Skip to main content

Oops: In Lavabit case, Feds forgot to redact ‘’

ladar lavabit snowden
Image used with permission by copyright holder
There was never any official evidence that Edward Snowden was the target when the federal government was investigating Lavabit — but it was obvious, considering it was known that Snowden was using the secure email service in the months following the big reveal on the NSA’s surveillance services.

Lavabit’s owner, Ladar Levison, wasn’t allowed to disclose any information about the case, or he could have faced possible jail time, according to Wired. That information, including identifiers of who the government was targeting, was also redacted in the court documents that were unsealed in 2013.

Updated on 03/18/2017 by Julian Chokkattu: Added in a response from Lavabit’s attorney. 

That time the US government forgot to redact @Snowden old Lavabit email while pretending the case wasn't about him.

— Lorenzo Franceschi-B (@lorenzoFB) March 17, 2016

Lavabit offered encrypted email services. The government demanded that Lavabit provide its private SSL keys, which would give up the data for all its users. Levison shut Lavabit down in defiance. Recently, Levison filed a motion in December of 2015 to have the court documents unsealed, and to remove the gag order that is keeping him silent.

The court denied the motion, but according to Wired, it did order the re-release of unredacted “previously filed pleadings, transcripts, and orders.” Just about the only thing that would still be under wraps is the identity of the government’s target, though the government managed to get other information redacted as well.

But the government screwed up. In those documents relating to the case, which were published on March 4 by federal authorities, the government forgot to redact a crucial identifier of their target — his email. Spotted by Cryptome, “” was left untouched in the court document, and that is more than enough evidence to finally confirm that the government was indeed after Snowden when they approached Lavabit.

Lavabit’s attorney, Jesse Binnall, a partner at Harvey and Binnall, PLLC, still couldn’t say much after the official reveal.

“Our position is that we still can’t talk about it just yet,” Binnall told Digital Trends. “The documents that were unsealed kind of speak for themselves, but we don’t have any other comment about it.”

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
How much is Spotify Premium, and can you get a deal?
An iPhone with the Search section of the Spotify app on it.

Spotify gives you access to an incredible amount of music (more than 100 million songs), podcasts (6 million) and audiobooks (350,000) -- so it's no wonder the music streaming service has become culturally ubiquitous, with well over 239 million subscribers as of 2024. That's more than both Apple Music and Amazon Music.

If you want to get the best of Spotify, you'll want to sign up for a Premium account that, as of June 2024, for new subscribers, costs $12 a month for an individual membership. There are also subscription options for two people (Spotify Premium Duo, $17 a month), families (Spotify Premium Family, $20 a month), and students (Spotify Premium Student, $6 a month).

Read more
The unlocked Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is on sale today
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra in Titanium Gray with S Pen on back.

Smartphones have become a central part of our lives, whether you're just using something basic to make phone calls or something really advanced. If you're the latter, then you'll want to grab one of the best phones on the market, which is currently the Galaxy S24 Ultra if you're an Android user. Of course, aiming for the top means paying a high cost, but luckily, Samsung has a great discount on the S24 Ultra, bringing it down to $1,300 from its original $1,420 price tag, saving you a nice $120 in the process. Plus, you can get up to $750 of trade-in value, although that's only for the latest phones, so realistically expect half of that.

Why you should buy the Galaxy S24 Ultra
There is a lot to love about the Galaxy S24 Ultra, but the biggest new change to the S24 lineup is Galaxy AI, which has a lot of powerful new features. It includes things like live translation for both text and voice, the ability to circle an image and find relevant search terms, and the most powerful and most likely used, AI photo editing that lets you easily alter backgrounds and remove or add things. It's probably one of the most advanced phones that you can find right now, and since the Ultra comes with a massive 6.8-inch Dynamic AMOLED and a stylus, it actually makes it a lot easier to do all these things compared to other phones.

Read more
Here’s the latest phone from a brand you’ve forgotten about
A promotional image of the HTC U24 Pro.

HTC is back. After teasing the announcement of a new smartphone recently, the company — once a titan of the smartphone world — has shown off the HTC U24 Pro, a midrange smartphone with great specifications and at least one unexpected feature to surprise us. Lets see what’s new.

It has a simpler design than the HTC U23 Pro, which was announced this time last year, with a sandblasted rear panel that meets the curved screen at the edge of the case. The camera module's design is reminiscent of the Huawei P20 Pro's, with a dual camera module in the top left and a single third camera set underneath it.

Read more