Skip to main content

As Amazon and Google keep bickering, consumers are the ones who lose

Amazon Echo Show Youtube App

Last summer, when we got an Amazon Echo Show in our house, our son quickly figured out how to ask Alexa to watch snippets of his favorite movies on it. Pretty soon, Moana songs filled our home. Constantly.

But last winter, YouTube went dark on our device, relegating my son to listening only. Ever since, he’s been asking when he can watch videos on our device again. My answer to him: Probably never again. At least not on YouTube.

How could I explain to him, a four year old, that companies Amazon and Google — the biggest adults in the tech space — are waging a fight, which is why he can’t have his Disney movies?

Each side continues to blame the other for the fighting, with each upping the game.

To get you up to speed: Last year, Google, which owns YouTube, pulled all of its videos off Amazon Echo devices with a screen, such as the Echo Show and Amazon’s Fire TV. Google claimed that showing YouTube on Amazon devices violated its terms of service. But the real reason Google/YouTube made the decision can be found in the statement a spokesperson gave on the issue in December:

“We’ve been trying to reach an agreement with Amazon to give consumers access to each other’s products and services. But Amazon doesn’t carry Google products like Chromecast and Google Home, doesn’t make Prime Video available for Google Cast users, and last month stopped selling some of Nest’s latest products. Given this lack of reciprocity, we are no longer supporting YouTube on Echo Show and FireTV.”

In a nutshell, Amazon wasn’t selling Google’s products on its site, so Google pulled YouTube from Amazon products.

Now, apparently, both sides are digging in a bit deeper: Business Insider reported last week that Amazon called Google and told Google it  wouldn’t sell any new Nest (owned by Google) smart home products on the website. To which Google essentially replied, fine, we won’t provide any more of our old Nest products for you guys to sell. So there. (That’s not a direct quote, by the way).

If you search on Amazon’s online marketplace for a Google Chromecast (based on autofill results, many have), you’ll get a listing for an Amazon Fire TV Stick instead. For the time being, you can still find oodles of Nest products to buy, including their Nest Thermostats and cameras (which by the way, work with Alexa). But who knows how much longer they’ll be available.

What if Google/Nest decides that their products shouldn’t work with Alexa anymore?

Each side continues to blame the other for the fighting, with each upping the game, and to be honest, it’s worrying me. So I say to you both: Come on, guys, stop it already. It’s starting to piss me off.

We have Amazon Echo devices in our house, as well as a Nest Cam and a Google Home Mini. That means that both Alexa and Google Assistant live in harmony in our smart space. We use them for different reasons, have them connected to various smart home devices, and appreciate them all. They don’t fight at our house, they just get along. Can’t you guys get along, too?

My concern about the bickering is that it could eventually extend beyond just YouTube viewing or shopping. For example, what if Google/Nest decides that their products shouldn’t work with Alexa anymore? If you bought a Nest Cam or thermostat because you liked that you could communicate with those devices through Alexa, you could be shortchanged down the road.

Philips Hue light bulbs

And what if each company starts demanding loyalty from certain brands, meaning that smart home devices like Philips Hue lighting only come with Alexa or Google Assistant integration and not both? Or what if Google, with its massive search engine, decides to bury Amazon’s website somehow, now that net neutrality rules are no longer? All of those things could spell disaster for consumers.

The point is, how much farther could the two companies take this pettiness? I don’t want to know. And I don’t think anyone else does, either.

As each tech giant continues to hurl stones at each other, it’s clear they’re not just hurting themselves, they’re also hurting the consumers of their products. People have made it clear over and over that they want more streamlined compatibility, not less. Petty moves don’t serve anyone.

So, Amazon and Google: Knock it off already. You’re the tech parents in the room. Time to start acting like it.

Editors' Recommendations

Is the Pixel Tablet a competitor to the Echo Show 15?
The Google Pixel Table and the Speaker Dock.

This past week's Google event showed off quite a few products, but none caught my attention quite like the Google Pixel Tablet. The device looks just like a Nest Home Hub, but that's by design. It can be detached from its base and carried around the house, but upon connection to the speaker dock, it transforms into a smart home device.

I've been asking for a new version of the Nest Hub, and Google delivered -- although not exactly in the way I expected. It also brought another, much-beloved device to mind: the Echo Show 15.

Read more
Matter smart home standard is officially available
The Matter logo on a black background.

After running into a few roadblocks, Matter is officially here. Announced by the Connectivity Standards Alliance (CSA), the Matter certification program is now live, allowing manufacturers to bring the tech to their products and release them on an expedited timeline.

Matter is big news in the smart home community, as it will serve as a universal framework that allows different ecosystems to interact with each other. For example, your Alexa-enabled devices will be able to use Matter to communicate with your Apple HomeKit products. Its goal is to streamline the setup process for smart home devices and build an ecosystem that’s easy to use while bringing together products and software from Samsung, Google, Apple, and over 280 other collaborators.

Read more
The Google Home app finally has the big redesign you’ve been waiting for
Google Home icon on home screen.

A new, major Google Home design overhaul is coming soon to the delight of users everywhere. Many have been unhappy with the Google Home app's UI for quite some time as its streamlined approach to providing information seemingly took some agency away from smart home device owners. The new redesign, however, aims to give users more control over their devices and settings than ever before.

While the redesign certainly retains a more straightforward, minimalist look to its UI elements, the settings themselves are as abundant as ever — giving users full control over every aspect of their smart home. The newfound control doesn't end with more granular settings, however, as the redesign is meant to be fully customizable so that users can prioritize the aspects of smart home living most applicable to them.

Read more