Skip to main content

Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn is a ‘Soulslite,’ but I don’t feel a difference yet

Nor fights a Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn boss with her gun.
Kepler Interactive

As I played through a demo of Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn, a fast and furious new action RPG, I felt a small yearning. I’m still waiting for the Soulslike genre to have its Spelunky moment.

In 1980, a game called Rogue released, and it left a lasting impact because of its unique structure. If players died, it wasn’t possible to reload a save and continue playing through that same adventure; instead, the dungeon would be procedurally generated and players would have to start fresh with a new character. This would go on to inspire a genre of games called “roguelikes,” but that genre truly came into its own decades later thanks to Spelunky.

Recommended Videos

Game designer Derek Yu discovered that the core design philosophies that made Rogue special weren’t restricted to its specific gameplay style. Spelunky recontextualized the ideas of randomized runs and punishing deaths that encourage players to get better from Rogue to a 2D platformer. In doing so, Yu exposed a whole new group of players to the engrossing gameplay loop that the original Rogue uncovered and created a new genre. Now, roguelikes and roguelites are a massive genre full of diverse games, from Balatro to The Rogue Prince of Persia.

Gameplay from Spelunky.
Mossmouth

The Soulslike is now a full-fledged subgenre too, as FromSoftware forged a challenging but rewarding design loop through Demon’s Souls and Dark Souls. The formula encourages players to learn mechanics, get better, and overcome the tough enemy keeping them down. I love that FromSoftware’s games have had that effect, but my biggest problem with Soulslikes is that they all look and feel too much like Dark Souls. Many Soulslikes adopt similar control schemes, camera perspectives, and combat to FromSoftware titles when they could be applying that design to new and unexpected genres or styles of control.

When A44 started to refer to its new game, Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn, as a “Soulslite,” I had hoped the studio had finally cracked the code and given the genre its Spelunky moment. That is very much not the case, even if Flintlock adds its own flourishes with guns and more fast-paced platforming and combat. While I’m sure fans of Dark Souls will enjoy Flintlock, I can’t help but think of all the players put off by Soulslikes who could discover the beauty of the formula if a game redefined Dark Souls as Spelunky did to Rogue.

Still a Soulslike

Flintlock takes place in what A44 calls a “gunpowder fantasy” world. Imagine if Game of Thrones took place around World War I. This gives the game a unique aesthetic and gun-powered flair to combat. Players can shoot their flintlock pistol to stun them mid-attack animation or fire at enemies with a rifle from afar and use a gunpowder blast to break a long fall. There’s also the godlike companion with its own moves and a combo system that can increase how much Reputation — Flintlock’s versions of Souls — players receive.

Gameplay from Flintlock The Siege of Dawn.
Kepler Interactive

A44 believes that this more frenetic gameplay, colorful aesthetic, and combo system give Flintlock enough of a distinct flavor to call it a Soulslite rather than a Soulslike. Although I do think what I played of Flintlock is solid, the Soulslite labeling doesn’t feel quite right. While gameplay speed can increase, the cadence of attacking, blocking, dodging, and parrying always feels the same. Flintlock adopts that and similar controls to Dark Souls; the only real differences are that I can sometimes interrupt enemies with a gunshot and the world I’m fighting in is much more colorful.

As I play, I just can’t help but wish that Soulslikes were getting even more experimental and ambitious. To be fair, I think games like Flintlock are laying the groundwork for that. A44 is proving that Soulslike combat shouldn’t just be restricted to swords and magic. Stellar Blade blended in elements of character action games like Devil May Cry, while Another Crab’s Treasure was almost as much of a 3D platformer as it was a Soulslike. All of these games also aren’t afraid of difficulty, which inherently makes them a bit more accessible than Dark Souls.

While I do appreciate that Soulslikes are trying to make themselves stand out from the Souls games more, none of them have gone all the way like Spelunky did for its own genre. All Soulslikes are inherently derivative of FromSoftware’s work, but I think there’s still more room for ambitious game designs to explore and expand the concept of what a Soulslike or Soulslite could mean. In fact, FromSoftware seems to be the only studio that can top itself by transforming Dark Souls’ mechanics to work in a parry-focused game like Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, a mecha game with Armored Core VI, and an open-world adventure like Elden Ring.

Nor aims a gun at an enemy in Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn.
Kepler Interactive

Souls games don’t click with players just because they control a certain way and have a certain cadence to battles. They stick with me because of the constant push and pull. I get great feelings of shame when I fail and of victory when I overcome a tough opponent. I keep playing because we know we have to get back to a certain point of proven skill or be punished, not because it’s our Souls or something synonymous with it.

I don’t know what exactly that looks like in something like a platformer, strategy game, or card game, but the game designer who cracks that code could take Souls-inspired games to the next level. When that happens, then I think we can start throwing the term Soulslite around. Until then, Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn doesn’t quite feel like it’s standing out from the crowd as much as it intends to. That might be great news for genre purists, but the full game will need to take its ideas one step further to really impress me.

Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn launches later this year for PS5, Xbox Series X/S, and PC.

Topics
Tomas Franzese
A former Gaming Staff Writer at Digital Trends, Tomas Franzese now reports on and reviews the latest releases and exciting…
This Acer gaming PC with RTX 3050 is on sale for just $700
The Acer Nitro 50 gaming PC on a white background.

You don't need to spend more than $1,000 when buying a new gaming desktop, and you can spend much lower than that if you take advantage of the discounts from gaming PC deals. Amazon has an offer for the Acer Nitro 50 that you wouldn't want to miss: $100 in savings off its original price of $800, so you'll only have to pay $700 for this machine. It won't stay at 13% off for much longer though, so you better hurry and buy the gaming desktop right now.

Why you should buy the Acer Nitro 50 gaming PC
The Acer Nitro 50 is a decent choice for playing the best PC games, as it's powered by the 14th-generation Intel Core i5 processor, the Nvidia GeForce RTX 3050 graphics card, and 16GB of RAM that will be enough for most gamers, according to our guide on how to buy a gaming desktop. It's not going to challenge the performance of the top-of-the-line models of the best gaming PCs, and it may struggle to run upcoming PC games at their highest settings, but the Acer Nitro 50 is an excellent and affordable option that will let you explore the world of PC gaming.

Read more
Where to find the cartographer in Dawntrail in Avowed
An environment shot of the Dawnshore Eastern Overlands in Avowed.

After the tutorial teaches you the essential tips and tricks for playing Avowed, you will be set free in the Living Lands. Almost right away you will encounter a man named Sanza who has an important side quest for you to locate a missing cartographer. While you might be eager to complete the main story, side quests are important for unlocking new abilities and exploring the world. Unlike most side quests, however, this one only gives you a vague written description of where the cartographer is instead of a marker on your map to travel to. Even though each zone in Avowed isn't massive, there is still a lot of ground to cover when looking for a single person. Here's where you can find the cartographer in Dawntrail.
Where to find the missing cartographer

The side quest only says that the cartographer should be located near some cliffs on the east side of Dawntrail, which is quite a big place to search. The area you're looking for is called Usher's Hand and is directly east of Paradis. If you go out the eastern exit and head north, you will find it no problem.

Read more
How to respec in Avowed
A player casting an ice spell in Avowed

Avowed is a very flexible game in terms of letting you use any weapon or piece of armor you want. Having a variety of offensive options is one of the best tips and tricks we can give you, but skills are slightly different. You will be investing points into your stats, to unlock abilities, and unlock companion abilities as you earn XP and level up. These skills will completely change how your game plays both in and out of combat, but you don't have to stick with whatever direction you picked first if you end up regretting it. Here's how you can respec your character in Avowed.

Read more