Skip to main content

British high court denies Hollywood repayment from online piracy

newzbin2Apparently, it’s not as easy to profit from online movie piracy as studio executives once believed. The revelation came after a British high court judge denied an attempt on behalf of a consortium of movie studios to lay claim to profits derived from the illegal distribution of their content.

The court’s refusal to let studios access the money was their first set-back in a legal process that stretches back to March 2010, when they won a ruling that ordered the torrent-indexing website Newzbin2 to remove links to pirated material. A year after that initial case, a second legal decision demanded that British ISPs British Telecom and Sky block access to the site altogether. Together, both cases led to the end of Newzbin2, with the owners of the site complaining that with so much traffic blocked, it became impossible to cover the costs of operation.

In its heyday, Newzbin2 was reported to have around 700,000 users, with one studio executive complaining that “several hundreds of millions of pounds a year” were lost because the site provided easy access to illegally obtained material.

In his ruling, Justice Guy Richard Newey argued Newzbin2 was not necessary liable for the lost profits, likening the site to a landowner upon whose land bootleg DVDs were being sold. “Suppose, say, that a market trader sells infringing DVDs, among other goods, from a stall he has set up on someone else’s land without consent,” Newey wrote. “The owner of the land could not, as I see it, make any proprietary claim to the proceeds of the trading or even the profit from it. There is no evident reason why the owner of the copyright in the DVDs should be in a better position in this respect.”

Newey referred to earlier legal cases in the United Kingdom and Australia for precedent in his decision, ultimately concluding that “it seems to me clear that a copyright owner does not have a proprietary claim to the profits of an infringement of copyright” and noting that if “a person might be deterred from pursuing an activity if he perceived there to be even a small risk that the activity would involve a breach of copyright or other intellectual property rights … that could have a chilling effect on innovation and creativity.”

In response to the ruling, a spokesman for the Motion Picture Association released a statement claiming that action had to be taken against Newzbin2 and the money it made from authorized use of others’ creative works. “We made it clear that we would take further action against the individuals in the hope that the site would close and welcome the fact that this has finally happened,” the statement read. “Intellectual property is a property right that creates value and stimulates investment and growth. Recognition and protection of this right underpins innovation.”

Complaining that Newey’s ruling “does not take the specific facts of this case into account,” the Motion Picture Association plans to seek an appeal against this decision.

Topics
Graeme McMillan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
A transplant from the west coast of Scotland to the west coast of America, Graeme is a freelance writer with a taste for pop…
Everything leaving Max (formerly HBO Max) in October 2023
Eve and Villanelle from Killing Eve both looking shocked.

All good things must come to an end: romances, seasons, even free Twitter (sorry, X), etc. That's never been more true for streaming content libraries. Every month, as more movies and shows are added to each of the many streamers out there, it seems just as much content leaves as well.

Max isn't immune to this vicious cycle, and in October 2023, a fair amount of films and shows are leaving the service for an undetermined amount of time. From a couple of Exorcist movies to the Dolly Parton classic 9 to 5 to the so bad, it's good teen soap Dawson's Creek, there's a lot of good stuff leaving, so check out the list below and try to watch some of these gems before they leave Max for good (or at least a long while).

Read more
The best new shows to stream on Netflix, Hulu, Max (HBO), and more
A man in a suit with his hands up, others pointing guns at him in a scene from The Continental: From the World of John Wick.

This week offers a great example of why having multiple streaming subscriptions is a good idea. Because some of the best new shows to stream are all over the place. If you love action, Peacock's The Continental: From the World of John Wick brings some of that John Wick flavor to TV. Horror fans will naturally gravitate towards the new season of American Horror Story on Hulu. As for comedy fans, Netflix is bringing the laughs with the fourth and final season of Sex Education.

Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, Max, Apple TV+, Disney+, Paramount+, and Peacock will keep you swimming in new shows, especially if you've taken the drastic step of subscribing to all of them. If you want to save some money, go for the cheaper ad-supported tiers. But whichever way you prefer to go, we've got you covered with our weekly roundup of the best new shows to stream.
When you're done here, check out the best new movies to stream this week, as well as the best shows on Netflix, best shows on Hulu, best shows on Amazon Prime Video, and best shows on Disney+.

Read more
The 50 best shows on Netflix in September 2023
The cast of Sex Education.

Not every Netflix original series gets to go out on its own terms, but the hit comedy Sex Education is coming to a proper end this week with the release of the fourth and final season. That's why we're welcoming it back to our roundup of the best shows on Netflix. And it shouldn't be too long before Sex Education is once again one of the 10 most popular shows on Netflix.

This week's other new addition is the fifth season of New Amsterdam, a medical drama that has now come to its conclusion. That makes it the perfect binge-watch after the summer of Suits, as new fans will have a lot of episodes to enjoy.

Read more