Skip to main content

NYCLU raises privacy qualms about LinkNYC’s Wi-Fi hotspots

citybridge follows up linknyc program with linkuk
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Turning old phone booths into public Wi-Fi hotspots may seem like a great way to increase connectivity so people don’t have to rely as much on using their data, but the New York Civil Liberties Union’s latest report may have you reconsidering connecting to the free service.

LinkNYC is a project backed by Mayor Bill de Blasio, and it’s primarily being funded and operated by a consortium of companies including Qualcomm, Intersection, and Civiq Smartscapes. The project involves converting phone booths into Wi-Fi hot spots that offer free 24/7 gigabit Wi-Fi with a 150-foot radius, free calls to anywhere in the U.S., a touchscreen tablet interface, a digital display that shows ads and announcements, as well as ports so you can charge your devices (cable not included).

Recommended Videos

“LinkNYC will eventually become a network of as many as 7,500 to 10,000 public kiosks offering fast and free Wi-Fi.”

Please enable Javascript to view this content

The NYCLU says CityBridge, the company behind LinkNYC, “retains vast amount of information about users — often indefinitely — building a massive database that carries a risk of security breaches and unwarranted NYPD surveillance,” in a letter sent to the Mayor’s office.

“LinkNYC, which was publicly launched in January, will eventually become a network of as many as 7,500 to 10,000 public kiosks offering fast and free Wi-Fi throughout all five boroughs,” the NYCLU says in the letter. “The sheer volume of information gathered by this powerful network will create a massive database of information that will present attractive opportunities for hackers and for law enforcement surveillance, and will carry an undue risk of abuse, misuse and unauthorized access.”

CityBridge’s privacy policy for the Link hubs says that by accepting the terms connected to the use of its service, CityBridge will be permitted to monitor information about your visits to websites, information used to facilitate use of its services, and pages viewed or searched for, including page response times, download errors, length of visits to certain pages, and more.

But LinkNYC’s General Manager, Jen Hensley, told Digital Trends that “LinkNYC does not collect or store any data on users’ personal web browsing on their own devices.”

To use its services, you need to sign in with your email address, and after asking for consent, CityBridge will also permit “selected third parties to provide you with information about goods or services that may interest you.”

“Sometimes we supplement technical information we collect from you with information collected by third parties,” according to the privacy policy. “Third parties may include advertising partners or other providers that help us understand our users. We do not collect information about your precise location. However, we know where we provide WiFi services, so when you use the Services we can determine your general location.”

Mayor Bill de Blasio’s office responded to NYCLU’s allegations that CityBridge is retaining vast user data.

“New York City and CityBridge have created customer-first privacy protections to ensure our users’ personal information stays that way — personal,” Natalie Grybauskas, spokesperson for the Mayor, told Digital Trends. “We believe our privacy policy is the best way to protect New Yorkers and LinkNYC users while they safely and securely enjoy free superfast Wi-Fi across the five boroughs. We will continue to work to ensure legitimate concerns are addressed.”

“LinkNYC does not collect or store any data on users’ personal web browsing on their own devices.”

The NYCLU’s letter also raised the issue of whether the NYPD could be requesting access to user data via the LinkNYC hubs, and whether sensors and cameras on the hubs would feed into the NYPD’s systems and the Domain Awareness System. The DAS is a surveillance system designed by Microsoft that tracks targets and gets detailed information from them, and connects to 6,000 cameras in New York City.

But Grybauskas specifically mentioned that cameras and environmental sensors aren’t fed into the Domain Awareness System, and that the NYPD would have to secure a subpoena to acquire this information. The same goes for personal information, as it won’t be shared or sold for third-party use unless it’s ordered by a court or through a subpoena.

Hensley, echoed Grybauskas’ sentiments and said CityBridge would need a subpoena “or similar lawful request” before sharing any data with the NYPD or law enforcement, and once they have, they would “make every effort” to let users know about those requests.

Hensley also referred to the Domain Awareness System, and said that the cameras in the Link hub are “currently inactive and are not designed to feed into any NYPD systems.”

The NYCLU’s letter reminds us of the important point that there’s no such thing as a free lunch.

“New Yorkers’ private online activities shouldn’t be used to create a massive database that’s within the ready grasp of the NYPD,” Donna Lieberman, executive director of the NYCLU, said in the letter. “Free public Wi-Fi can be an invaluable resource for this city, but New Yorkers need to know there are too many strings attached.”

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
This new color for Amazfit’s T-Rex 3 smartwatch looks fantastic
The Amazfit T-Rex 3 smartwatch in Haze Grey.

Amazfit has launched the T-Rex 3 smartwatch in a new color, adding to the two existing hues already available. It’s called Haze Grey, and the case and strap have an off-white, light grey finish, matched to the same metal bezel seen on the other two models. This time, the triangular indicators are in contrasting orange rather than red.

The T-Rex 3 is already a good looking smartwatch, but it’s unquestionably tough, and the Haze Grey color softens it slightly, shifting away from the military-style black color, and what some may see as “rescue” red. It’s a good addition to the range, giving potential buyers a great mix of understated and brighter colors to choose from.

Read more
I tried roaming on Google Fi and T-Mobile, this is the best
i tried roaming on google fi and t mobile vs 2

If you travel abroad frequently, you’ve probably wondered how to cut back on bill shock. We’ve all been there: you have a great vacation, get back home, and your next postpaid bill drops. Except, it’s much higher than you expected thanks to roaming charges for using your phone abroad.

Most networks offer some form of roaming bundle. While Verizon and AT&T offer paid daily bundles that can quickly rack up a bill of more than $100 per line for the month, T-Mobile remains the only of the big three carriers to offer inclusive roaming for free.

Read more
Research suggests cutting down screen time can work better than antidepressants
Person looking at text messages on smartphone.

“Once young people began carrying the entire internet in their pockets, available to them day and night, it altered their daily experiences and developmental pathways across the board,” wrote Jonathan Haidt in an article roughly a year ago.

A co-author of The Anxious Generation, which was on The New York Times (Non-Fiction) best-seller list, Haidt’s article drew divisive remarks soon after it was published. Are we putting too much blame on social media, and the internet? Well, that’s up for debate, but reversing the scenario apparently delivers results we can see and feel.

Read more