Skip to main content

‘Red Dead Redemption 2’ scene alludes to notorious 19th-century serial killers

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Red Dead Redemption 2 is a massive, meticulously designed game. Rockstar Games took great care in bringing this game to life in painstaking detail. It wouldn’t be surprising to see players discover new wrinkles months or even years from now. More than a month after launch, one historian has discovered an allusion to a family of 19th-century serial killers.

Historian and writer Mike Stuchbery stumbled upon this at the Aberdeen Pig Farm. The farm is marked on your map, located southeast of Emerald Ranch. You have to approach the front porch to initiate the mission. A large man named Bray Aberdeen comes out on the porch and asks you to have dinner with him and Tammy, a woman who appears to be his wife.

Once you get inside, you need to go check on Tammy upstairs before dinner starts. At dinner, it’s pretty clear that Bray and Tammy are actually brother and sister. It’s all quite creepy. After you eat dinner, you’re offered a drink from an “Aberdeen family recipe.” It’s strong stuff. The screen turns from hazy to dark, and Arthur awakens in a mass grave near the farm.

Side note: This was the second time we were invited into someone’s house only to wake up in a random spot with less money in Red Dead Redemption 2, so think before you accept invites into the homes of strangers.

Stuchbery, however, returned to the house and connected the Aberdeens with the real-life Bender family. The Benders presided in Kansas in the 1870s. John Jr. and Kate Bender were siblings with a creepy relationship just like Bray and Tammy. In the early 1870s, people went missing near the Benders’ property. In 1873, investigators finally searched the area and found eight bodies in the yard (along with random body parts), which Red Dead Redemption 2 parallels with the mass grave Arthur wakes up in.

The Bender family earned the moniker “Bloody Benders” for their gruesome murders. Remarkably, no one really knows what happened to the Bender family.

Red Dead Redemption 2 is just the latest piece of media to allude to the mysterious killings, joining Neil Gaiman’s American Gods and the TV series Supernatural, among many others.

Editors' Recommendations

Steven Petite
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Steven is a writer from Northeast Ohio currently based in Louisiana. He writes about video games and books, and consumes…
GTA 4 and Red Dead Redemption remasters reportedly shelved to focus on GTA 6
Niko Bellic with arms outstretched in Grand Theft Auto IV.

Rockstar Games has reportedly halted plans to remaster Grand Theft Auto IV and Red Dead Redemption, following the lukewarm reception to Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy – The Definitive Edition, which launched in 2021. Instead, Rockstar will shift its focus to the upcoming Grand Theft Auto VI -- a game that has been in the works for a while now.

This news first came from reputable GTA insider Tez, who said Grand Theft Auto IV and Red Dead Redemption remasters had been "on the table a few years ago," before Rockstar shelved plans to move forward. This was then independently corroborated by Kotaku, citing sources with knowledge of Rockstar’s plans. According to Kotaku, these two remasters aren't necessarily canceled for good, but Rockstar seems to have shifted most of its focus toward Grand Theft Auto VI for now since the demand for it is so high.

Read more
GTA+ feels like last nail in the coffin for Red Dead Online
Two outlaws on horseback chase a cowboy across the desert in Red Dead Online.

It feels like every single headline I've seen recently in a story about Rockstar has included Grand Theft Auto Online somehow. With the massively popular multiplayer component of Grand Theft Auto V releasing as a stand-alone game recently, it's no surprise that Rockstar is going all-in on it. GTA Online has been around since 2013, when GTA V launched. And it didn't just retain a player base, but grew it larger and larger.

GTA+ is the be-all and end-all of that, the four-carat diamond ring planted on the online game's finger that says "you're my forever." It offers players (specifically those on Xbox Series X/S or PS5) a ton of free rewards, from $500,000 in GTA bucks in their in-game bank accounts to entire properties needed to take part in certain pieces of content.

Read more
Red Dead Online Call to Arms: Tips and tricks for beginners
red dead online

Polish those pistols and pick out your favorite hat. It's time to jump into Call to Arms, the all-new PvE survival mode in Red Dead Online. Strawberry is under siege. It's up to you and your posse to ride into town and save the day, like the climax of any good Western. Survival is key, so here are some tips and tricks to winning Call to Arms rounds in Red Dead Online.

Red Dead Online's season passes should become a live service standard
Is Red Dead Online worth playing in 2021?
Red Dead Online tips and tricks

Read more