Understanding the EU’s antitrust inquiry into Apple’s iBookstore


Remember back in early 2010 when Apple launched iBookstore? The idea of selling electronic books wasn’t new — the Kindle, Sony Reader, Barnes & Noble Nook, and other e-readers were already on the market, along with their associated book stores and third-party efforts like Google Books. But one thing that made consumers’ jaws drop when Apple unveiled iBookstore was the price tags: New releases were initially priced at $12.99 to $14.99 each, compared to the $9.99 typically offered by Amazon and others. Now, the European Commission has launched a formal antitrust investigation looking into whether five major publishers — perhaps with Apple’s help — abused their market position to effectively raise the price of e-books in Europe.


The investigation specifically targets Simon & Schuster, Harper Collins (owned by News Corp), Penguin (owned by the UK’s Pearson Group), Hachette (part of France’s Lagardere Publishing), and Verlagsgruppe George von Holzbrink (which owns MacMillan). The EC intends to examine whether those publishers, perhaps in collusion with Apple, conspired to fix pricing for e-books. If so, the actions could be in violation of EU regulations that prohibit cartels and restrictive business practices. The EC notes that the fact they’ve launched a probe will not prejudice the outcome, but it will be treating the case as a matter of priority.

ec privacy laws telco drapeaux europ  ens devant le berlaymontThe EC’s investigation follows on the heels of a similar probe by the UK’s Office of Fair Trading earlier this year, and mirrors a class action lawsuit filed against Apple and the same five publishers in the Northern District of California earlier this summer. Earlier this year, the EC carried out unannounced inspections at the locations of several e-book publishers.

This week, the UK’s OTF closed its investigation “on the grounds of administrative priority,” but will be working closely with the EC as it conducts its own inquiry.

Agency versus wholesale

Here’s how the logic of the anticompetitive argument works: Apple was the first e-book retailer to offer publishers an agency pricing model, rather than a wholesale pricing model. Under a wholesale pricing model, booksellers pay a fixed price for a particular book title, but are free to try to sell it to consumers at any price. They might be able to get a particular book from a publisher for $5, but under a wholesale pricing agreement they can try to sell it for $100 a copy—if they think they can find enough gullible consumers.

kindle against stack of booksUnder an agency model, publishers set the prices retailers can charge for books. Book sellers (like Apple’s iBookstore) are just agents of the publisher, and have to stick to the publisher’s prices. If a publisher decides a book should cost $19.99, then all retailers under that agency deal have to charge $19.99.

Publishers generally favor an agency model: it means prices for particular titles are consistent across a wide range of retailers,offering a better consumer experience, and publishers don’t have to get into complicated negotiations with individual booksellers, distributors, and partners, all of whom are angling for the best price possible. The agency model also makes it easier for publishers to manage their costs and revenue streams. However, retailers — especially big retailers — generally favor a wholesale model: Negotiate the lowest price possible, then sell as many units as they can at the highest price the market will bear. Big retailers benefit from wholesale models because they can leverage their buying power to make bulk purchases, lowering their per-unit costs and increasing their margins. Small, locally-owned bookstores might be able to match Walmart’s pricing on books, but they are almost certainly paying a higher price than Walmart for the same product, and making less money from selling it.

How is an agency model anticompetitive?

An agency pricing model isn’t anticompetitive on its own. However, the European Commission is concerned that Apple setting up agency-based deals with many major publishers at the same time had a negative impact on competition between online booksellers. After all, online booksellers using an agency model can’t really compete with each other by setting lower prices.

Since the introduction of iBookstore, a number of online booksellers have shifted to an agency pricing model. In most cases, they do it so they can continue to sell popular e-book titles from leading publishers — like the five in the investigation. That includes Amazon.com, which was forced to convert over to an agency model in April of 2010. The question before the EC’s antitrust investigation is, essentially: Did Apple’s decision to go with an agency model in its iBookstore force the rest of the industry to convert to an agency model, effectively raising e-book prices for most consumers?

Is Apple to blame? Or merely a victim?

Apple’s launch of iBookstore corresponded to the release of the original iPad. Although Apple was (and remains) the dominant digital music retailer, the company had not yet branched out into e-books. In fact, Apple CEO Steve Jobs raised eyebrows in 2008 when he claimed in the New York Times “people don’t read anymore,” leading many to question whether the iPad would be a capable e-reader. Nonetheless, the Amazon Kindle was seeing tremendous success in the marketplace, and Apple apparently decided that if the iPad was going to take on the Kindle— especially at a substantially higher price point — it would have to be in the e-book business.

apple stocks ipad book store with 30000 free booksHowever, rather than make a deal with Amazon, Sony, Barnes & Noble, or other companies running e-book stores, Apple decided to chart its own course and integrate e-books into its existing digital goods infrastructure. After all, Apple was already handling music, movies, television shows, and apps. That meant Apple had to make its own deals with publishers; however, unlike selling all those other forms of content, which it helped pioneer, Apple came very late to the game on e-books.

Publishers had been chafing against Amazon’s discount wholesale model for some time. The wholesale pricing model was developed from the physical process of printing, shipping, and selling books. Publishers would sell to a retailer (like Amazon or the now-defunct Borders) or an distributor like Ingram, charging a price based on the suggested retail price and a discount schedule — typically 50 percent off the retail price. But under this model, publishers who offered discounts on e-books that were the same as physical book discounts were effectively subsidizing e-book retailers, who were then able to cut e-book prices to consumers. That’s how Amazon started selling new titles at $9.99.

Publishers realized an agency model for e-books would be much more advantageous for them: Not only does it give them more control over e-book pricing and make for a more consistent customer experience across digital goods retailers, but it also brings in more revenue.

So when Apple knocked on publishers’ doors and said “Hey, we’d like to start selling e-books!” the major publishers may have realized they had Apple over a barrel, and replied with “Sure. But we’re not going to make the same mistake with you we did with Amazon.” As long as enough of the major publishers held the line on only signing a deal with Apple if it used an agency model, Apple probably had a choice between agency pricing and a very thin selection of titles for the iBookstore. Publishers then used Apple compliance to force agency pricing on other e-book retailers, with Macmillan being the first to play hardball with Amazon over agency pricing.

How it might play out

If the publishers are found to have colluded to force Apple, Amazon, and others to accept agency pricing models for e-books, they could be forced to pay hefty fines and alter their business practices — that could mean a return to some form of wholesale pricing for e-books in the future. If Apple is found to have cooperated or assisted, Apple could also be on the hook for penalties.

European anti-competition law has no caps, and can extend to up to 10 percent of the worldwide revenue of each company taking part in the infringement, although the commission has wiggle room for lesser and higher penalties.

So far, Apple and Hachette have had no comment on the investigation; Harper Collins and Simon & Schuster indicated only that they are cooperating with the investigation, and representatives of Penguin and Macmillan have denied any wrongdoing.

Smart Home

The Google Home Hub doesn’t have a camera. Here’s why that’s a good thing

Bucking the smart display trend, Google's new $149 Home Hub smart display surprisingly doesn't have a camera. We think a camera-less Google smart speaker with a screen is a good thing, and here's why.
Movies & TV

Celebrate the 25th anniversary of ‘The X-Files’ with the show’s 10 best episodes

The X-Files premiered 25 years ago, so here are the 10 best episodes of the award-winning sci-fi series. From alien-abduction drama to hilarious satires, these are the best episodes from all 11 seasons of the hit series.

Intel's 9th-gen chips could power your next rig. Here's what you must know

The Intel Core i9-9900K processor was the star of the show for consumers, but a powerful 28-core Xeon processor also led announcements. Here's everything you need to know about the latest Intel chipsets.
Movies & TV

Lose the torrents. Here's how to watch 'Game of Thrones' online (legally)

Game of Thrones is one of the most popular shows on TV, but unless you're a cable subscriber, finding a way to watch isn't always easy. Check out our guide on how to watch online, whether you prefer using HBO, Sling TV, Hulu, or Amazon.

The best Pixel 3 screen protectors to keep your phone Pixel perfect

The Pixel 3 is equipped with the hottest hardware and a beautiful 5.5-inch P-OLED display protected by Gorilla Glass 5. But it's not invincible. Here are the best Pixel 3 screen protectors to keep it safe.
Home Theater

Set your ears free with the best completely wireless earbuds

If you can't stand the tangle of cords, or you're just excited about completely wireless earbuds, you're going to need some help separating the wheat from the chaff. Our list serves up the best wireless earbuds around.
Emerging Tech

Regular paints and plastics will soon be able to ‘heal’ like skin

Imagine if paints, plastics, or other coatings could heal up like human skin in the event that they suffered damage. Thanks to researchers at Clemson University, such technology is almost here.

Montblanc’s $995 Summit 2 watch stays on your wrist for longer between charges

Montblanc has taken the wraps off of the new Montblanc Summit 2 -- the first watch to feature the new Qualcomm Snapdragon Wear 3100 processor. The watch features a premium design and Google's Wear OS.

Preapproval for iPhone Upgrade Program now available for iPhone XR

Apple took the wraps off of its new set of iPhones, including the iPhone XS, iPhone XS Max, and the new iPhone XR. The iPhone XR is being offered as the "affordable" iPhone, and it's a little different than the more expensive models.

Double your charging speed with Nomad’s Tesla Model 3 wireless charger

Nomad's wireless charger for the Tesla Model 3 fits the EV's charging dock exactly. If you plug both of the Nomad's into the Model 3's two front USB ports you can charge two smartphones quickly or one phone twice as fast.

Google Pixel 3 vs. Apple iPhone XS: Does Google’s A.I. take down Apple?

The Google Pixel 3 is here, boasting top-tier specs like a Qualcomm Snapdragon 845 and 4GB of RAM, and some of the world's best artificial intelligence features on a phone. But can it take out the Apple iPhone XS?

Hinge's new feature wants to know who you've gone out on dates with

With its new "We Met" feature, Hinge wants to learn how your dates are going with matches in its app. That way, it can inject the information into its algorithm to provide future recommendations that better suit its users' preferences.

Which Verizon plan is best for you? We check out family, individual, and prepaid

Verizon offers lots of plans for individuals, your family, and folks who want prepaid service. Here is everything you need to know about Verizon's plans, from data packages and smartphones to Big Red's prepaid plans.
Product Review

The Huawei Watch GT’s battery life gets a tick, but the software may not tock

Huawei’s track record with smartwatches is strong, having releases two models and several spin-offs to general acclaim. This is the Watch GT, and it moves away from Google’s Wear OS to focus on fitness, yet stays ahead of the…