Skip to main content

Oscar Effects: The Rise and Fall of San Francisco in ‘Star Trek Into Darkness’

Five films are nominated for an Academy Award in the “Visual Effects” category this year, and they each offer a nice look at the amazing tricks filmmakers and their effects teams can pull off on the big screen. In recognition of these five films and one of our favorite Oscar categories, we’re putting the spotlight on one “Visual Effects” nominee each day leading up to Sunday’s broadcast and taking a closer look at what made them stand out.

Previously, we explored the breathtaking visual magic of outer-space thriller Gravity, the technology that brought a dragon to life in The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, the task of animating an army of automated suits of armor in Iron Man 3, and the trouble with trains in The Lone Ranger. Now we look at the process of building the San Francisco cityscape of 2259 for Star Trek Into Darkness, and the techniques used to bring it crashing to the ground in the film’s final act.

No one can accuse Star Trek Into Darkness director J.J. Abrams of skimping on impressive visuals in last year’s sequel to 2009’s franchise-rebooting Star Trek.

From the film’s very first act, which saw James T. Kirk and the crew of the U.S.S. Enterprise saving a colorful planet from destruction wrought by an overactive volcano, Abrams and the artists of visual effects studio Industrial Light and Magic offer up one fantastic sequence after another that takes the well-known cast of characters from one end of the universe to another. And when they bring the action back to Earth for the film’s explosive finale, the result is a memorable sequence that features a massive starship crashing into downtown San Francisco, reducing large portions of the futuristic city to rubble.

“We wanted to make that feel incredibly dramatic and give the city a real personality, but also make it feel as real as it could”

The last flight of the U.S.S. Vengeance is a fantastic sequence for several reasons, with the first and foremost being the amount of detail that ILM put into both the creation of the San Francisco cityscape in the year 2259 and the city’s destruction.

“It was an enormous undertaking to create all of the architecture in the background and avoid that Flintstones thing of the same building passing by,” said ILM’s visual effects supervisor Roger Guyett in a behind-the-scenes featurette released earlier this year. “We wanted to make that feel incredibly  dramatic and give the city a real personality, but also make it feel as real as it could. I didn’t want to create a future San Francisco that felt almost too conceptual, or shoot in a Los Angeles street and try to turn it into a future version of itself.”

Not content to simply build a Jetsons-style city in the clouds and call it a day, the ILM team designed the San Francisco of 2259 using a mix of urban planning and architectural theory, as well as a healthy dose of forward-thinking. A few local landmarks – like the Transamerica Pyramid – were also included to keep everything rooted in (potential) reality and provide some frame of reference for the scale of the city’s growth over the next two centuries.

It was particularly tricky, according to ILM’s co-visual effects supervisor Pat Tubach, to predict how advancements like flying cars would affect the city and the layout of the landscape and architecture.

ILM Star Trek Into Darkness VFX 009
Here we see Star Trek Into Darkness’s 23rd century San Francisco coming together around the film’s climax. Image used with permission by copyright holder

“To design a future San Francisco was a real challenge,” he said. “One thing that would always change a city dramatically is if you have flying vehicles. You’re going to need ways of entering buildings, you’re going to need different pathways and different mechanisms for how the city functions.”

Speaking to FX Guide, Tubach – a San Francisco resident himself – called the project “a big thrill” for both himself and his local colleagues.

“We’re not just throwing future-tech at something for the sake of doing that, but building the city in a believable way,” he explained. “So this is a city that you recognize and this is a city people live in, and it hasn’t gone so far off the deep end in terms of technology that you can’t believe that this is something that can actually exist.”

The ILM team designed the San Francisco of 2259 using a mix of urban planning and architectural theory.

Coming up with a vision for San Francisco in 2259 would prove to be the easy part, however, as the ILM team was then tasked with creating a fully 3-D model of the city that could be used in both the early scenes occurring around Starfleet Headquarters and the final, explosive sequence that would wreak havoc on the city. The 3-D modeling was especially important for the scenes featuring Spock (Zachary Quinto) and John Harrison (Benedict Cumberbatch) atop a barge as it flies through the city, according to ILM CG Environment Supervisor Barry Williams.

“[The surrounding city] is essentially full 3-D, no cheating at all,” he said of the urban landscape that whizzes by during Spock’s climactic brawl with John Harrison. “[It’s] modeled, textured, everything in that environment.”

The level of detail put into the city made its destruction in the last act of the film that much more devastating, and raised the level of difficulty for the film’s grand finale.

In one of the final major sequences in the film (Spoiler Alert!), the massive U.S.S. Vengeance comes hurtling out of the space on a collision course with Starfleet Headquarters, giving John Harrison one final chance for vengeance on the organization that he believes has wronged him. The black ship manages to take out a chunk of Alcatraz Island just before it makes impact with the city, and the ship’s momentum carries it further, bulldozing skyscrapers and countless other buildings as it skids to a halt.

The destruction in the scene is, put it mildly, pretty intense – and the creating the scene may have been even more so.

“The Vengeance crashes into the ground and we had to simulate that,” explained Karin Cooper, ILM’s CG creature supervisor. “That affects the buildings, so then we have some hero buildings that are set up that the eye gets automatically drawn to, so we simmed those, and then there are all these little buildings we have to sim, and all the debris coming off the dish…”

“There are shots where there are maybe 50 or 60 sim elements,” said compositing supervisor Jay Cooper in a May 2013 interview. “It’s obviously computationally heavy to run those, and even more computationally heavy to run them together, so what you end up having to do is take different pieces of sims and takes and put them altogether.”

It takes a special kind of ship to cause that much chaos.

Along with wrangling all of the resulting debris and other fallout from the crash, ILM’s team also had to account for what the crash would do to a ship like the U.S.S. Vengeance. After all, it takes a special kind of ship to cause that much chaos.

“When the dish [from the U.S.S. Vengeance] crashes into the city it had to make many types of shapes, bending and twisting, and there was a lot of really great simulation from our creature-dev department of it actually bowing,” recalled Bruce Holcomb, ILM’s CG model supervisor. “The flagship was a large sum of data. I think some of the files were around 2Gb, and that’s just the models alone before we even got paint on them.”

The final product of their efforts was an epic, intense sequence that spanned only a short period in the film, but had a lasting effect on both the futuristic version of San Francisco and ILM’s approach to handling these types of sequences in future projects. After all, when it comes to disaster scenes, the more epic the destruction, the greater the testament to the creative talents of the team involved.

(Images © Paramount Pictures)

Check out our coverage of the other nominees

Rick Marshall
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
The best feel-good movies on Netflix right now
A girl stands next to her teacher at a desk.

At the end of a hard day, Netflix is never going to be able to give you the warm hug that you need. That's something A.I. also falls well short on. But what Netflix can offer, that A.I. can't, is a lineup of feel-good movies that serve as a reminder that humanity has more to offer than just our worst instincts. At our very best, we can all provide love, acceptance, friendship, and more.

This month's top selections for the best feel-good movies on Netflix include the original version of Matilda, a sports drama called The Long Game, and Wonder, a film that has a very impressive cast. You can find all of these films and more below.

Read more
Where to watch the 2024 Wimbledon men’s final live stream
Carlos Alcaraz holds a trophy at Wimbledon.

After two weeks of competition, the two best players in the sport are the only ones left standing. In the 2024 Wimbledon men's final, No. 2 Novak Djokovic takes on No. 3 Carlos Alcaraz at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club in London, England. It's a rematch of the 2023 Wimbledon final, where Alcaraz bested Djokovic in five sets, 1-6, 7-6 (8-6), 6-1, 3-6, 6-4.

Alcaraz defeated Daniil Medvedev in the semifinals to reach his fourth Grand Slam final. With the semifinal victory, Alcaraz became the sixth man to reach four Grand Slam finals before his 22nd birthday. Djokovic, the 24-time major champion who defeated Lorenzo Musetti in the semifinals, is attempting to win his eighth Wimbledon title. Djokovic's last Grand Slam title came at the 2023 US Open.
Watch the 2024 Wimbledon men's final live stream on ESPN and ESPN+

Read more
3 BritBox shows you should watch in July 2024
The cast of Suspects.

If you've ever watched a British TV show, you may have gotten an inkling that the British do TV a little bit differently than their American counterparts. While you may at first be confused by their seemingly random premiering schedules, the strange season lengths, and the innovative ways they tell their stories, you'll eventually find much to appreciate in what British TV has to offer.

BritBox is the perfect service for exploring all of that. The streaming service is designed to deliver a package filled with British TV greats to you, but once you've subscribed, you may be even more lost than usual about what's actually worth watching. If you're in that boat, don't worry. We've selected three great shows from the service that are worth checking out this month.
Dunkirk (2004)
Dunkirk - starring Benedict Cumberbatch, Simon Russell Beale - Trailer

Read more