Skip to main content

Why the lawsuit against Apple’s AirTags may be bigger than you realize

Apple is facing yet another lawsuit, but this one could very well define the future of AirTags. Two women who were victims of stalking using AirTags have filed a class-action lawsuit against Apple in a district court in Northern California. The plaintiffs cite incidents where former partners hid AirTags in a car wheel and a child’s backpack to track their whereabouts and harass them. 

The ordeal is harrowing, but it’s not the first of its kind. Ever since AirTags went on sale, reports of stalking and using them to steal cars have been all over the internet. But this time, Apple has been dragged to court over a rather comprehensive set of charges.

An AirTag attached on a keyring
Digital Trends

Accusing Apple of gross negligence, the plaintiffs allege that the company rushed out a product without proper safeguards. 

Recommended Videos

The design has also been lambasted as the trackers didn’t perform as expected, even though Apple claimed the AirTags are “stalker-proof.” The lawsuit mentions that “AirTag’s design defect was a substantial factor” in causing harm. To recall, AirTags weren’t initially loud enough, and after being flagged, Apple decided to bump up their sonic warning capability. 

The claims against Apple

Among the 12 claims Apple faces, the plaintiffs allege Apple of breaching their privacy by geolocating them, violating state privacy laws, and fraudulent marketing to deceive the public that AirTags were safe. The lawsuit makes it clear that “each Plaintiff continues to be at risk of unwanted and unlawful tracking via an AirTag device.”

Apple AirTag lifestyle image.
Apple AirTag Apple

More importantly, the legal challenge is not merely about winning damages from Apple; it also seeks injunctive relief with measures such as Apple wiping the entire log of the plaintiff’s location data, and halting further tracking of them.

Previous Apple lawsuits and AirTag concerns

The plaintiffs claim that the safeguards put in place by Apple are “woefully inadequate.” Apple’s own safety updates in the past show that it was aware of the lapses and was actively trying to fix them as more abusive use cases pop up. The lawsuit also highlights the safety imbalance between iPhone users and those using an Android phone. 

Stalking also isn’t prosecuted in the same fashion in all states, and in many cases, the victim gets little to nothing in terms of protection and legal backing. In a scenario like that, the onus falls on Apple to come up with safety precautions that can prevent such incidents from befalling people everywhere. 

The scale of impact

The lawsuit goes against Apple is filed on behalf of the following “classes” of people: 

  1. iOS device users who were stalked without consent in the U.S. 
  2. American citizens with an Android phone subjected to nonconsensual stalking. 
  3. Everyone in the U.S. with an iOS device, but still potentially at risk of stalking.
  4. At-risk folks using an Android phone and living in Apple’s home market.

That’s a huge subset of people. As of April this year, at least 150 reports have been filed where AirTags were allegedly misused for stalking. As for the net sales figures, Apple is reportedly targeting a global shipment of 35 million units, according to analyst Ming-Chi Kuo. So, how much does Apple standsto lose? 

Apple AirTag close up.
Apple

The lawsuit seeks “recovery of actual damages or $50, whichever is greater, discretionary treble damages up to $1,000, punitive damages.” The settlement amount will balloon depending on the number of class members that sign up to support the legal challenge.

Assuming it ends in a loss, Apple is more than capable of coughing up a few hundred- million dollars to save face, and it has done so multiple times in the past. But the bigger question is about the existence of AirTag as a category.

What this means for the future of AirTags

Depending on the outcome and whether states (where the victims live) pick up an individual fight over privacy and user safety against Apple, this could challenge the very existence of AirTags as a product category. 

Apple is fiercely resilient at protecting an established product like iPhones and Macs against such legal challenges because they bring in billions of dollars each year. As for the AirTags, they are still in their first-generation phase. But the risks they have generated are far more serious, and not merely hypothetical.

Digital Trends

It would be unwise to speculate that one legal challenge could spell the end for AirTags, but it can’t be ruled out in its entirety. If the cascade effect spills over to other states and more victims come forward with legal challenges, it just might happen. And let’s not rule out the possibility of inquiry by regulatory agencies that are increasingly looking into the state of Big Tech affairs under Federal Trade Commission chair Lina Khan.

Right now, Apple has multiple options on the table. Wave its magical engineering wand to fix all the flaws, recall millions of the sold units and replace them with better (read: safer) upgrades, or completely rethink its strategy for the next-gen AirTags. Irrespective of the outcome, this lawsuit will likely prove to be the litmus test for Apple’s coin-sized object tracker. 

Nadeem Sarwar
Nadeem is a tech and science journalist who started reading about cool smartphone tech out of curiosity and soon started…
The iPhone 17 Air might not stack up in terms of battery life
Alleged concept render of the iPhone 17 Air in black.

Concerns over iPhone 17 Air battery life might have been spot-on, according to a new report from The Information. Apple allegedly conducted internal tests that showed only 60 to 70 percent of iPhone 17 Air devices would make it through the day without needing a recharge, versus between 80 to 90 percent for other iPhone models.

Of course, part of that is due to the design of the handset. At just 5.5mm, the iPhone 17 Air is set to be the thinnest iPhone ever (and one of the thinnest phones on the market overall), but it might come at the cost of battery capacity. To help offset this problem, Apple is supposedly planning to launch an optional battery case accessory to give users a little bit more juice to get them through the day.

Read more
Apple admits Siri’s AI features are “taking a bit longer” than expected
Pulling up Siri on lock screen of iPhone.

On an earnings call with analysts yesterday, Apple CEO Tim Cook said that the more advanced Siri is under active development, but it could still be a while before it arrives. He assured callers that Apple is "making progress," but didn't give any indication of a launch window. Cook spoke extensively about the Apple Intelligence features that have already been released on iOS 18, including Genmoji, Clean Up, ChatGPT integration, and more.

Cook went on to say, "With regard to the more personal Siri features we announced, we need more time to complete our work on these features so they meet our high-quality bar. We are making progress, and we look forward to getting these features into customers’ hands."

Read more
Galaxy S25 Edge leak reveals a look that’s almost iPhone Air like
Galaxy S25 Edge

Two highly anticipated smartphone models are set to launch before the end of the year: Samsung’s Galaxy S25 Edge and Apple’s iPhone 17 Air. Newly released images of the Galaxy S25 Edge, scheduled to arrive this month, reveal a striking resemblance to rumored images of the iPhone 17 Air, which is expected to hit the market in September.

The Galaxy S25 Edge, which Samsung teased earlier this year, will arrive on May 13. When the phone launches, it’s expected to be one of the thinnest smartphones in the world.

Read more