Skip to main content

Wearing this smartwatch again reminded me why it’s still the best you can get

A person wearing the Apple Watch Series 8.
Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

I put the Apple Watch Series 8 back on my wrist recently in preparation for the impending — and inevitable — release of the Apple Watch Series 9. It’s no secret that the Apple Watch is great, but I wanted to see if it’s really as good as I remembered.

After a few months of wearing other smartwatches, I’d only used the Apple Watch Series 8 on a few different occasions, but I’d always considered it the benchmark. Well, it’s not as good as I remembered — it’s even better, and I can’t believe I haven’t worn it more this year.

Returning to the Apple Watch

A person wearing the Apple Watch Series 8.
Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Over the past year, I’ve worn the Apple Watch Series 8 and the Apple Watch Ultra fairly consistently, whether it’s to review, compare, revisit, or test. But since mid-2023, I’ve reviewed and tested various other smartwatches, so the Apple Watch didn’t get worn as much. When I put it back on in August, I was immediately reminded why it’s always such a joy: It’s absolutely effortless to wear, use, and own in every respect. This is a huge deal, as when a health and fitness product is needy, annoying, or poorly designed, you won’t want to wear it.

I love wearing the Apple Watch. It’s quite astounding that the Apple Watch’s core design hasn’t changed since the very first version was released, proving Apple got it exactly right the first time around. Other, less confident manufacturers constantly play with the shape, design, and fit of their wearables, but not Apple. It has stuck to a broadly similar formula throughout, refining it and improving the underlying technology instead. The Apple Watch Series 8 looks fantastic on my wrist, and with the right band, I barely know it’s there.

Apple Braided Solo Loop in blue.
Apple Braided Solo Loop Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

The band is crucial to the Apple Watch’s success. The quick-release system, although proprietary, is neat and versatile and avoids messing around with fiddly pins when you want to swap bands. It’s done in the blink of an eye, and the complete avoidance of lugs keeps the case compact and comfortable while maximizing screen real estate. It adds something special to the Apple Watch’s almost unique, 100% recognizable design too.

I’ve long paired my Apple Watch Series 8 with a Braided Solo Loop band, which I think is the most comfortable band I’ve ever tried. It’s lightweight, strong, washable, and looks brilliant too. It also lessens the visual impact of the Apple Watch on your wrist. I have no interest in flashy metal bracelets for the Apple Watch Series 8. For me, they ruin its simplicity and try to make it a statement piece. I don’t see it as a statement watch, so dressing it up like one isn’t for me, but it’s another testament to Apple’s design that it can be dressed up if you want.

A person wearing the Apple Watch Series 8, with a Tudor Black Bay on the other wrist.
Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

The Braided Solo Loop is perfect for when I want to wear the Apple Watch with an actual statement watch. It’s probably controversial, but I don’t mind wearing a traditional watch on my left wrist and the Apple Watch on my right wrist. Because the Solo Loop is understated and supremely comfortable, it doesn’t look odd (well, not that odd), and it doesn’t become bothersome when you pair it with another watch. Change the Watch face to an all-digital one, and I get to enjoy my current favorite mechanical watch and still keep “closing my rings.”

What about fitness?

The Apple Watch Series 8 showing a Perfect award for exercise.
Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

The Apple Watch Series 8 is truly functional, and it’s extremely good at almost everything it does. My own smartwatch needs are relatively basic. I want interactive notifications, easy mobile payments, and a way to control my music — plus health and fitness tracking that I can understand and that will motivate me. I also want a selection of cool watch faces, good performance, and the chance to add to all this as my needs change.

All of this is covered without any problem at all. The Apple Watch shrugs it all off when other smartwatches make such a meal out of everything from connectivity to setting up health tracking, when features are disabled due to a desire to maximize battery life for the sake of slapping some big numbers on the promotional material. I find this unacceptable, as not only do I not want to dig through menus to find if a feature is turned on or not, but I shouldn’t have to do it. There are no such concerns with the Apple Watch Series 8.

It auto-tracks workouts without fail, the movement alerts and medals when I meet my goals are fun without being intrusive, and it’s easy to see how I’m progressing towards these goals too. All my notifications are delivered reliably and with the option to interact with them, and I happily switch between the GMT, World Time, Contour, and sometimes the Gradient watch face. A choice of excellent, free watch faces is pretty rare. I’m looking forward to the Snoopy watch face in watchOS 10, a character with a long history of being featured on watches.

Where the Apple Watch fails

Tracking sleep on the Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 Classic.
Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 Classic Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

If I think the Apple Watch Series 8 is so good, does it do anything badly? The battery life isn’t fantastic, and with a single 30-minute workout tracked and no sleep tracking, it still doesn’t last two full days — with the 10% warning coming up in the early evening. Two full working days are possible without a workout or sleep tracking. If you want an Apple Watch with longer battery life, the Apple Watch Ultra is for you, as it will double the time you get from the battery even with activities tracked.

Sleep tracking isn’t good either, and Apple has fallen well behind Samsung here. The Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 and Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 Classic’s new sleep tracking platform is excellent, with masses of detail and even a sleep coaching program if it sees a need to improve. The Apple Watch is more than comfortable and light enough to wear overnight, but there’s little reason to do so, as the data it provides is very basic.

Oura Ring, iPhone 13 Pro, and Apple Watch Series 7.
An Oura Ring next to an iPhone and Apple Watch Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

I get around this by wearing an Oura Ring, which is a superb sleep tracker. I also like the way the Oura Ring reliably links with Apple’s HealthKit, meaning workouts tracked and data gathered through either product appears in the respective apps. This faultless integration, which is so simple to set up, is a big benefit of Apple’s tightly controlled ecosystem. The only downside is it’s an expensive combination.

Finally, in a recent update, Apple decided to activate Siri’s voice guidance when tracking some workouts as standard. It’s a hateful decision, as Siri will yell out some basic stats at various intervals when you’re outside. It happens even if you have the volume on the Watch turned down and you have to dig into the settings to turn Siri off. There’s nothing wrong with the feature (it’s handy for cyclists or headphone wearers, I suppose), but it should be off by default, as it’s pretty embarrassing and easy to forget about until it happens again.

The Apple Watch is the best smartwatch there is

If you own an iPhone and want to buy a smartwatch, you should only be looking at the Apple Watch. You even have a choice that extends beyond case size or color. If the Series 8 isn’t quite hardcore enough, the Apple Watch Ultra will likely fit the bill. If you don’t want an electrocardiogram or an always-on screen, then save some money and buy the Apple Watch SE 2. Regardless of which one you buy, you’re rewarded with the same simplicity, the same broad customization options, and the same frictionless ownership experience.

There are other smartwatches I’ve loved this year, with the Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 Classic coming very close to replicating the Apple Watch’s brilliance for Android, and while it is undeniably more impressive when it comes to health tech, it’s still not quite there with performance, software, or reliability. I also like the Tag Heuer Connected Calibre E4, but I can’t wear that on the opposite wrist to my Tudor Black Bay.

When I put the Apple Watch Series 8 back on recently, I thought to myself that I simply haven’t worn it enough this year. It does everything I could want, with no fuss, and is versatile enough for me to wear on its own and be proud of it, or even treat it almost like a glorified fitness band and wear it with another watch. I am looking forward to seeing the Apple Watch Series 9 along with other products on September 12, but it has a very hard job ahead of it, as it needs to somehow improve on what is the absolute best smartwatch available, despite having been around for a year already.

Editors' Recommendations

Andy Boxall
Senior Mobile Writer
Andy is a Senior Writer at Digital Trends, where he concentrates on mobile technology, a subject he has written about for…
My daughter keeps ruining my Apple Watch, and there’s no way to stop her
Apple Watch laying among some children's toys on a blanket

One of the biggest changes for the Apple Watch was the always-on display, introduced on the Apple Watch Series 5. Sure, later models added more sensors for things like blood oxygen levels and body temperature, but those don’t have quite the same level of impact as the always-on display. In fact, I’m still using my Apple Watch Series 5 and don’t plan to upgrade unless Apple adds a certain feature I’ve been waiting for.

I got my titanium Apple Watch Series 5 when it first came out, which was in 2019. Since then, I’ve gone through one of life’s biggest milestones: I became a first-time mother in late 2021. So far, I’ve endured sleepless nights, loss of privacy around the house, struggling to be on time for things, having to juggle large bags of baby stuff, and — oh yes — lots of dirty diapers. I tell you, it’s been a rough ride, and some days I’m still wondering how I manage to survive.

Read more
Why I never want the Apple Watch to change
The Apple Watch SE 2 on a mans wrist.

A recent report indicated Apple’s next version of watchOS will be a “fairly extensive upgrade” — with changes to the user interface specifically mentioned. It went on to say that, despite these possible alterations to the software, the Apple Watch itself won’t see such significant changes. There may be some people who think this is a bad thing and want to see “new” hardware to keep things exciting, at least in their minds.

I’m in the opposite camp. I never want Apple to change the basic shape and design of the Apple Watch. Here’s why leaving it alone is the very best course of action.
Recognizable and comfortable

Read more
If this Apple Watch Ultra 2 rumor is true, I already don’t want it
The Apple Watch Ultra's raised bezel and Digital Crown guard.

For years, rumors circulated that Apple was working on a more rugged Apple Watch, and in 2022, we finally got it in the form of the Apple Watch Ultra. Simply put, it's one of the best smartwatches you can buy in 2023.

But there’s one caveat that won’t appeal to everyone, aside from the aesthetics: the fact that this is a chonky boi. Yes, the Apple Watch Ultra is the biggest Apple Watch that Apple offers, coming in the form of a large 49mm case size with a 1.93-inch display. And according to the latest Apple Watch Ultra rumor from DigiTimes, the next iteration of it could get about 10% bigger in 2024, which would mean a screen size of about 2.1 inches. Though I’m sure plenty of people are excited about more screen estate on their wrist, I’m not a fan.
What about those of us with small wrists?

Read more