Skip to main content

FCC’s revisions would ban throttling, but leave paid ‘fast lanes’ open

Under pressure from legions of online protesters, as well as heavyweights in the tech world like Google, Yahoo, and Netflix, FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler announced revisions to the commission’s recent proposal for net neutrality regulation, designed to disallow unfair advantages given to companies who pay for faster access online.

Though still under scrutiny from net neutrality advocates, the new revisions ostensibly attempt to both stop ISPs (Internet Service Providers) from giving preferential treatment to companies who put up cash for faster Internet access, as well as preventing them from intentionally slowing traffic for select services. Both issues have been of major concern as of late, but the latter issue was recently brought to light thanks to allegations made by Internet backbone companies Cogent and Level 3, which said that ISPs like Comcast and AT&T have been intentionally throttling video services on their networks for over a year by purposely refusing to upgrade their basic infrastructure.

Recommended Videos

The original wording of the FCC’s new regulatory proposal was immediately under fire, as it addressed the issues raised by Cogent and Level 3 to stop services from intentionally slowing streams, but left the door open for ISPs and other services to accept payment for access to Internet fast lanes. Today’s revisions are designed to allay such concerns, ahead of a vote on the new proposal this Thursday.

A Wall Street Journal report quoted an official from the FCC who said that the commission will be looking into banning paid prioritization deals outright, ostensibly to include those made by Netflix with Verizon and Comcast, in which the popular streaming service made unprecedented concessions to pay those ISPs directly for access to faster connection. Netflix has since denounced those deals, claiming it was compelled to make the agreements thanks to slowing speeds on those networks.

According to the Journal, the commission is also looking into categorizing ISPs as utilities, which would subject them to greater regulatory restrictions.

However, it’s unclear whether Wheeler’s latest revision will have any teeth. As of now, cash deals between ISPs and other services would still be allowed. According to officials, the FCC will “scrutinize the deals to make sure that the broadband providers don’t unfairly put non-paying companies’ content at a disadvantage.” But given the lax approach the FCC has taken on the matter, even before a landmark court decision in favor of Verizon dissolved previous net neutrality regulations, today’s draft still has many neutrality advocates crying foul.

Concerns over the new regulations are worrisome enough that two of the five FCC commissioners involved, Democrat Jessica Rosenworcel and Republican Ajit Pai, have reportedly called for Thursday’s vote to be delayed while the commission addresses the issues raised by net neutrality advocates.

As it stands, the new drafted proposal essentially leaves the matter up to the FCC and chairman Wheeler’s own judgement as to whether or not handshake agreements for faster access represent an unfair advantage to other services online. And that kind of leeway leaves a lot of holes exposed in the regulatory armor – especially given the amount of money ISPs like Comcast, who is in the middle of a $45.2 billion merger with Time Warner Cable, have to throw around. 

We’ll continue to follow this story as it unfolds, so stay tuned for more updates. What do you think about the new revisions? Are you confident that the FCC can keep things fair for all companies competing for fair access online? Let us know in the comments.

Ryan Waniata
Former Home Theater & Entertainment Editor
Ryan Waniata is a multi-year veteran of the digital media industry, a lover of all things tech, audio, and TV, and a…
Buy your dad an Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K, get it by Father’s Day, and save 40%
The newest version of the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K has WiFi 6.

Not every Father's Day gift has to be something new, big, and exciting. If your dad's idea of the best TV ever is the one he already has, but you all know it could use a boost, then you should take a look at this great offer on the latest version of the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K. Usually $50, you can save 40% and get one for just $30 at this time (that's a savings of $20). As of June 12, Amazon says the TV upgrade will arrive two days before Father's Day if you use the fastest shipping (available free with your Amazon Prime free trial). That means I could order it as late as July 14 and get the device on Father's Day. Your particular situation could vary, so tap the button below and check out the info for yourself. Otherwise, keep reading to see all the details and figure out if the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K is a good gift for Dad (or yourself).

Why you should buy the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K

Read more
At $120 off, the most comfortable noise-canceling headphones are now at a comfortable price
Sonos Ace with a Sonos Arc.

One of the best things about wearing noise-canceling headphones is the great deal of comfort they bring when in loud, chaotic environments. However, they need to really fit around your head to get that seal, which can lead to some comfort issues. If you're the type that wants to float away into your music or studies, then the Sonos Ace are your absolute best bet, and they are the headphones we consider to be the overall best noise-canceling headphones for comfort. Unfortunately, they're usually $449, the same price as the brand new Sony WH-1000XM6. Now, however, in a deal you can find at any major retailer, they're discounted by $120, making them just $329. Tap the appropriate button below to make your purchase or keep reading to see just how comfortable the Sonos Ace are, and learn about the special link they have with the best soundbar Sonos makes.

Why you should buy the Sonos Ace

Read more
FIFA Club World Cup 2025: What is it, and what new tech is it bringing?
There's a surprising amount of new tech featuring at the 2025 Club World Club
Soccer ball in net

The FIFA Club World Cup 2025 kicks off June 14 in North America, as the best club sides from domestic soccer leagues around the world take to the field in a tournament which will crown the best club in the world.

This isn’t to be confused with the very similarly named FIFA World Cup - which is also being hosted by the US in 2026 along with Canada and Mexico - where the top nations from around the world (think the USMNT, Brazil, England etc) compete to be the best country in the world.

Read more