Skip to main content

Valve programmer reveals why there’s no crowbar in Half-Life: Alyx

The crowbar, the iconic weapon of Half-Life protagonist Gordon Freeman, is nowhere to be found in Half-Life: Alyx, and Valve designer and programmer Robin Walker revealed why that is the case.

In an interview with Kotaku, Walker said that the Half-Life: Alyx development team “lost, like, a year and a half of our lives trying to get a crowbar in VR.”

Walker revealed that the crowbar created interesting gameplay scenarios, including puzzles that were solved by using the tool to reach through tight spaces and pull something towards the player. But it appears that the crowbar resulted in too many problems.

According to Walker, players testing Half-Life: Alyx would forget that they were holding the crowbar, so it kept hooking on things. The programmers tried fixing that by turning its physics off and stopping it from colliding with objects while it is off-screen, but nothing proved effective.

Walker also said that the crowbar, as the iconic melee weapon of the series, did not fit into Half-Life: Alyx, which primarily uses ranged combat.

The biggest problem that resulted in the removal of the crowbar, however, is that players thought that if they were holding it, they were playing as Gordon.

“It didn’t matter how much we told them, like, literally at the start of the game, that they aren’t Gordon,” Walker said. “We would finish playtests and ask players, ‘So tell us what’s happened so far. Tell us everything you learned about the state of the world and what the story’s about.’ And the players would think they’re Gordon.”

Valve wanted to maintain a unique identity for Alyx, and with the crowbar so closely associated with Gordon, the alien-killing weapon was removed from Half-Life: Alyx.

Half-Life remains popular

Half-Life: Alyx, which is set between the events of Half-Life and Half-Life 2, significantly boosted sales of the Valve Index, as all purchases of the VR headset came with a free copy of the game. The massive demand, in conjunction with supply chain disruptions, resulted in a shortage of stocks for the VR headset, though it went on sale again for a limited time earlier this month.

Valve programmer David Speyrer hinted in an interview with The Verge in November last year that if Half-Life: Alyx succeeds, Half-Life 3 may be under consideration. It remains to be seen if that will indeed happen, but in the meantime, Valve expects the series’ dedicated fan base to create a mod that will allow Half-Life: Alyx to be played outside of virtual reality.

Editors' Recommendations

Aaron Mamiit
Aaron received a NES and a copy of Super Mario Bros. for Christmas when he was 4 years old, and he has been fascinated with…
Valve knows that a non-VR Half-Life: Alyx mod will be made by game’s fans
Half-Life: Alyx Gravity Gloves

While Half-Life: Alyx isn't officially playable without a virtual reality headset, developer Valve knows that its dedicated fan base will likely mod the new release for traditional PC play.

"Yes, it’s going to happen," Robin Walker of Valve admits in an interview with Polygon. "I’m fine with it. For the sake of the other members of the team, I don’t want to say I encourage you to do it, but it’s going to happen."

Read more
Valve Index VR goes on sale again Monday in time for Half-Life: Alyx
Valve Index VR

Valve announced that the Index VR headset will be back in stock for a limited time this Monday, March 9. The Steam creator revealed the return of the anticipated headset on Twitter after weeks of it being out of stock due to Coronavirus related issues.

Read more
Valve will sell ‘far fewer’ Index VR headsets due to coronavirus outbreak
Valve Index HMD release date store page leak june 2019 controller base station

The outbreak of coronoavirus, officially called Covid-19, has been the cause of a range of issues in the tech world, from the canceling of MWC to Apple announcing it is unlikely to meet its quarterly forecasts. Now, it is impacting the production of hardware as well, with Valve announcing that it will have "far fewer" units of its Index VR headset available to purchase.

“With Half-Life: Alyx coming on March 23, we are working hard to meet demand for the Valve Index and want to reassure everyone that Index systems will be available for purchase prior to the game’s launch,” a Valve spokesperson said in a statement given to Road to VR. “However, the global coronavirus health crisis has impacted our production schedules so we will have far fewer units for sale during the coming months compared to the volumes we originally planned. Our entire team is working hard right now to maximize availability.”

Read more