Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

’10 Cloverfield Lane’ review

'10 Cloverfield Lane's' monster of a mystery will leave you squirming

10 Cloverfield Lane is a very terrifying, and very satisfying movie experience.

In the scoop-crazy, spoiler-filled minefield of modern movie culture, any time a film can arrive on the scene and surprise us, that’s a pretty big accomplishment.

Not only did 10 Cloverfield Lane seemingly appear out of nowhere back in January, dropping a trailer no one expected for a movie sequel few people even knew was in the works, but now that the film is in theaters, it’s become clear that those weren’t the only surprises the project has in store for curious audiences. Fortunately, like so many of the other projects to come out of JJ Abrams’ Bad Robot Productions, 10 Cloverfield Lane has managed to retain much of its mystery heading into its opening weekend — and audiences would do well to avoid any sort of spoilers this time around.

Reviewing films that rely on a sense of mystery is a tricky dance that critics have performed with some frequency when it comes to the Bad Robot films, beginning with 2008’s Cloverfield and running right through both Star Trek movies and 2011’s Super 8, and most recently with Star Wars: The Force Awakens. However, 10 Cloverfield Lane could very well be the Bad Robot movie that benefits the most from a spoiler-free viewing experience.

Fortunately, it’s also a movie that can be described well in vague — and generally positive — terms.

Directed by Dan Trachtenberg from a script initially penned by Josh Campbell and Matthew Stuecken, then rewritten by Oscar-nominated Whiplash writer/director Damien Chazelle, 10 Cloverfield Lane follows a young woman played by Mary Elizabeth Winstead (Scott Pilgrim vs. the World) who wakes up after a terrible car crash to find herself trapped in an underground bunker with an eccentric doomsday prepper played by John Goodman and a young man played by John Gallagher, Jr. Told that the world outside the bunker has become contaminated after a mysterious, apocalyptic event, Winstead’s character isn’t so sure of the danger on the surface, but must contend with an increasingly tense environment in their shared living space.

Trachtenberg not only lived up to expectations but exceeded them with his first feature.

From a tonal perspective, 10 Cloverfield Lane really does live in the same world as its 2008 predecessor, which chronicled a giant monster’s rampage through New York City through the shaky lens of a survivor’s camera. By keeping the true nature of the monster — human, alien, or otherwise — uncertain, both films keep the tension building as the story unfolds, making the final reveal of the true threat a supremely cathartic experience. In the 2008 film, that catharsis came when audiences finally got a good look at the monster whose arrival made the protagonists’ terrifying ordeal necessary. In Cloverfield Lane, the cathartic moment is different, but no less monstrous.

As Trachtenberg’s feature directorial debut, 10 Cloverfield Lane is the sort of film that should ensure we see more of the filmmaker in the future as studios recognize what he was able to achieve with a relatively low budget. Anyone who’s seen Trachtenberg’s short film Portal: No Escape likely had high hopes for Cloverfield Lane, and it seems safe to say that the filmmaker not only lived up to expectations but exceeded them with his first feature. With much of the film occurring in the bunker, Trachtenberg works the angles well to take the sense of claustrophobia to the next level while also lingering that extra second or two to do the same with the tension between the characters.

10 Cloverfield Lane
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Trachtenberg also benefits from fantastic performances by his cast, particularly Goodman in his role as the gun-toting owner of the bunker, Howard. In a perpetual state of ragged, heavy breathing and entirely unpredictable, Howard is the focal point of every scene he appears in, and Goodman does a nice job of adding layers to the character with subtle elements that make him seem like more than just a caricature of conspiracy theorists and survivalists. Winstead also seems comfortable as the film’s skeptic, playing a role that essentially makes her the audience’s representative in the film; she acts accordingly.

The elephant in the room, however, is the question that can’t — and more importantly, shouldn’t — be answered in a review of the film: How does it connect to Cloverfield, if at all?

What the film does brilliantly is to answer that question in a way that feels satisfying, but leaves plenty of room for audiences to form their own theories. Although it doesn’t shy away from offering hints about a story that’s so much bigger than what’s happening inside the bunker, it leaves the most direct suggestions of a connection between the 2008 film and Cloverfield Lane to the film’s most unreliable source.

And like its predecessor, 10 Cloverfield Lane is not just your typical monster movie — human or otherwise. Thanks to its talented director and cast, it’s so much more than that.

Editors' Recommendations

Rick Marshall
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
10 best Justice League and Justice League Unlimited episodes ever, ranked
The cast of "Justice League Unlimited."

The Justice League cartoon is one of the most ambitious animated projects DC has ever produced. Starting off as one two-season show, it later continued with the sequel series Justice League Unlimited. The cumulative story follows the many, many members of the titular team of superheroes as they defend the world from all kinds of destructive threats.
Despite its being a cartoon marketed towards children, its fantastic storytelling and approach to mature themes have made it a classic, and it's episodes like these ten that stand as a benchmark for all other DC stories.

10. Injustice for All

Read more
The best horror movies on Amazon Prime right now
movies tv shows about the boogeyman need to watch sinister 2012 netflix horror

With the Halloween season upon us, there’s no better time to watch horror movies than the month of October. There’s also no better streaming platform to enjoy all the scary genre flicks with than Amazon Prime Video. Home to many ghoulish titles, Prime Video is a hotbed for terror during this autumnal time of year, to the point where it can be overwhelming when you’re trying to find something to watch. And as we all know, endless scrolling is a fate worse than death (not confirmed, but we bet so), so why not let your friends at Digital Trends curate for you?

Our monthly roundup of Prime Video horror movies is packed with as many sub-genres as possible, from vampires and ghosts to apocalyptic disasters and murderous psychos. We also try and highlight all the latest and greatest titles, while doing our best to honor the classics. So without further ado, here are the best horror movies on Prime Video you can stream right now.

Read more
The 7 best death-defying stunts in movies ever
Men swing from poles while driving cars in the desert.

Stunt work continues to be one of the most impressive and underappreciated aspects of filmmaking. Time and time again, stunt performers perform jaw-dropping feats to entertain an audience. What would action filmmaking be without the stunt performers? It's why Chad Stahelski and Christopher McQuarrie have campaigned for a stunt category at the Academy Awards.

From Buster Keaton and Jackie Chan to Zoë Bell and Tom Cruise, stunt work continues to evolve and improve with the dawn of new technology. To honor stunt work in movies, watch seven of the greatest death-defying stunts below.
Collapsing house - Steamboat Bill, Jr. (1928)
Buster Keaton's famous stunt from Steamboat Bill, Jr. (1928)

Read more