Skip to main content

5G vs. Wi-Fi 6: Which is the future of wireless connectivity?

As an industry analyst covering all things related to network connectivity, I have a unique perspective given the time I spend with enterprise networking infrastructure companies, operators, and service providers. Each makes an argument for why a Wi-Fi 6 or 5G solution is best-suited for deployment given application, use case, or workflow.

Lately, some wireless carriers claim that next-generation 5G deployments will render Wi-Fi obsolete. It is an understandable claim to make given the billions of dollars that AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon are investing in deploying both fixed and mobile 5G networks. However, I will dive deeper into the underlying technologies behind both 5G and Wi-Fi 6 to analyze each and determine if a true winner can be crowned.

Related Videos

Three consideration vectors

In my analysis of 5G and Wi-Fi 6, my key takeaway is that it comes down to three vectors: Economics, propagation, and scale. Let us examine each.

From an economics perspective, 4G LTE and 5G (which I will collectively refer to as mobile broadband) are inherently more expensive to integrate from a chipset and software perspective into devices relative to Wi-Fi 6 (although companies such as Marvell and Qualcomm are bridging that silicon gap). Furthermore, the licensed spectrum aspect of mobile broadband typically equates to a monthly charge per device. However, private cellular networks are gaining momentum and will likely grow with the OnGo/CBRS initiative. I wrote an article about private cellular networking for reference.

5G and Wi-Fi 6 are not in a grudge match — they’re complementary.

Propagation is a second consideration. Today, mobile broadband has significant challenges in traveling through walls and objects versus Wi-Fi 6. Many companies such as JMA Wireless, Airspan Networks, and others are attempting to solve this challenge, but the effort is still nascent. However, with optimal midband licensed spectrum assets, 5G can be a compelling machine-to-machine connectivity option for factory and process automation use cases in more open industrial spaces. On the other hand, Wi-Fi, with its access point and router install base density, provides excellent propagation and performance for most traditional campus environments.

Finally, there’s scale. Wi-Fi enjoys a significant install base footprint in organizations large and small, and Wi-Fi 6 delivers improvements in performance, latency, power consumption, and device density over prior generations. On the other hand, 5G has traditionally been used for redundancy in mission-critical operations. Still, its adoption is growing significantly in light of private cellular networking and the momentum behind Open RAN that can dramatically reduce capital expenditures on infrastructure deployment.

IT vs. OT environments

Another factor to consider in evaluating 5G and Wi-Fi 6 is the actual deployment area within the enterprise. For a quick explanation, IT typically refers to the computer hardware and software in the traditional office environment, while OT monitors and controls manufacturing, industrial assets, and processes. In my opinion, Wi-Fi 6 will continue to enjoy widespread deployment in IT, given its install base. In contrast, OT, or “non-carpeted” areas of enterprises, have traditionally lacked connectivity or employ a mishmash of solutions that are often proprietary and difficult to manage. Consequently, 5G is poised to bring a compelling connectivity option to OT environments.

Wrapping Up

From my perspective, 5G and Wi-Fi 6 are not in a grudge match. Instead, use cases and economics will drive a blend of both connectivity options. There’s no doubt that 5G is a game-changer given its ultralow latency, and it will birth a new set of applications in manufacturing, health care, smart cities, and automotive, among others. However, Wi-Fi 6 will also continue to evolve and provide a highly scalable, cost-effective connectivity solution for knowledge workers within a campus environment. Bottom line, 5G and Wi-Fi 6 are better together!

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
CES 2023: This Android phone can send satellite text messages to your iPhone
CES 2023 promo for Bullitt's satellite connectivity.

One of the most remarkable features of the iPhone 14 and iPhone 14 Pro is support for satellite connectivity, allowing users to call for emergency services and send SOS messages when they can’t find a cellular or Wi-Fi connection. Motorola will bring that functionality to the Android smartphone ecosystem within the next three months, according to an announcement at CES 2023. The company has partnered with the British brand Bullitt and will introduce the connectivity perk on one of its upcoming Defy series phones.

To enable satellite communication, Bullitt has created custom connectivity hardware for the phone, which works in tandem with a custom app called Bullitt Satellite Messenger. Again, the idea is to cover zones where users lose out on cellular networks or Wi-Fi coverage, especially in cases of emergencies in remote areas. The messaging part is enabled by Bullitt Satellite Messenger, which needs a subscription service that costs $5 per year.

Read more
I don’t want to see 5G on any phone in 2023
OnePlus 7 Pro 5G

I don’t want to see 5G on any phone in 2023. Why? It’s a complete waste of space, nobody actually uses it, and to the average person on the street, it means absolutely nothing. Yet, it has been a regular feature on new phones for years now.

Before everyone gets all uptight and starts stabbing out an angry email, I’m not talking about 5G, I’m talking about the tiresome practice of adding 5G to the end of phone names. We get it, it has 5G. So do the vast majority of phones out there, and it’s time to differentiate those that don’t, rather than those that do.
Enough already
Samsung Galaxy S10 5G. Julian Chokkattu/Digital Trends

Read more
Verizon’s cheapest 5G unlimited plan just got even cheaper
Verizon banner splashed across iPhone screen.

Verizon is one of the top service providers in the world, and now it's sweetening the deal on its cheapest unlimited 5G plan. Currently, Verizon offers a handful of different service options, with the Welcome Unlimited plan being its cheapest.

An end-of-the-year deal, however, is reducing the price of the Welcome Unlimited plan even further by $5 per month per line — making it one of the cheapest unlimited 5G plans on the market.

Read more