Skip to main content

Boon review: Neo-Western provides action with little payoff

The idea of a “hitman with a heart” is a movie trope that’s been done on countless occasions. Whether it be a futuristic sci-fi adventure like Looper or a neo-noir action thriller like John Wick, hitmen contemplating the duality of man and grappling with their past lives is a successful storyline when done right. Boon is the latest addition to the genre with mixed results.

Directed by Derek Presley (Whitetail), Boon stars Neal McDonough as Nick Boon, a mercenary with a ruthless past working for a crime syndicate. This movie marks McDonough’s second appearance as the titular character following his first outing in 2021’s Red Stone.

On the run from hired killers and a curious federal agent, Boon hides out in the Pacific Northwest, where he eventually meets a widowed pastor, Catherine, played by Christiane Seidel (The Queen’s Gambit), and her teenage son. Catherine is at the mercy of the local criminal kingpin, Mr. Fitzgerald, played by Sons of Anarchy alum Tommy Flanagan, who runs his illegal enterprises on her land. When Catherine and her son run afoul of Fitzgerald and his hired hands, Boon must decide whether to stay quiet or interfere and risk repercussions from the intimidating and violent crime boss.

Neal McDonough stands in front and protects Jake Melrose, and Christiane Seidel in a scene from Boon.

Action reigns supreme

The neo-western film immediately establishes Boon as a highly-skilled and intelligent gunman as he goes toe-to-toe with an assassin following a highway confrontation. McDonough, who also serves as a co-writer and producer, is no stranger to playing the bad guy, as the veteran character actor has been the villain on shows like Yellowstone, Arrow, and Justified. This time around, McDonough plays a complicated antihero, who despite being a religious man, tries to justify his violent actions when protecting a mother and her young son.

Furthermore, Boon is more interested in staging action sequences than developing and fleshing out the rest of its supporting characters, especially its main villain. On one hand, Fitzgerald is set up to be a powerful antagonist who strikes fear into the hearts of the town’s residents. However, his character is all based on reputation and a few nefarious speeches. Not once does he try to inflict physical violence on someone himself, let alone pick up a gun. Suspending disbelief isn’t an option when details like these are missing throughout the script.

BOON Official Trailer (2022)

Pacing issues

For a 95-minute action movie, the pacing is very lethargic, especially after the opening firefight. The driving force behind Boon’s decision to stay in town is to protect Catherine and her son. Yet Catherine withholds the reason why she obeys Fitzgerald and his daughter-in-law, Emilia (Christina Ochoa of Animal Kingdom), for over half of the film. When she finally tells Boon the truth about her past, the reveal is quite underwhelming because of how long it took to get there.

Eventually, the film reaches its inevitable showdown between Boon and Fitzgerald. Strangely, Fitzgerald isn’t even present for this climactic moment, which is a befuddling decision in itself. In addition, the forced storyline with the FBI agent, played by Demetrius Grosse, becomes an integral plot point despite spending little time with the character throughout the film.

Neal McDonough holds a shotgun and points it in a scene from the movie.

Disappointing payoff

The true villain of the film, Emilia, and her henchmen make their way to Catherine’s property for an action-packed shootout in the third act. The ending is predictable, and the final moments elect to set up a future adventure for Boon rather than end definitively. A mid-credits scene tries to tie up a loose end, but it’s an unsatisfying payoff that deserves an entire scene instead of a 30-second clip.

Despite McDonough’s engagingly stoic performance and some decent fight scenes, Boon‘s issues of pacing and character development are too big to overcome to be truly entertaining even on a B-movie level.

Boon will release in theaters and on-demand and digital on April 1, 2022.

Editors' Recommendations

Dark Winds review: A pulpy detective thriller with a stellar cast
Joe Leaphorn stands in the desert in Dark Winds.

If there’s anything that the great detective thrillers of the past have taught us, it’s that setting is everything. In a genre that so often tackles themes of corruption and brutality, it stands to reason that a detective thriller will only ever be as rich and compelling as the place it's set in. It’s for that reason that classic Golden Age noirs like Sunset Blvd. and The Third Man, for instance, make their cities just as integral to their stories as the characters in them — if not more integral.

Dark Winds, AMC’s new pulpy detective thriller, understands this. The series, which is based on the Leaphorn & Chee novels by Tony Hillerman, is set on a Navajo reservation in the early 1970s and goes to great lengths to depict its setting as respectfully and authentically as it can. The series is primarily directed and written by creators of Native American descent, and it stars an impressive cast of Native American actors, including Zahn McClarnon, a performer who has spent the past several decades building a reputation as one of Hollywood’s most dependable and compelling screen actors.

Read more
The Staircase review: A crime drama that loses its footing
Colin Firth and Toni Collette both look up in The Staircase.

The Staircase is a true-crime thriller that does not tell the true story behind the crime at the center of its plot. That’s because the crime in question remains shrouded in mystery. The case’s details continue to plague and nag at the minds of true-crime fanatics everywhere, and forum sites like Reddit are filled with pages dedicated to discussing what might have happened on the fateful 2001 night in which Kathleen Peterson was found dead at the bottom of a staircase in her North Carolina home.

Without an agreed-upon version of what happened on the night Kathleen either tragically died or was brutally killed, The Staircase attempts to tell the twisty true story of the criminal investigation that her death inspired. The show, which is based on Jean-Xavier de Lestrade’s 2004 documentary series of the same name, meticulously dramatizes the scandalous trial that played out after Kathleen’s death, as well as the ways in which it fractured the relationships between her loved ones.

Read more
The Bad Guys review: A clever crime comedy for the whole family
Mr. Wolf and the rest of The Bad Guys look out a car window together.

The Bad Guys is, in many ways, a fairly typical animated family movie. It’s got a group of charming and snarky talking animals, a bright animation style, fast-paced and physics-defying action sequences, and more than a few jokes that will only work on audience members between the ages of 2 and 10. But The Bad Guys is also a crime comedy in the same vein as Ocean’s Eleven, a film that definitely doesn’t qualify as “family-friendly,” if only because it “condones” criminal behavior.

By combining its traditional, kid-friendly elements with a plot that was clearly inspired by several much edgier heist films, The Bad Guys ends up being an unexpected combination of two opposing genres. What’s even more surprising is the fact that The Bad Guys mostly succeeds at creating the same kind of magic found in so many of the crime comedies that its makers obviously admire.

Read more