Skip to main content

Box office hits and misses: M. Night Shyamalan scares up an impressive weekend

It was a particularly creepy weekend at the box office, with two scary thrillers making successful debuts. Despite quite a bit of positive buzz going into the weekend, though, M. Night Shyamalan’s The Visit ended up finishing a close second to stalker drama The Perfect Guy.

The two films’ opening weekends were separated by just over $1 million, with director David M. Rosenthal’s The Perfect Guy earning $26.7 million over its three-day premiere and Shyamalan’s The Visit raking in $25.69 million. While the two films earned similar numbers, however, they couldn’t be farther apart from a critical standpoint.

Recommended Videos

Directed by Rosenthal and starring Sanaa Lathan (AVP: Alien vs. Predator), Michael Ealy (Sleeper Cell), and Morris Chestnut (The Best Man Holiday), The Perfect Guy follows a Washington lobbyist (Lathan) whose relationship with a charming stranger (Ealy) goes sour when she discovers he’s a psychopath with an affinity for violence. The film’s evil-boyfriend premise failed to win over critics, and The Perfect Guy currently has a mere 31% approval rating on review aggregator site RottenTomatoes.com.

On the flip side, Shyamalan’s low-budget film about a pair of kids whose visit with their grandparents reveals terrifying (and possibly deadly) secrets about their relatives is being widely regarded as a triumphant return to form for the much-maligned filmmaker. The film features a relatively unknown cast, and has received rave reviews from critics — resulting in a 64% RottenTomatoes.com approval rating as of Monday morning.

With both The Perfect Guy and The Visit made on extremely low budgets ($12 million and $5 million, respectively), the two films are turning a tidy profit already and likely making their studios, cast, and creative teams quite happy.

The weekend’s third-place finisher was the religious-themed War Room, which dropped out of the top spot after two surprisingly successful weekends. The film earned $7.4 million in its third weekend in theaters and continued to reap rewards from its focused, faith-based subject matter to the tune of a $39.1 million return so far on a $3 million budget.

Robert Redford and Nick Nolte’s outdoor adventure-comedy A Walk in the Woods took fourth place for the weekend with $4.7 million, and it was closely followed by Mission: Impossible – Rogue Nation, which added another $4.15 million domestically to its already impressive $612.9 million worldwide earnings so far. Director F. Gary Gray’s acclaimed N.W.A. biopic Straight Outta Compton finished just behind Rogue Nation with $4.09 million in U.S. theaters.

Also earning a spot among the weekend’s top ten films was Owen Wilson’s overseas drama No Escape ($2.87 million) and franchise reboot The Transporter Refueled ($2.7 million), the latter of which has failed to generate the sort of excitement (or more importantly, box-office returns) likely to spawn a sequel at this point.

The two aforementioned films were followed by 90 Minutes in Heaven, a religious-themed drama starring Kate Bosworth and Hayden Christensen. The film’s $2.16 million opening weekend was good enough for ninth place on the weekend, but it failed to generate the sort of buzz that previously propelled the similarly themed War Room to a successful run.

Tenth on the list of the weekend’s highest-grossing films was the Spanish-language animated feature Un Gallo con Muchos Huevos, which dropped off significantly after a huge opening weekend but still earned another $1.9 million, bringing its total haul to just over $6.6 million so far.

The upcoming weekend features the release of several films that have been earning lots of praise in early screenings. First and foremost is Johnny Depp’s potentially Oscar-friendly turn as gangster James “Whitey” Bulger in Black Mass, which will be competing for movie-lovers’ attention with the IMAX-friendly Everest, which is also generating some early Oscar buzz. Also premiering this upcoming weekend is Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials, the sequel to last year’s surprisingly successful post-apocalyptic adventure The Maze Runner, as well as the zombie horror-comedy Cooties, and the gritty, critically praised drug-war drama Sicario.

Rick Marshall
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
The ’90s are alive thanks to the I Know What You Did Last Summer sequel
A group of teens sit in a car and look scared.

The deadly hook from the '90s has made its way to 2025 in I Know What You Did Last Summer.

Sony released the first trailer of the sequel reboot to 1997's teen slasher I Know What You Did Last Summer. The 2025 movie features a similar premise to the original, as five friends attempt to cover up their accidental involvement in a deadly crash. The friends make a pact to bury what happened on that fateful night and remain silent. One year later, someone knows what happened that night and seeks revenge in the deadliest of manners.

Read more
What time does Andor season 2 premiere? Find out when the first 3 episodes stream on Disney+
Diego Luna smirks at someone in Andor season 2.

After a three-year hiatus, the wait for Andor season 2 is nearly over. The first three episodes of Andor season 2 will premiere on Disney+ at 9 p.m. ET/6 p.m. PT on Tuesday, April 22.

Disney+ subscriptions begin at $10 per month for a basic membership with ads. Disney+ Premium costs $16 per month. Under the Disney brand, several bundles are available for purchase that combine multiple streaming services, including Disney+, Hulu, and ESPN+. A bundle that includes all three streaming services starts at $17 per month.

Read more
5 movies leaving Amazon Prime Video in April 2025 you have to watch 
Two men arguing in Michael Clayton.

The great thing about Amazon Prime Video is that there is a wide variety of movies to choose from with your subscription, with new titles being added all the time. However, movies come and go. To help you out, we have a heads-up as to some of the top titles that are leaving the streamer this month.

You’ll want to catch these five movies leaving Amazon Prime Video in April 2025 before they’re gone. Four of them are classics you have probably seen already but will love re-watching. One is a relatively new film with rave reviews, so watch it before it leaves the streamer. 

Read more