Skip to main content

Comcast formally files for Time Warner mega-merger, promises expanded net neutrality

comcast fires back against netflixs poor viewability claims time warner merger
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Comcast set the pieces on the board today for a game that it hopes will result in the absorption of Time Warner Cable to create a super media conglomerate. After completing the required Hart-Scott-Rodino notification with the Department of Justice, the company filed the necessary joint Applications and Public Interest Statement with the FCC today, and Comcast Executive Vice President David Cohen will testify before a Senate Judiciary Committee tomorrow to plead his case for the merger.

To outline his defense of the merger that will consolidate an unprecedented amount of power across media lines, from cable holdings and broadband infrastructure, to broadcast and media content control, Cohen took to the Internet this morning in a blog.

In his argument, Cohen attempts to make a case for the merger by outlining several reasons that “Comcast and TWC are better together for millions of customers and businesses.” Cohen raises a litany of proposed benefits in his post to quell concerns from a multitude of parties, including claims that the merger will provide faster Internet speeds (specifically for TWC customers), a “fully upgraded network” with highly reliable and secure service, “robust” VOD services, a commitment to diversity and inclusion, and “the extension of the FCC’s Open Internet rules on network neutrality.”

That last point appears to reference Comcast’s handshake agreement to uphold net neutrality, or fair play online, until 2018 , which may actually be Comcast’s best argument. When the company bought NBC Universal, it agreed to uphold net neutrality as part of the deal. As of now, thanks to Verizon’s recent legal victory, the FCC is unable to enforce basic net neutrality under current rules. The merger would potentially enforce Comcast’s agreement for TWC’s umbrella, adding basic net neutrality for a larger broadband market.

Comcast already holds a lot of keys, and this deal will give it a whole lot more to play with.

Cohen goes on to argue that the merger will make the two massive companies more efficient. The notion of streamlining seems to be the underlying theme here, such as a case Cohen lays out for businesses spread across the country: “Today, if you had a real estate business with offices in New York, Boston, and Washington, DC – Comcast and TWC couldn’t easily offer you a seamless business solution for these multiple locations,” Cohen argues.

However, as pointed out by those who oppose the merger – a coalition of sorts which includes politicians in congress, consumer advocacy groups, competing companies, and Comcast haters across the nation – the merger would appear to put far too much power in Comcast’s hands, and destroy fundamental competition across multiple media markets. In other words, Comcast already holds a lot of keys, and this deal will give it a whole lot more to play with.

The notion of a lack of competition should the merger proceed is not some theoretical notion of capitalism on a broader scale, but a fundamental rule of dollars and cents. As was quoted in a recent DT piece on the subject, Senior Staff Attorney for Public Knowledge John Bergmayer put it very succinctly, “By raising the costs of its rivals and business partners, an enlarged Comcast would raise costs for consumers, who ultimately pay the bills. It would be able to keep others from innovating, while facing little pressure to improve its own service.”

That’s the fear from multiple parties, and that’s what consumers will likely face if the merger proceeds. With so much power across industries, why should Comcast innovate or upgrade when the majority of its subscribers have no viable alternative? Meanhwile, the deal could send the already high prices of American broadband access skyrocketing from the competition, while Comcast essentially controls the price. Not great. 

By the numbers

For those who haven’t been following just what the merger of the two largest MSOs will mean in actual numbers, here’s a quick breakdown of the current holdings of both companies, the money changing hands, and what a merger will mean.

  • A combination of around 34 million video subscribers, or about 28 percent of the nation’s subscribers
  • A combined 31 million broadband subscribers, or between 34 and 40 percent of all broadband access
  • A spin-off of 3 million of Comcast’s current subscribers to smaller MSOs
  • A much larger geographic reach, expanding Comcast’s current heavy presence on the West Coast, Pennsylvania, and Florida to TWC’s New York, Ohio, and Texas territories
  • $45.2 billion in stock and cash for the sale
  • A proposed buy-back by the conglomerate of around $10 billion in Comcast stock

Bad blood

Further worriesome, is Comcast’s notoriously bad customer service ratings. According to Business Insider, Comcast’s ASCI (American Customer Satisfaction Index) scores from 2013 were woefully low, with consumers ranking the company the third lowest in phone service, the second lowest TV service, and the bottom of the barrel of Internet Service Providers. And in what seems like an amazingly unlucky coincidence, on the same day of its filing with the FCC this morning, Comcast was named the Worst Company in America by the Consumerist – the second time the company has garnered the dishonor. Ouch.

What happens in the future as Comcast proceeds will likely shape the video and broadband landscape for years to come. At a time when the entire multi-media paradigm is in flux, this kind of consolidation is troubling. We’ll find out just how much influence Comcast has as it prepares its main defense before the Senate committee tomorrow.

What do you think about the merger? Has Cohen convinced you? Let us know in the comments.

[Update: this article was supplemented to reflect Comcast’s new title from the Consumerist as ‘Worst Company in America’, 4/8/2014]

Ryan Waniata
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Waniata is a multi-year veteran of the digital media industry, a lover of all things tech, audio, and TV, and a…
Best subwoofer deals: Up the bass for as low as $90
The Klipsch Reference Series 12 on a shelf.

A home audio setup isn’t complete without some bass, and whether you’re looking to add one of the best subwoofers to your arrangement or something more affordable, there are a lot of subwoofer deals worth taking a look at. Some of the best TV brands make great complementary audio equipment, so you’ll find the likes of Sony, LG, and Hisense among currently discounted subwoofers. But you’ll also find some more subtle brands with some impressive savings. We’ve tracked down all of the best subwoofer deals you can shop right now, so if you’ve been shopping the best TV deals and need something to pair with a purchase or if you already have a TV that needs an audio upgrade, read onward for more details on how to save on a new subwoofer.
Dr.J Professional 2.1 channel soundbar with subwoofer system -- $90, was $200

More than just the subwoofer, this surround system includes a versatile soundbar or dual-speaker -- it can be split in half -- offering a versatile audio system. It does featured Bluetooth for wireless connectivity, so you can connect a phone or tablet, for example. You can also plug your TV in via HDMI ARC, optical, or 3.5 mm audio. The 35W bass woofer delivers a nice little kick.

Read more
Best Sony TV deals: Save on best-in-class 4K TVs and 8K TVs
The Sony Bravia XR X93L 4K Google TV hanging over a media center in a living room.

Sony has been one of the best TV brands around the globe for decades, and it currently makes some of the best TVs you can buy. This is true whether you prefer 4K or 8K resolution, as well as OLED or QLED picture technologies. But despite its popularity among home theater shoppers, Sony doesn’t price its products out of range for most people. You can almost always find something by Sony among the best TV deals, and there are quite a few Sony TV deals worth taking a look at right now. We’ve tracked down what we feel are the best Sony TV deals among the current crop of sales. While there aren't currently any Sony 8K TV deals to shop, you’ll find a wide selection of Sony 4K TVs below, as well as some information on which may make the right centerpiece for your home theater.
Sony 55-inch X80K 4K Google TV — $600, was $650

Another TV that performs much better than its cost suggests is the X80K. Customers rate it near flawlessly for picture quality, which is enhanced by both the 4K HDR Processor X1 and Triluminos Pro, a system that allows over a billion colors to be used by the X80K's LED screen. You'll also get a 120Hz refresh rate enhanced by Motionflow XR tech to get even the fastest moving items on your screen a crisp look.

Read more
What is Deezer? Features, pricing, and music quality explained
Deezer app on an iPhone 15 Pro.

We're all familiar with music streaming platforms such as Spotify and Apple Music. While these streaming giants are widely used, there are other platforms you can choose from. However, we need to ask ourselves if any music streamer offers extra features for its listeners, particularly in terms of audio quality and personalized recommendations. One does, and it is called Deezer.

Deezer has been around for almost two decades and is a platform that prioritizes premium sound quality while still being affordable for most people. There is a lot to know about Deezer, so we have created this helpful guide to give you a solid idea of the platform.
What is Deezer?

Read more