Wednesday. PlayStation hasn't noted how long cloud streaming will be in testing for, but it's looking for user feedback and is expected to change features over time.

Read more