Skip to main content

Here are the bills that could make cell phone unlocking permanently legal

What happens if you illegally unlock your smartphone
Image used with permission by copyright holder

A bipartisan group of senators introduced a bill today that would force wireless providers to let you unlock your cell phone or tablet. This is the second bill introduced this week that addresses the unlocking ban. But unlocking advocates say neither piece of legislation completely solves the problem.

Dubbed the “Wireless Consumer Choice Act,” today’s bill (full text below) was introduced by Sens. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN), Mike Lee (R-UT) and Richard Blumenthal (D-CT). The bill would mandate that the Federal Communications Commission order wireless providers to allow customers to unlock their cell phones and tablets – but only after their service contract has expired.

“Consumers shouldn’t have to fear criminal charges if they want to unlock their cell phones and switch carriers,” said Lee in a statement. “Enhanced competition among wireless services is the surest way to increase consumer welfare.”

Problem is, most wireless carriers already allow customers whose contracts have expired to unlock their devices. According to Sina Khanifar, leader of a growing pro-unlocking movement, the only way to make any substantial difference for consumers is to alter the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), which makes unlocking or any circumvention of digital locks, including DRM on music, movies, and e-books, a federal crime. Without changes to the DMCA, unlocking remains illegal.

“My take on the bill is that, as far as I can tell, it doesn’t do anything at all,” says Khanifar. “It fails to address the DMCA entirely, and it doesn’t seem that it does anything to make unlocking more legal.”

The Library of Congress decided in October to no longer exempt cell phone unlocking from the DMCA, as it had been for the past six years, based on arguments from CTIA, the wireless industry’s primary lobbying group.

In January, Khanifar launched a “We the People” petition on WhiteHouse.gov, which surpassed the 100,000-signature threshold required to elicit a response from the Obama administration. White House senior advisor R. David Edelman issued the Obama administration’s response to Khanifar’s petition on Monday, saying that it was only “common sense” to legalize unlocking, provided you “aren’t bound by a service agreement or other obligation.” FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski backed this position, and said his agency would investigate the issue.

Khanifar and a coalition of unlocking champions, which includes the Electronic Frontier Foundation, Reddit, Mozilla Foundation, YCombinator, iFixit, and others, launched the “Fix the DMCA” campaign on Wednesday. The group hopes to push Congress to alter Section 1201 of the DMCA, which governs the circumvention of digital locks, and lays out maximum punishment for doing so: a $500,000 fine and/or five years in prison, for first-time offenders.

The Wireless Consumer Choice Act is not the only bill on the Senate’s docket. Earlier this week, Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) introduced the “Wireless Device Independence Act of 2013.” While unlocking advocates have their doubts about Wyden’s bill, too, Khanifar says it’s better than the bill that was introduced today.

“Wyden’s bill is better, in that it modifies Section 1201 of the DMCA,” says Khanifar. “But while it permits unlocking for personal use, it doesn’t make it clear that services and software written and sold for that purpose would be legal.”

See the full text of the unlocking bills below:

Wireless Consumer Choice Act full text

Wireless Consumer Choice Act FINAL

Wireless Device Independence Act of 2013 full text

03-05-2013 Wireless Device Independence Act Bill Text

Editors' Recommendations

Andrew Couts
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…
Google Pixel 8: all the latest rumors and what we want to see
Google Pixel 8 leaked render.

The Google Pixel 8 and Pixel 8 Pro are on their way. Google's fallen into a pretty reliable release pattern for Pixel phones, meaning we can safely expect a new lineup of flagship Pixels each year. In 2023, that means the Pixel 8 and 8 Pro.

The Google Pixel 7 and Google Pixel 7 Pro are two excellent devices -- possibly two of the best smartphones Google has ever made. But while they have some serious strengths, several problems and missed opportunities drag both phones down. This wouldn't be a problem if the competition were standing still, but it's not. The Apple iPhone 15 Pro is a beast, and the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra is quite possibly one of the best smartphones ever created. So what's a humble Pixel to do?

Read more
How to track an Android phone, tablet, or smartwatch
Sage green Pixel 6a and Snow Pixel 7a in hand

Losing your smartphone can be an absolute nightmare. Not only does your smartphone have all of your most precious photos, videos, and chats saved on it, but it may have information of a more sensitive nature too (like banking apps). That's a big part of the reason why we all experience that familiar skipped heartbeat when we realize our phone isn't where we expect it to be. Thankfully, there are a number of ways you can keep track of all of your smart devices, whether phones or tablets, and even smartwatches.

Read more
Watch how the iPhone 15 handles the bend test that busted the Pro Max
YouTuber Zack Nelson bending an iPhone 15 to test its strength.

Earlier this week, we reported how popular tech YouTuber Zack Nelson busted the back of an iPhone 15 Pro Max when he subjected it to his bend test.

The back glass shattered with relatively little effort, which came as a great surprise not only to Nelson but to everyone watching, too.

Read more