Skip to main content

The FBI hasn’t stopped its quest to get access to encrypted data

fbi director james comey encryption shutterstock 205595632
Mark Van Scyoc / Shutterstock
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) continued its quest to gain access to encrypted data when FBI director James Comey took to the podium during today’s open session of the U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee, reports Gizmodo.

During the session, Comey pleaded his case that his agency should get “front door” access to encryption technology by having companies give the FBI a solution for accessing messages, files, and other encrypted information. Comey believes there is a way to get such access without compromising the entire system, even though he did not reveal how exactly that might happen.

“Weakening encryption is a lose-lose proposition, which decreases security and privacy. In the wake of recent data breaches, the DOJ should not encourage companies to weaken encryption to provide the government even more access to Americans’ information,” American Civil Liberties Union counsel Neema Singh Guliani told the outlet. “Strong encryption is critical to secure the Internet and protect our information; policies that weaken these technologies diminish cybersecurity, decrease privacy, and threaten the notion of a free and open Internet.”

Regardless, Comey won’t give up on finding a way to access encrypted information without setting the entire system on fire. “I don’t think the great people of America have really put their minds to this,” said Comey. “Maybe it’s impossible. Maybe the scientists are right! But I’m not ready to give up on that.”

In order to prove his point that the FBI needs this access, Comey brought up ISIS’ encrypted messaging, calling it a threat to national security. In addition, he stated how encryption technologies prevented the FBI from investigating how ISIS was bringing Americans into the fold, even though Comey didn’t reveal how many such investigations were thwarted when asked.

This isn’t the first time the FBI painted encryption in a negative light. Last October, Comey lamented how encryption prevented his agency from properly solving crimes, since he argued criminals utilize encrypted messaging services to carry out their crimes. In addition, Comey said that, due to end-to-end encryption becoming a popular practice among big companies such as Apple and Google, lawbreaking will become an easier endeavor.

Fortunately for Comey, he does have allies in Senator John McCain and New York City police commissioner William Bratton, the former of which said that the FBI should ask companies to create a stockpile of encryption keys for the agency. Meanwhile, Bratton revealed his disdain for phone encryption last October, indicating that he too believes it hinders criminal investigations.

From the looks of things, Comey has quite an uphill batte. Apple CEO Tim Cook revealed his company will not give up on iOS encryption, while Google gave encryption default status with Android 5.0 Lollipop.

Editors' Recommendations

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
The FBI still hasn’t cracked the San Bernardino terrorists’ encrypted smartphone
hacker compromises data of nearly 30000 fbi and dhs employees with a simple phone call j edgar hoover building headquarters

There's a reason smartphone encryption is a flashpoint for controversy: in those instances when a secured handset is used to facilitate crime, it sometimes presents a significant roadblock to law enforcement. Two months following the Islamic State-inspired rampage in San Bernardino, California that left 14 people dead, technicians at the Federal Bureau of Investigation have been unable to crack security on a smartphone belonging to the terrorist couple who were responsible.

"We still have one of [the] killers' phones that we haven't been able to open," FBI Director James Comey told the Senate Intelligence Committee on Wednesday. "We are still working on it."

Read more
California anti-encryption bill proposal might force Apple to stop sales on its home turf
apple 2016 first quarter iphone 6s plus review camera

A week after New York state pushed an anti-encryption bill into the hands of the state assembly, California followed suit with its own bill, which could require manufacturers to make smartphones that can be decrypted and unlocked.

Introduced by California assembly member Jim Cooper, the bill is almost a carbon copy of the New York bill. It asks for manufacturers or operating system providers to include a method for unlocking all phones upon request. If the bill passes through both the state assembly and the state senate, all phones manufactured on or after January 1, 2017 would have to have encryption backdoors to be sold legally in California. The law would also penalize the manufacturer with a $2,500 fine for each smartphone that doesn’t abide by the law.

Read more
White House backs away from demanding access to encrypted data
immigration joins digital age white house

The U.S. government is not currently seeking legislation demanding access to users' encrypted data, according to a new report by Reuters. However, White House officials remain in talks with the likes of Google, Apple, and Facebook to prevent "malicious actors" from avoiding detection and threatening national security through the use of closed networks.

"We are actively engaged with private companies to ensure they understand the public safety and national security risks that result from malicious actors’ use of their encrypted products and services," said White House spokesman Mark Stroh, Reuters reports. "However, the administration is not seeking legislation at this time."

Read more