Skip to main content

Can you subpoena a fingerprint? Debate over biometrics in court heats up

It’s not you the judge wants — it’s your fingerprint. That was the message that Paytsar Bkhchadzhyan, the girlfriend of an alleged Armenian gang member, received from a Los Angeles judge, who authorized a search warrant for naught more than her fingerprint.

As biometrics becomes an increasingly critical component of today’s technology, so too are our most unique biological identifiers. The L.A. case represents one of the few times thus far in which a fingerprint has been demanded in connection with court proceedings, but this may soon become a more commonplace occurrence.

Recommended Videos

Some experts are concerned that biometric data and its use in court cases could be a slippery slope. “It isn’t about fingerprints and the biometric readers,” Susan Brenner, a law professor at the University of Dayton, tells the L.A. Times. Rather, she and other experts are worried about “the contents of that phone, much of which will be about her, and a lot of that could be incriminating.” This, Brenner concludes, could be a violation of our Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, though others disagree.

“Unlike disclosing passcodes, you are not compelled to speak or say what’s ‘in your mind’ to law enforcement,” said Albert Gidari, the director of privacy at Stanford Law School’s Center for Internet and Society. “‘Put your finger here’ is not testimonial or self-incriminating.”

The debate reflects a societal shift in our data storage habits. Whereas previously, search warrants were used to enter houses or cars, now, there’s a treasure trove of information to be found in a smartphone. And instead of a key, it’s a fingerprint that stands guard. That said, Apple’s fingerprint sensor (or Touch ID), only works if the phone has been used in the last 48 hours. Once two days of non-activity have passed, or the phone is restarted, it requires a passcode to unlock.

In the recent L.A. case, it was unclear as to why Bkhchadzhyan needed to unlock her mobile device. But one thing is clear — in keeping with recent trends, authorities didn’t need Apple to get inside her iPhone either.

Lulu Chang
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Concert overload? Apple Music’s new feature can help you choose
The Apple Music screen on the Apple iPhone 16 Plus.

It's a good time to have ears because there's a lot of amazing music coming out all the time. Chappell Roan and Sabrina Carpenter are churning out catchy earworms left and right. Old favorites like Linkin Park and Breaking Benjamin are making comebacks. If you've already had to choose between concerts this year, it was probably a tough choice — but Apple Music is introducing a new feature that might help you make your decision.

Apple Music will soon have a tool that musicians can use to create specific playlists based on the setlists of their current shows. If several concerts are happening at the same time, you'll be able to look at the setlist and see what songs are being performed. If one artist is playing your favorite album and the other isn't, well, it's an easy choice.

Read more
You can earn a limited-edition Apple Watch reward on October 10. Here’s how
The Apple Watch Series 10 sitting on top of a green bush.

Earning Apple Watch awards is part of what makes the wearable such a fun way to track your health. This Thursday, and this Thursday only, you have a chance to earn a limited edition badge.

You can earn the Apple Watch digital badge on October 10 in honor of World Mental Health Day. To qualify, record at least ten mindful minutes using any app that contributes data to the Apple Health app on iPhone. You can easily collect the data using an Apple Watch, including the new Apple Watch Series 10.

Read more
How much is Apple Music, and how can you get it for free?
Apple Music on iPhone.

Apple Music has established itself as a formidable player in music streaming, trailing only behind the giant Spotify. Offering a treasure trove of over 100 million songs, handpicked playlists, and exclusive artist content, it’s a paradise for music enthusiasts.

Since its inception in 2015, Apple Music has expanded its vast library and continually enhanced its features, perfectly weaving itself into the rich fabric of the Apple ecosystem to provide an unparalleled listening experience. It’s no wonder it has become a beloved choice for auditory adventurers, standing tall as a fierce competitor among the myriad streaming services available today.

Read more